Best of the Week
Most Popular
1.Scottish Independence YES Vote Panic - Scotland Committing Suicide and Terminating the UK? - Nadeem_Walayat
2.Independent Scotland Will Disintegrate as Unionist Regions Demand Referendum's to Rejoin UK - Nadeem_Walayat
3.Bank of England Panic! Scottish Independence Bank Run Already Underway! - Nadeem_Walayat
4.Gold and Silver Price Ready To Go BOOM - Austin_Galt
5.Gold and Silver Potential Price Meltdown Scenario - Rambus_Chartology
6.Scottish Independence UK Catastrophe - The Balkanisation of Britain - Video - Nadeem_Walayat
7.The Price Of Gold And The Art Of War Part I - Darryl_R_Schoon
8.Main Reason Why Scotland Will Vote NO to Independence, 70% Probability - Nadeem_Walayat
9.Heavy Gold and Silver Shorting is Bullish - Zeal_LLC
10.10 Year U.S. Treasury Short Best Place to be Remainder of 2014 - EconMatters
Last 5 days
A Public Bank Option for and Independent Scotland - 17th Sept 14
The Charade of Independence for Scotland and UKIP - 17th Sept 14
Gold Report - U.S. National Debt Surges $1 Trillion In Just 12 Months - 17th Sept 14
How to Find Trading Opportunities in ANY Market Using Fibonacci Analysis - 17th Sept 14
Why Money Is Worse Than Debt - 17th Sept 14
Can Gold Price Finally Recover? - 17th Sept 14
Scotland Independence - Europe Holds Its Breath - 17th Sept 14
The Energy Prices at Risk with Scottish Independence - 17th Sept 14
Scottish Independence SNP Lies on NHS, Economy, Debt, Oil and Currency - 17th Sept 14
The Truth Behind the Dangerous "Helicopter Money" Delusion - 16th Sept 14
Central Bank Balance Bullying: Investor Implications - 16th Sept 14
U.S. Dollar and Gold Elliott Wave Projection - 16th Sept 14
The Origins and Implications of the Scottish Referendum - 16th Sept 14
The Collapse Of U.S. Silver Stocks As Public Debt Skyrockets - 16th Sept 14
Emerging Markets Are Set Up for a Crisis, What’s on Your Radar Screen? - 16th Sept 14
Scottish Independence Bank Run Already Underway - Video - 16th Sept 14
The Emergence of the US Petro-Dollar - 16th Sept 14
Economic GDP Drives Stock Prices Inestment Myth - 16th Sept 14
Don't Miss This Gold Buying Opportunity - 16th Sept 14
Why ECB QE Is Bearish For Gold Prices - 15th Sept 14
Property Rights and Property Taxes—and Countries That Don’t Have Them - 15th Sept 14
Junior Miners Breaking Out Higher Forecasting Gold and Silver Price Bottom? - 15th Sept 14
Stock Market Patiently Waiting for Mean Reversion - 15th Sept 14
A Closer Look at the US Dollar - 15th Sept 14
The Silver Price Sentiment Cycle - 15th Sept 14
Stock Market Correction Underway - 15th Sept 14
Marc Faber - “I Want To Be Diversified, I Want To Own Some Gold” - 15th Sept 14
The Myth of Nuclear Weapons - 15th Sept 14
US Dollar Forecast to Go Much Higher - 15th Sept 14
Analysis And Price Projection Of The Uranium Market - 15th Sept 14
Bank of England Panic! Scottish Independence Bank Run Already Underway! - 15th Sept 14
The Ethics of Entrepreneurship and Profit - 14th Sept 14
The Big Investor Opportunity in the Orbital Space Junkyard - 14th Sept 14
Kohl's and The Rest of The Retailers are in Deep Doo Doo - 14th Sept 14
Independent Scotland Will Disintegrate as Unionist Regions Demand Referendum's to Rejoin UK - 14th Sept 14
Stock Market Pullback Continues - 13th Sept 14
SNP Fanatics Warn of Day of Reckoning for Scottish Independence No Campaigners - 13th Sept 14
Scottish Independence Would Shake Up the Global System - 13th Sept 14
The World Order Becomes Disorder - 13th Sept 14
Is Geothermal Power About to Become The Next Great Battleground Over Fracking? - 12th Sept 14
Heavy Gold and Silver Shorting is Bullish - 12th Sept 14
Strong U.S. Dollar Undermines Gold and Silver - 12th Sept 14
Debt And The Decline Of Money - 12th Sept 14
Panic On The Streets Of London ... Can Scotland Ever Be The Same Again? - 12th Sept 14
Will The Real Silver Commercials Stand Up? - 12th Sept 14
If You Own Only One Investment, Make Sure This Is It - 12th Sept 14
Main Reason Why Scotland Will Vote NO to Independence, 70% Probability - 12th Sept 14
Better Days Ahead For U.S. Stock And Housing Market - 12th Sept 14
U.S. Meddling Dims Prospects for Ukraine Peace - 12th Sept 14
Is the Fed Preparing to Asset-Strip Local Governments? - 12th Sept 14
China Holds “Gold Congress” - Positioning Itself As Global Gold Hub - 11th Sept 14
Fire Ice Could be Energy's Magic Bullet or a Planet-killing Catastrophe - 11th Sept 14
The Mass Psychosis Of 9 /11 Will Never Be Healed - 11th Sept 14
Radical Islam's Crisis of Competing Caliphates - 11th Sept 14
Ukraine Crisis And Self-Determination - 11th Sept 14
Cameron and Miliband Desperately Attempt to Prevent Scotland Committing Suicide - 11th Sept 14
A Supply Crunch Points to Higher Uranium Prices - 11th Sept 14
The Myanmar Shadow - 11th Sept 14
Europe Takes the QE Baton - 11th Sept 14
Full Frontal Inflation - 11th Sept 14

