Most Popular
1. It’s a New Macro, the Gold Market Knows It, But Dead Men Walking Do Not (yet)- Gary_Tanashian
2.Stock Market Presidential Election Cycle Seasonal Trend Analysis - Nadeem_Walayat
3. Bitcoin S&P Pattern - Nadeem_Walayat
4.Nvidia Blow Off Top - Flying High like the Phoenix too Close to the Sun - Nadeem_Walayat
4.U.S. financial market’s “Weimar phase” impact to your fiat and digital assets - Raymond_Matison
5. How to Profit from the Global Warming ClImate Change Mega Death Trend - Part1 - Nadeem_Walayat
7.Bitcoin Gravy Train Trend Forecast 2024 - - Nadeem_Walayat
8.The Bond Trade and Interest Rates - Nadeem_Walayat
9.It’s Easy to Scream Stocks Bubble! - Stephen_McBride
10.Fed’s Next Intertest Rate Move might not align with popular consensus - Richard_Mills
Last 7 days
Time to take the RED Pill - 28th May 24
US Economy Slowing Slipping into Recession, But Not There Yet - 28th May 24
Gold vs. Silver – Very Important Medium-term Signal - 28th May 24
Is Gold Price Heading to $2,275 - 2,280? - 28th May 24
Stocks Bull Market Smoking Gun - 25th May 24
Congress Moves against Totalitarian Central Bank Digital Currency Schemes - 25th May 24
Government Tinkering With Prices Is Like Hiding All of the Street Signs - 25th May 24
Gold Mid Tier Mining Stocks Fundamentals - 25th May 24
Why US Interest Rates are a Nothing Burger - 24th May 24
Big Banks Are Pressuring The Fed To Losen Protection For Depositors - 24th May 24
Another Bank Failure: How to Tell if Your Bank is At Risk - 24th May 24
AI Stocks Portfolio and Tesla - 23rd May 24
All That Glitters Isn't Gold: Silver Has Outperformed Gold During This Gold Bull Run - 23rd May 24
Gold and Silver Expose Stock Market’s Phony Gains - 23rd May 24
S&P 500 Cyclical Relative Performance: Stocks Nearing Fully Valued - 23rd May 24
Nvidia NVDA Stock Earnings Rumble After Hours - 22nd May 24
Stock Market Trend Forecasts for 2024 and 2025 - 21st May 24
Silver Price Forecast: Trumpeting the Jubilee | Sovereign Debt Defaults - 21st May 24
Bitcoin Bull Market Bubble MANIA Rug Pulls 2024! - 19th May 24
Important Economic And Geopolitical Questions And Their Answers! - 19th May 24
Pakistan UN Ambassador Grows Some Balls Accuses Israel of Being Like Nazi Germany - 19th May 24
Could We See $27,000 Gold? - 19th May 24
Gold Mining Stocks Fundamentals - 19th May 24
The Gold and Silver Ship Will Set Sail! - 19th May 24
Micro Strategy Bubble Mania - 10th May 24
Biden's Bureau of Labor Statistics is Cooking Jobs Reports - 10th May 24
Bitcoin Price Swings Analysis - 9th May 24
Could Chinese Gold Be the Straw That Breaks the Dollar's Back? - 9th May 24
The Federal Reserve Is Broke! - 9th May 24
The Elliott Wave Crash Course - 9th May 24
Psychologically Prepared for Bitcoin Bull Market Bubble MANIA Rug Pull Corrections 2024 - 8th May 24
Why You Should Pay Attention to This Time-Tested Stock Market Indicator Now - 8th May 24
Copper: The India Factor - 8th May 24
Gold 2008 and 2022 All Over Again? Stocks, USDX - 8th May 24
Holocaust Survivor States Israel is Like Nazi Germany, The Fourth Reich - 8th May 24
Fourth Reich Invades Rafah Concentration Camp To Kill Palestinian Children - 8th May 24

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Protect your Wealth by Investing in AI Tech Stocks

The Brexit War! EU Fearing Collapse Set to Stoke Scottish Independence Proxy War

Politics / BrExit Apr 03, 2017 - 05:38 AM GMT

By: Nadeem_Walayat


On Wednesday 29th May 2017 Theresa May's post man in Brussels hand delivered a 6 page letter to Donald Tusk the President of the European Council, triggering Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty starting the formal process for the UK exiting the European Union within 2 years' time, with the negotiations expected to begin during May following the conclusion of the French Presidential elections.

Of note in Theresa May's letter was that whilst she mentioned Trade 6 times, she mentioned Security 11 times, effectively sending an early warning to the European Union of the threats it faces from the likes of Czar Putin's Russia and should not to risk jeopardising Britain’s key role in securing Europe's borders via its extensive security, military and intelligence apparatus that Britain operates to secure the European Union's eastern and southern borders, an EU hard line on trade would prompt the UK to scale back on the defence of Europe, so that European nations pick up the bill for defending Europe rather than Britain and the United States.

