Best of the Week
Most Popular
1.Gold Price Target of USD 2,300 - GoldCore
2.Greece Banking System Collapse Monday as ECB Pulls the Plug, Capital Controls Ahead of GrExit - Nadeem_Walayat
3.Why British Muslims Are Leaving Elysium Paradise for Syrian Hell - Nadeem_Walayat
4.Greece BANKRUPT! Financial and Economic Collapse to Follow IMF Debt Default - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Extreme Gold/Silver Shorting - Zeal_LLC
6.European Empire Strikes Back Against Greek Debt Fantasy, Counting Down to GREXIT - Nadeem_Walayat
7.Gold And Silver – Three Choices: Sell, Hold, Hold and Add. A Trading Treatise - Michael_Noonan
8.Gold and Silver Price Headed for Breakdown - Jordan_Roy_Byrne
9.Greece Crisis OXI - Raul_I_Meijer
10.Flatline Investing and Dead End Debt Schemes - Doug_Wakefield
Last 5 days
Syriza Convinces Greece to Commit Suicide, GrExit Beckons, Market Reaction - 6th July 15
Financial and Commodity Markets Become Scary: Crash Point Or Turning Point - 5th July 15
A Revolutionary Pope Calls for Rethinking the Outdated Criteria That Rule the World - 5th July 15
Forget 'Haircut', Instead Syriza Plans Beheading of Greek Bank Depositors, Theft of Deposits - 5th July 15
The Pentagon’s 2015 Strategy For Ruling the World Through Endless War - 5th July 15
United States Celebrates the Disastrous Secession From Great Britain - 5th July 15
Greece Referendum Vote Result Forecast Yes Win, But Depression Will Continue - 5th July 15
The Great Greek Economic Depression - 4th July 15
Happy 4th of July Stock Market Analysis - 4th July 15
The Most Pressing Reason Yet You Want to Avoid Investing in Retail Stocks - 4th July 15
Fed’s Full Normalization and the Stock Market - 3rd July 15
The U.S. Dollar's 2014-2015 Rally: Wave 3 in Action - 3rd July 15
Stock Market Where are we? And where are we Going? - 3rd July 15
Xi’s Anti-Corruption Campaign Is Key to China’s Prospects - 3rd July 15
How the New Iranian Nuclear Deal Will Impact Crude Oil - 3rd July 15
China's Stock Market Rollercoaster Ride Continues - 3rd July 15
Gold Stocks Cheap to Buy but Not for Long - 3rd July 15
Capital Controls and a Bank Holiday in Greece… Here’s How You Can Profit - 3rd July 15
Greece's Varoufakis: I will Resign if there's a 'Yes' Vote - 2nd July 15
The Student Loan Bubble: Gambling with America’s Future - 2nd July 15
Inflation Is Lurking, but This Asset Can Protect You - 2nd July 15
Three Total Wealth Stock Investor Tactics You’ll Need Because Greece Isn’t Over - 2nd July 15
Why This $5.6 Trillion Investor Profit Boom Is Set To Take Off - 2nd July 15
Greek Debt Crisis: "Too late to prepare now" - Video - 2nd July 15
Guaranteed US Dollar Death Dynamics - 2nd July 15
The Greek Stress Test & The Reality Of Incremental Changes - 2nd July 15
Forget Drachmas Greece Syriza Government Could Instruct Central Bank to Print Euros! - 2nd July 15
Greece Debt Crisis Trigger for Stock Market Crash or Bull Rally? Video - 1st July 15
Gold Stocks Break Below 2008 Low - 1st July 15
SPX Stock Market Retracement May be Over - 1st July 15
Silver Tunnel Vision 'Experts' - 1st July 15
Gold And Silver - Monthly, Quarterly Ending Analysis - 1st July 15
Europe’s Controlled Demolition - 1st July 15
The End of Dow 18,000; Bailouts No Longer Extended  - 1st July 15
Athens Mayor: Greek Government Should Resign - 1st July 15
China Stocks - This Is What a Bubble Looks Like - 30th June 15
Stocks Plunge on Greece Euro-Zone Financial Armageddon Blackmail - 30th June 15
Greece Crisis Shows Importance of Gold as Europeans Buy Coins and Bars - 30th June 15
Stock Investors Express Route to Profits in the Healthcare Sector - 30th June 15
Beyond the Greek Impasse - 30th June 15
Gold GDXJ : Impulse Move Pending - 30th June 15
Fed Interest Rate Increase Could Be Best Thing to Happen to Gold - 30th June 15
Marc Faber - Greece is Basically Bankrupt - 30th June 15

Free Instant Analysis

Free Instant Technical Analysis


Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

China Stocks - Where are they going?

