Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. TESLA! Cathy Wood ARK Funds Bubble BURSTS! - 12th May 21
2.Stock Market Entering Early Summer Correction Trend Forecast - 10th May 21
3.GOLD GDX, HUI Stocks - Will Paradise Turn into a Dystopia? - 11th May 21
4.Crypto Bubble Bursts! Nicehash Suspends Coinbase Withdrawals, Bitcoin, Ethereum Bear Market Begins - 16th May 21
5.Crypto Bubble BURSTS! BTC, ETH, XRP CRASH! NiceHash Seizes Funds on Account Halting ALL Withdrawals! - 19th May 21
6.Cathy Wood Ark Invest Funds Bubble BURSTS! ARKK, ARKG, Tesla Entering Severe Bear Market - 13th May 21
7.Stock Market - Should You Be In Cash Right Now? - 17th May 21
8.Gold to Benefit from Mounting US Debt Pile - 14th May 21
9.Coronavius Covid-19 in Italy in August 2019! - 13th May 21
10.How to Invest in HIGH RISK Tech Stocks for 2021 and Beyond - Part 2 of 2 - 18th May 21
Last 7 days
Investing in the Tulip Crypto Mania 2021 - 19th Jun 21
Here’s Why Historic US Housing Market Boom Can Continue - 19th Jun 21
Cryptos: What the "Bizarre" World of Non-Fungible Tokens May Be Signaling - 19th Jun 21
Hyperinflationary Expectations: Reflections on Cryptocurrency and the Markets - 19th Jun 21
Gold Prices Investors beat Central Banks and Jewelry, as having the most Impact - 18th Jun 21
Has the Dust Settled After Fed Day? Not Just Yet - 18th Jun 21
Gold Asks: Will the Economic Boom Continue? - 18th Jun 21
STABLE COINS PONZI Crypto SCAM WARNING! Iron Titan CRASH to ZERO! Exit USDT While You Can! - 18th Jun 21
FOMC Surprise Takeaways - 18th Jun 21
Youtube Upload Stuck at 0% QUICK FIXES Solutions Tutorial - 18th Jun 21
AI Stock Buying Levels, Ratings, Valuations Video - 18th Jun 21
AI Stock Buying Levels, Ratings, Valuations and Trend Analysis into Market Correction - 17th Jun 21
Stocks, Gold, Silver Markets Inflation Tipping Point - 17th Jun 21
Letting Yourself Relax with Activities That You Might Not Have Considered - 17th Jun 21
RAMPANT MONEY PRINTING INFLATION BIG PICTURE! - 16th Jun 21
The Federal Reserve and Inflation - 16th Jun 21
Inflation Soars 5%! Will Gold Skyrocket? - 16th Jun 21
Stock Market Sentiment Speaks: Inflation Is For Fools - 16th Jun 21
Four News Events That Could Drive Gold Bullion Demand - 16th Jun 21
5 ways that crypto is changing the face of online casinos - 16th Jun 21
Transitory Inflation Debate - 15th Jun 21
USDX: The Cleanest Shirt Among the Dirty Laundry - 15th Jun 21
Inflation and Stock Market SPX Record Highs. PPI, FOMC Meeting in Focus - 15th Jun 21
Stock Market SPX 4310 Right Around the Corner! - 15th Jun 21
AI Stocks Strength vs Weakness - Why Selling Google or Facebook is a Big Mistake! - 14th Jun 21
The Bitcoin Crime Wave Hits - 14th Jun 21
Gold Time for Consolidation and Lower Volatility - 14th Jun 21
More Banks & Investors Are NOT Believing Fed Propaganda - 14th Jun 21
Market Inflation Bets – Squaring or Not - 14th Jun 21
Is Gold Really an Inflation Hedge? - 14th Jun 21
The FED Holds the Market. How Long Will It Last? - 14th Jun 21
Coinbase vs Binance for Bitcoin, Ethereum Crypto Trading & Investing During Bear Market 2021 - 11th Jun 21
Gold Price $4000 – Insurance, A Hedge, An Investment - 11th Jun 21
What Drives Gold Prices? (Don't Say "the Fed!") - 11th Jun 21
Why You Need to Buy and Hold Gold Now - 11th Jun 21
Big Pharma Is Back! Biotech Skyrockets On Biogen’s New Alzheimer Drug Approval - 11th Jun 21
Top 5 AI Tech Stocks Trend Analysis, Buying Levels, Ratings and Valuations - 10th Jun 21
Gold’s Inflation Utility - 10th Jun 21
The Fuel Of The Future That’s 9 Times More Efficient Than Lithium - 10th Jun 21
Challenges facing the law industry in 2021 - 10th Jun 21
SELL USDT Tether Before Ponzi Scheme Implodes Triggering 90% Bitcoin CRASH in Cryptos Lehman Bros - 9th Jun 21
Stock Market Sentiment Speaks: Prepare For Volatility - 9th Jun 21
Gold Mining Stocks: Which Door Will Investors Choose? - 9th Jun 21
Fed ‘Taper’ Talk Is Back: Will a Tantrum Follow? - 9th Jun 21
Scientists Discover New Renewable Fuel 3 Times More Powerful Than Gasoline - 9th Jun 21
How do I Choose an Online Trading Broker? - 9th Jun 21
Fed’s Tools are Broken - 8th Jun 21
Stock Market Approaching an Intermediate peak! - 8th Jun 21
Could This Household Chemical Become The Superfuel Of The Future? - 8th Jun 21
The Return of Inflation. Can Gold Withstand the Dark Side? - 7th Jun 21
Why "Trouble is Brewing" for the U.S. Housing Market - 7th Jun 21
Stock Market Volatility Crash Course (VIX vs VVIX) – Learn How to Profit From Volatility - 7th Jun 21
Computer Vision Is Like Investing in the Internet in the ‘90s - 7th Jun 21
MAPLINS - Sheffield Down Memory Lane, Before the Shop Closed its Doors for the Last Time - 7th Jun 21
Wire Brush vs Block Paving Driveway Weeds - How Much Work, Nest Way to Kill Weeds? - 7th Jun 21
When Markets Get Scared and Reverse - 7th Jun 21
Is A New Superfuel About To Take Over Energy Markets? - 7th Jun 21