Free Instant Analysis

Free Instant Technical Analysis


Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Huge Stocks Bear Market

Plausible Gulf Oil Spill Scenario: Underground Blowout and Mudflow

Politics / Environmental Issues Jul 27, 2010 - 03:49 AM GMT

By: Dian_L_Chu

Politics

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleAmid rising fears over a circulating story about a leak and seepage, the federal government's oil spill chief said that seepage detected two miles from BP's oil cap is coming from another well. Meanwhile, BP is on track to use static top kill procedure in Macondo.


The static kill option is basically the cousin of the previously failed top kill. According to Platts, “the static kill would pump drilling mud and cement into the well, using the same entry points as the previous top kill procedure. The materials would be forced into the choke and kill lines of the well's blowout preventer (BOP).”

Scenario Apocalypse?

Although BP's new containment cap has stopped the flow of oil, circulating stories about a leak and seepage had caused mounting concern that the cap was displacing pressure and causing leaks deep underground.

One oil industry veteran engineer describes to me an underwater blowout (UGBO) as quite plausible, with the well being capped plus the static kill adding pressure from the top.

That is, capping the well might not be such good news.

The more they try to restrict the oil gush, the more pressure could be built up within the wellbore (like a soda can.) The increasing pressure could eventually push the leak below leading to a UGBO. (See graph)


(Note: The graph is a general illustration and does not represent the BP Macondo well.
Source: http://www.silentpcreview.com/)

What Is A UGBO?

According to Schlumberger Oilfield Glossary and Wikipedia:

“An underground blowout is a special situation where the uncontrolled fluid flows from one reservoir into the wellbore, along the wellbore, and into another reservoir. Usually this is from deeper higher pressure zones to shallower lower pressure formations.”

“Underground blowouts can be very difficult to bring under control, and are historically the most expensive problem in the drilling arena. If left unchecked the fluids may find their way to the surface or ocean floor nearby.”

While there are sporadic discussions around a possible UGBO at Macondo well, it is still hard to visualize what kind of damage it could actually bring. A look at the ongoing mudflow environmental disaster in Indonesia could shed some light.

Indonesia Mudflow

The Sidoarjo mudflow in east Java, Indonesia has been ongoing since May 2006. The mud volcano was created by the blowout of an exploration well drilled by PT Lapindo Brantas, which triggered the eruption of hot mud.

The hot mud has continued to spew out at a rate of 100,000 cubic meters a day--equivalent to the contents of forty Olympic-size swimming pools--despite government efforts to plug the leak.

News reports described the mud lake is so huge — seven square kilometers in area and 20 meters deep — that it is now visible from space. Experts have warned that the mud may continue to flow for several decades.

Since 2006, the mudflow ha s inundated hundreds of hectares while new mudflows are still opening up. Some 50,000 Indonesians reportedly have been displaced after the drilling accident in May 2006.

Mudflow in the Gulf?

In the case of the Macondo well, a UGBO could cause a seismic shift of the seafloor, and a potential astronomical increase of oil shooting to the sea surface of the Gulf, and flowing towards coastline. The seabed breach could also bring about a mud volcano and mudflow, similar to what happened in Indonesia, in the Gulf of Mexico deepwater, possibly for decades.

In fact, this is the very same doomsday scenario many scientists and geologists have feared, as there are some early signs of a typical UGBO such as the reported seepage and leak. That is why BP and the U.S. government have been feverishly analyzing underwater data and monitoring the pressure.

This one oil industry expert I talked to believes that with the failure of the first top kill, and the risk of UGBO, the more prudent course is to just drill the two relief wells as planned (see graph), instead of further risking the well integrity by the trying experimental well cap and another static kill.

Inaction Is Good …., Occasionally?

While this apocalyptic scenario seems beyond the imaginable, and there does not seem to be a previously documented case of a deepwater UGBO, but again, everything regarding this gulf disaster has been unprecedented.

I imagine all the experts in BP’s camp are quite aware that the risk of an UGBO is quite high, but with mounting public criticism towards BP and the Administration, any cautionary (i.e., non-action) note most likely will not be taken into serious consideration by the people in charge.

Crucial - Implementing Lessons learned

There are plenty of lessons learned and yet to be acted upon for the spill response and remedial side of the oilfield technology to catch up with the technology on the drilling and production side. The new rapid response system for the Gulf deepwater announced by the four oil majors--Chevron, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil and Shell-- seems to be a good start towards that direction.

Meanwhile, let’s hope a deepwater UGBO remains as a scenario-based discussion only.

(Many thanks to the silent co-contributor of this article.)

Dian L. Chu, M.B.A., C.P.M. and Chartered Economist, is a market analyst and financial writer regularly contributing to Seeking Alpha, Zero Hedge, and other major investment websites. Ms. Chu has been syndicated to Reuters, USA Today, NPR, and BusinessWeek. She blogs at Economic Forecasts & Opinions.

© 2010 Copyright Dian L. Chu - All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.


© 2005-2014 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

Free Report - Financial Markets 2014