IMF Economists Say The Economic Recovery Is A Fake

Economics / Economic Recovery Jul 20, 2013 - 10:04 AM GMT

By: Andrew_McKillop

Economics

WE ALWAYS BELIEVE THE IMF
Yet another 'leaked report' this time tells us something we have suspected for a long time – not only concerning the IMF's underhand “plausible denial” way of communicating bad news. The story starts with an internal IMF report called 'confidential' which was 'leaked to a Wall St Journal contributor'. This is now standard practice for the IMF, growing rapidly, and easy to trace back to its handling, or mishandling of European bailouts starting with Greece. One example is this report http://online.wsj.com...?  where the IMF 'concedes it made mistakes'. Original leakage of this report generated a mini-crisis among EU27 finance ministers, including harsh words from Economics Commissioner Olli Rehn.


The basic cause of dispute is always traceable to two things: the IMF's bad habit of overestimating economic 'recovery', and who pays what for the next or present bailout?

The present leaked report is technical and concerns seemingly-complex fiscal matters, but soon gets to the meat. This time the IMF starts with it's own economists' recognition they made a terrible mistake with their forecasts of the Greek economy 'bouncing back' . They forecast that forced reduction in Greek deficits would lead to 'only' a 5.5% reduction in the size of the Greek economy. But rather soon they were horrified to discover this was a preposterous claim and had to admit that Greek GDP has already suffered – the right word – a contraction of close to 18%.

Ergo, Greece will need more money as its economy contracts further and faster, as its skilled persons and its young people flee the country – told by the government to do so.

MUCH MORE DRAMATIC IMPLICATIONS FOR THE US
Daniel Amerman writing in 'Financialsense' 11 July points out that the latest IMF leak is not only damagingly truthful, or truthfully damaging about Europe's economic meltdown, but is at least as damaging for the USA. In fact more so.

As the IMF report says, not exactly in these words, since late 2008 a substantial chunk of the US economy has become "artificial". Another term we could use is “virtualized”. In brief, as the leaked report says, the USA's private sector basically imploded and has not recovered to this day.

Both IMF and national government statistics have either lied about, or miscalculated the economic impact of “fiscal tightening” or the reduction of government spending – or projected reduction as in the case of the US and most other OECD countries. The merest glance at the absurdly manipulated financial markets of today will show their present all-time highs obviously do not relate to the shrunken, downsized and dysfunctional real economy on which these markets squat. Since 2008, the “damage containment” operated in the US, Europe, Japan and other countries, which propels financial markets to literally uncharted highs,  is dependent on running unsustainable government deficits.

None of these governments have the ability to pay down their snowballing debt, under ordinary circumstances. The Catch 22 is they have to pay it back.

As this present 'leaked IMF report' rather clearly says, the constant growth of government control and siphoning of national economic wealth in the USA, exactly as elsewhere, a process that has grown for decades but has exploded since 2008, has created an unrecognizable economy. The IMF's economists used the poetic word “transformed”. More particularly for the US economy, long-gone are the days when the US could lecture to Europeans and Japanese about “bloated government”, pointing out that in 2007 the share of Federal and State government spending in the US was only about 35% of GDP.

Something happened at the height of the financial crisis of 2008. The USA's private economy imploded by $1.3 trillion-per-year according to IMF economists. The crash was so intense it was at least as large as the 1929-31 sequence relative to GDP. However, US government statistics disguise (or lie about) the event to this day. They claim a $300 billion contraction, ironed out by bailouts and QE and nice speeches by Obama, terminating at latest in June 2009.

The accounting trick, or fake statistics – take your pick – was the $1 trillion increase in government spending. Per year.

From the previous 35%/65% split of government/private enterprise activity and spending in GDP, in 2007, the US leapt to a 43%/57% split. According to the IMF that remains the situation since 2009. This makes it obligatory to “re-interpret” the US economy and the claimed post-2009 recovery. This has more than a few implications for what happens next – as the leaked IMF report suggest and hints in its own coded language.

FISCAL FEEDBACK LOOP OR RATCHET
What happened in Greece in fact happened everywhere, from 2008. The only difference was the scale and the speed with which “fiscal feedback” operated, negatively, on the real economy.

The situation is extreme in Greece as a bookshelf of IMF reports, leaked or not, will show. As a direct consequence the so-called “austerity trap” was sure and certain to trigger – although the IMF actually had the gall to pretend this was not sure and certain. Also, Greece already had an oversized and over-fattened government sector, meaning the economic damage associated with reducing government spending - while increasing income and VA taxes - was so great that it could only swallow the enhanced revenues that were expected. The economy could only implode.