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Protect your Wealth by Investing in AI Tech Stocks

Why Austrailia's Trade Unions Sponsored Work Study is Worthless

Politics / Austrailia Dec 11, 2007 - 01:53 PM GMT

By: Gerard_Jackson

Politics The aim of Buchanan and Woonay's Australia at Work study is to persuade people that free labour markets drive down real wage rates because labour lacks the power to defend itself against capitalists. Yet every single critic of this so-called study missed this vital point. What we got were conservative economic illiterates like Janet Albrechtsen, Andrew Bolt and Imre Saluszinsky (all of whom are from the Murdoch stable) engaging in ad hominem attacks instead of dealing with Buchanan and Woonroy's underlying assumption that free labour markets are exploitive.


However, Harry Clark, an economist, adopted the honest approach and tried to deal with the report on its own grounds. Alex Robson and Sinclair Davidson (both of whom are economists) took a similar line, exposing some of the study's damning contradictions and omissions.

Every time I write about labour markets a I stress that in a free market there is a tendency for every factor of production to receive the full value of its marginal product — particularly labour. Not only are Buchanan and Woonay denying this, our three economists never even referred to it. However, one of Clark's asinine readers did assert that workers cannot be paid "their marginal product" because it cannot be calculated. This is the kind of economic illiteracy that supporters of free markets continually face from the left.

Let me be abundantly clear on this point: employers do not need to calculate the marginal product because the miracle of the market place does the processing for them. Anyone with even a basic grasp of marginal productivity theory would know this. In his brilliant breakthrough on capital and marginal productivity Mountifort Longfield gave a detailed explanation of this process. (Lectures on Political Economy, Richard Milliken and Son 1834, Ch. IX). Paul Samuelson's Economics, the standard economics textbook for several decades, also detailed the process. (Tenth edition, McGraw-Hill, 1976, pp. 541-47). A particularly interesting exposition was provided by Fritz Machlup in Theories of Decision-Making in Economic and Behavioral Science. (Micro-Economics: Selected Readings, edited by Edwin Mansfield, 2nd edition, W. W. Norton & Co. Inc., 1975).

When I stated in a previous article (Rightwing columnists stuff up labour market reform debate) that the Buchanan and Woonay study was deeply flawed I was not referring to their sample but to the fact that it was a question-begging exercise: it assumed as true that which it was supposed to prove. In order to do this they had to eschew economic theory and deny that wage rates are determinate. This in itself made their results utterly worthless. What critics should have done is point out that even if their findings were completely accurate they would still not prove their case against free labour markets. Another vital point that our free marketeers missed.