“If, however, we leave the European Union without an agreement the default position is that we would have to trade on World Trade Organisation terms. In security terms a failure to reach agreement would mean our cooperation in the fight against crime and terrorism would be weakened.

“In this kind of scenario, both the United Kingdom and the European Union would of course cope with the change, but it is not the outcome that either side should seek. We must therefore work hard to avoid that outcome.”

" Europe' security is more fragile today than at any time since the end of the Cold War. Weakening our cooperation for the prosperity
and protection of our citizens would be a costly mistake."

You can read the whole 6 page letter here (PDF)

Whilst in European Commission responded to the letter with a hard line by stating that they would first seek to secure everything that is in the EU's interests such as the rights of the 4 million EU nations living in the UK against 1.2 million British citizens living in the EU as well as demanding agreement on a £50 billion exit fee before any negotiations can begin. Therefore immediately began by blackmailing Britain which acts as a warning shot across the bows of any other EU states that may contemplate breaking free from the European Union Superstate.

And before the week was out Donald Tusk delivered the EU's own 85 page letter written in euro-speak listing demands from each member state in the EU's favour before the EU will even consider negotiating anything in Britain's favour such as access to the single market as my following translation illustrates :

  • No separate negotiations between individual member states and the UK.
  • Agreement on an estimated up front £50 billion exit fee before anything else is negotiated.
  • The rights of 4 million EU nationals be agreed against 1.2 million Brit's living in the EU.
  • Poland demanding UK social benefit payments continue for polish nationals residing in Poland such as child benefit.
  • Spain demands Gibraltar as Britain's exit fee.

The BrExit Game

So the great Brexit game is about to begin where on one side is the United Kingdom, and on the other side will be the Rump 27 member state European Union desperate to give the aurora of permanence, stability and unity despite having spent the past decade teetering on the brink of collapse as the euro-zone went form one crisis to the next, leaving most of its member states in an economically crippled state as Germany increasingly calls the economic and political shots.

The EU euro-crats fear the BrExit domino effect as Britain exiting leaves behind at deep void that the European Union is unlikely to be able to fill given the fundamentals of the vast majority of EU funding recipient states revolving around a German Central Black hole that no other European Union member state can compete against. Germany like a vampire has been literally been sucking the economic lifeblood out of other European member nations, especially those within the Euro-zone most of whom remain in a permanent state of economic stagnation and worse depression which is exactly where Britain would be if it were not for LUCK that the fools of the last Labour government who having signed Britain up to a disastrous string of treaties never got around to the UK joining the Euro!

Apparently it was always on Tony Blair's agenda to mastermind a referendum in favour of Britain joining the Euro sometime between 2003 and 2004 (i.e. before the May 2005 general election) and to be implemented by 2007 as illustrated by the following Guardian article from mid-2003.

The UK must aim to join the euro by 2007 - we can't afford not to by Peter Mandelson

"My view (and I speak for no one but myself) is that the cabinet should adopt a medium-term road map which provides a target date for entry in 2007. This means shifting the nature of the debate from an uncertain "if" to a clear "when", subject to confirmation by the British people in a referendum, so that the government can start winning round public opinion."

Therefore, despite all of the noises about how smart Labour had been about not making the mother of all economic mistakes by joining the Euro, the truth is that it was sheer LUCK that Britain did not join the Euro before the financial crisis started to break late 2007. Labour just never got around to the referendum they had been planning probably since the Euro was first launched and the rest is history.

In the Brexit negotiation game that is beginning the objective for Britain is to leave the EU with as much access to the European Single Market as possible without free movement of labour for the least cost incurred in terms of annual contributions and influence on other aspects of British sovereignty.

Whilst for the European Union the primary objective is to prevent Brexit triggering a domino collapse of the European Union, by prompting other member states to decide to follow Britain’s lead and gain freedom from a dictatorial centralised European super state as EC President Jean Claude Junker stated:

"I don’t want others to take the same avenue because just suppose for one second that others would leave … two, three, four, five ... that would be the end.”

So for the EU the name of the game is SURVIVAL. Therefore the EU will go out of its way to make the process for Britain leaving as painful as possible with the final objective being one of trying to engineer a failure for Britain to actually leave the European Union through destabilisation of the British state by economic, market and political means, i.e. subversion.

Therefore the problem at the core of the Brexit Game is that both sides are playing a DIFFERENT game! Britain want's access to the EU market at very limited cost, the EU wants BrExit to FAIL so that the EU does not implode.

Scotland Independence Referendum Proxy War

One of the primary mechanism through which the EU can subvert the British state and economy during the BrExit negotiations is via use of the SNP I.S. (Independent Scotland). The objecting being to trigger a partial collapse of the UK economy by helping to convince the Scottish people to commit economic suicide by voting for Independence from the UK in a referendum held before BrExit negotiations are concluded. Which is exactly the stance that Nicola Sturgeon's SNP have taken, one of a determination for a hard exit out of the United Kingdom and into the European Union which would include virtually immediately adopting the Euro as an Independent Scotland would have no currency.