The IMF for its own reasons, including ideological, blithely imagined that when all the beneficiaries of government spending, including large numbers of “grey zone” semi-governmental and part-state enterprises and activities lost their income, they would somehow not stop spending and to an extent would go on paying taxes. The economists believed the contraction would be on a roughly one-for-one basis, that a 1% cut in government spending, for a country where say 50% of GDP is government spending, will only cause an 0.5% reduction in total spending. They did not include “multipliers”, that is positive feedback – intensifying the cause of the slowdown.

Overall, as shown dramatically in Greece, reduced employment further shrinks the economy causing more unemployment, less tax payments and bigger government deficits -- a perfect “reverse multiplier” to the claimed Keynesian-type multiplier where increased government spending is manna from heaven. The Greek economy contracted three times faster than the IMF's economists thought it would. Unemployment spiraled. Future growth can only be weak in a long-term crippled economy.

Daniel Amerman is a professional accountant, therefore able to closely analyze, and contradict the basic excuse used by US political deciders since 2008. The excuse is also used by the IMF. It pretends or claims that “before and after” conditions and performance of the economy are symmetrical – or remediable – by reducing government deficits and “restoring the economy” to its previous status. This can be summarized as calling the fiscal multiplier 1, meaning that in the US case, if government spending was reduced as a percentage of GDP to the pre-2008 level, there would only be a proportionate reduction of the size of GDP and a proportionate increase in unemployment rates.

There would not be a “Greek type implosion” due to multipliers. Amerman contests this “benign” or delusionary belief.

He argues that if the United States government were in fact to abandon its "artificial" economy and return to spending only its revenues, mostly from taxes, the much-higher-than-1 real fiscal multiplier would trigger.  By his calculations of what would happen, in an event which could be forced on the US, not politically decided because it is “politically impossible”, there could easily be an 8% to 10% contraction of US GDP. Unemployment would at minimum soar to 25%.

UNREAL ECONOMIC FUTURE
The fiscal multiplier under any hypothesis is far above 1. That is, economies of the developed world which have had a sometimes-insidious but always permanent real growth of the government sector as a part of GDP – for decades – will be exposed to “unexpectedly sharp” economic contraction anytime they try to backtrack on government spending.  Calling the multiplier a “ratchet” is more accurate because a decrease in government spending will have an unsymmetrical and stronger depressive effect, than the growth effect a same-percentage increase in government spending will have. Putting this yet another way, the economy becomes addicted to government spending – based on borrowing – and cannot adapt to the withdrawal pain, if state spending is cut.
 
Denying this “inconvenient truth” is the game of the IMF and the political and economic deciders of all the developed countries. This is another reason we are in uncharted waters.

At least as important, as Amerman also says, the coming forced reduction of government spending will truly be The Great Experiment. As we know, there is plenty of talk about reducing government spending – but when it actually happens as in Greece it produces dramatic and scary results. Greece is now truly in 1930s-style Great Depression territory, but uncharted because of the way it was thrown into economic meltdown. We literally do not know what will happen next, because so much of the economy is “virtualized”. We do not know if the “before situation” can be restored.

We can however use real world data from Greece, like the IMF's economists. This data underlines one important, possibly the most important point - that the Greek economy has been “transformed”, to use IMF jargon, but not for the better. For several months now, it is clear that its economy is in a type of void, where the role of government spending, at one and the same time, has to stop and cannot stop.

Amerman says exactly the same would happen to the US, or will happen to the US if it has to cut quickly. Basically, the only difference between Greece and the US is the second country is 30 times bigger. The probable fiscal multiplier-ratchet, in the US, is the same as the Greek one. Brave talk about QE Tapering is almost certainly talk – and not on the menu at all in Europe – because it firstly finances US government debt, long before any other claimed Keynesian miracles also produced by QE. Amerman concludes with a suggestion that the US might “limp through”, without collapse when (or if) government spending is reined in, but above all we are in uncharted waters, because a huge part of the economy is now “virtual”.

By Andrew McKillop

Contact: xtran9@gmail.com

Former chief policy analyst, Division A Policy, DG XVII Energy, European Commission. Andrew McKillop Biographic Highlights

Co-author 'The Doomsday Machine', Palgrave Macmillan USA, 2012

Andrew McKillop has more than 30 years experience in the energy, economic and finance domains. Trained at London UK’s University College, he has had specially long experience of energy policy, project administration and the development and financing of alternate energy. This included his role of in-house Expert on Policy and Programming at the DG XVII-Energy of the European Commission, Director of Information of the OAPEC technology transfer subsidiary, AREC and researcher for UN agencies including the ILO.

© 2013 Copyright Andrew McKillop - All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisor.

Andrew McKillop Archive

© 2005-2015 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

Biggest Debt Bomb in History