The market allocates factors, including labour, to their most valued lines of production. In doing so it tends to ensure that each factor receives the full value of its marginal product. However, economics also shows that if labour services are valued in excess of its MVP then unemployment will tend to emerge, unless the other labour markets are still free. The result is that the raising of wages rates above their market rates forces wages rates down in other lines of production. In other words, 'collective' bargaining that successfully raises real wages above the market rate drive down real wages elsewhere. Arthur Smithies nailed this when he wrote:

Concerted action by the whole labour movement to increase money wages will leave real wages unchanged. Real wage gains by a single union are won at the expense of real wages elsewhere. (Cited in Willam H. Hutt’s The Keynesian Episode: A Reassessment, LibertyPress, 1979, p. 267. Also Hutt's Hutt's Theory of Idle Resources, Liberty Press, 1977).

Friedrich von Hayek made this point very clear, a point that every competent economist should understand, when he wrote:

. . workers can raise real wages above the level that would prevail on a free market only by limiting the supply, that is, by withholding part of labour. The interest of those who will get employment at the higher wage will therefore always be opposed to the interest of those who, in consequence, will find employment only in the less highly paid jobs [suboptimal employment] or who will not be employed at all. . . [The unions] success in raising real wages beyond that point, if it is to be more than temporary, can benefit only a particular group at the expense of others. It will therefore serve only a sectional interest even when it obtains the support of all. (The Constitution of Liberty, Gatway Editions LTD 1972, p. 270).

Seeing as Hayek has become a hate figure for the Labor Party1 we should quote him further:

But, while the real wages of all the employed can be raised by union action only at the price of unemployment, unions in particular industries or crafts may well raise the wages of their members by forcing others to stay in less well-paid occupations [emphasis added]. (Ibid. 271).

That Keynes fully understood the true nature of a persistent level of a high rate of unemployment was revealed by his statement that though workers will

resist reductions of money-wages . . . whereas they do not resist reductions of real wages, which are associated with increases in aggregate employment and leave relative money-wages unchanged . . . Every trade union will put up some resistance to a cut in money-wages, however small. But since no trade union would dream of striking on every occasion of a rise in the cost of living, they do not raise the obstacle to any increase in aggregate employment . . . (The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, Macmillan, St Martin’s Press for the Royal Economic Society, 1973, p. 14).

This explains why unemployment in the 1960s averaged about 1.6 per cent despite heavy unionization and a mountain of regulations governing wage rates and the hiring of labour. Inflation was used to lower real labour costs below the value of labor's MVP2. This explains the labour shortages that afflicted the economy at the time3.

As Hayek said of Keynes:

The development of Lord Keynes's theories started from the correct insight that the regular cause of excessive unemployment is real wages that are too high. . . Hence he concluded that real wages must be lowered by the process of lowering the value of money. This is really the reasoning underlying the whole "full employment" policy, now so widely accepted.. (Ibid. 280).

Making a swift though painful journey through Australia at Work I could not help but be reminded of the words of S. G. Shumilin, a Stalinist 'economist', who declared:

Our task is not to study economics but to change it. We are bound by no laws
Buchanan and Woonay have neither morality, economic theory nor history on their side. The mystery here is why critics (apart from our ignorant conservative columnists) have let this pair off so lightly. I have spent years stressing the need to confront the reactionaries who oppose labour market reform. And what did we get? The risible H. R. Nicholls Society, a self-celebratory and hopelessly incompetent group that has probably set reform back another generation. This group's arrogance and stupidity has provided gross economic illiterates like Tim Dunlop and the crowd at Larvatus Prodeo considerable cause for well justified mirth at the expense of free market economics.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Prime Minister Rudd believes, on the advice of David McKnight, that so-called 'Hayekian economics' generates exploitation and creates poverty. The anti-Hayek ramblings of this pair expose them as ignorant clowns.

Kevin Rudd’s economic illiteracy and his attack on Hayek

Kevin Rudd’s imaginary contradiction

2. Of course, a general shortage of labour would also appear when a country was accumulating capital at rate that significantly exceeded population growth.. I do not believe this was the case with respect to Australia.

3. Julian Sheezel is the State Director of the Victorian Liberal Party. When I tried to bring to his attention the severe flaws and contradictions in the government's labour market reform arguments and warned that this could result in disaster, he brushed my facts aside on the grounds that they did not fit the script he was given. It was ignorant buffoons like Sheezel who helped sink the Liberal Government

Monopsony and labour markets: our rightwing screw it up again

Rightwing columnists stuff up labour market reform debate

Why industrial relations reforms flopped with the public

Liberal Government and labour market reform: more fallacious attacks

Minimum wages and capital accumulation: lefty economists fail again

Thanks to the “WMC Club” the Liberal Government's workplace reform package is in trouble

Liberal Party stuffs up its workplace reform arguments against the unions

Labour Market Wars

By Gerard Jackson
BrookesNews.Com

Gerard Jackson is Brookes' economics editor.

Gerard Jackson Archive

© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in