It remains to be seen just how convincing SNP propaganda will be over the coming months and years as they try and con the Scottish people into committing suicide. I am sure they will greatly exaggerate what will already be greatly exaggerated informal promises from the EU for what an independent Scotland can expect from the European Union, none of which will stand up to close scrutiny.

This despite the undeniable fact that the case for Scottish Independence is far weaker today than it was in September 2014, a time when the SNP propagandists were busy gloating about how Scotland would become the next oil rich sheikdom as the oil price soared into the stratosphere north of $120.

"There can be little doubt that Scotland is moving into a second oil boom. "Even with a cautious estimate of prices remaining at $113 a barrel being used, it's clear that Scottish oil and gas could generate more revenues than has previously been assumed." Alex Salmond, SNP Leader and First Minister.

We'll 2 and half years on and this is what Scotland's fantasy oil revenues would now be looking like, which for the duration has been met by delusional propaganda from the Scottish nationalists that the fall in the price of oil was always just temporary, and that a rebound was just around the corner. Instead the oil price has continued to grind lower slowly turning the Scottish oil industry and Independence economics into dust as the fantasy expectations for oil revenues of £11bn a year would have resolved into a loss of £2 billion a year and where today Scotland's economy is only being kept alive by a £12 billion annual English subsidy that has been supplemented by emergency life support for Scotland's oil industry to the tune of £2 billion, which illustrates the catastrophe that Scotland only just avoided by a whisker in 2014.

Despite heavy English support of the Scottish economy, the oil price crash resulted in the Scottish economy effectively flat lining during 2015 AND 2016 which compares against UK GDP of 2% for each year. Despite this the Scottish people mostly remain in a delusional state as evidenced by the landslide for the Nationalists at the May 2016 Holyrood elections as apparently the lack of growth in Scotland is somehow England's fault rather than the nationalist fanatics who remain determined to burn Scotland in pursuit of a highlands fantasy.

Since 2014 Scotland has lost over 70,000 jobs across the oil sector which further illustrates the crisis that Scotland is facing as there is no sign of the oil price rebounding to anywhere near the $113 that the likes of Alex Salmond were fantasising about, as required for Scotland's expensive offshore oil industry to recover. Instead Scotland's oil industry is being slowly ground into dust with an estimated 40% of its oil sectors jobs lost to date.

So what will the SNP say that the EU are going to promise an Independent Scotland in terms of oil? Promise to buy Scottish oil at double or triple the market price? We'll that's the projections that the Scottish nationalists were making in 2014 of where the oil price would be by now! Triple where it actually is!

SNP Controlled Scottish Parliament Demands Right for Scotland to Commit Suicide

And on cue as Britain counted down to triggering of Article 50 the SNP the day before fired another missile at Westminster in their continuing program towards the subversion of the BrExit settled will of the British people by voting to demand that another Scottish Independence referendum be held before the BrExit negotiations are finalised with the EU. This despite the fact that in the run up to Scotland's September 2014 Independence Referendum the Scottish Nationalists from Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon down promised that they would abide by the results of the referendum, declaring that it was at least a once in a generation decision if not once in a life time decision.

Therefore the SNP run Scottish government instead of focusing on actually governing Scotland to improve the lives of ordinary Scots, instead will waste the next 2 years playing a game with Westminster of repeatedly making demands that the UK parliament will reject and then using the rejections as smoke and mirrors propaganda to mask the failure of the SNP to govern Scotland, whilst fixating the Scottish people towards the fantasy prospects of an IS paradise which would be just as detached from reality as the fantasy the IS of the Levant paints for its fanatical followers.

Here's a reminder of why the SNP cannot be trusted who blindly only see Independence as the answer to every question, and thus remain fanatically determined to destroy the United Kingdom at every opportunity in their quest to hold ever-endums until Scotland votes to commit suicide.

Scotland Second Independence Referendum War

Scotland and Access to the EU Single Market

One of the primary propaganda points for the SNP demanding a second independence referendum is so as to retain access to the Single Market. Thus the SNP are seeking to protect trade with European Single Market comprising exports totalling £12.3bn, 8% of the Scottish economy. The disruption of which the SNP proclaims would be disastrous for the Scottish Economy. Therefore the SNP is seeking to EXIT the UK and ENTER the EU single market in pursuit of protecting this £12.3 bln of trade with the EU whilst making unsubstantiated claims that the EU will welcome Scotland into the EU with open arms and thus it would not be necessary for Scotland to actually leave the EU. However these SNP hopes have not been matched by statements out of the EU whose member states fear their own Scotland's demanding their own independence referendums and thus have stated that Scotland would need to apply for membership of the EU that could take anywhere from 2 years to 10 years.

However, the SNP are deliberately hiding the big elephant in the room consequence of Scotland Exiting the UK from the Scottish people, which is that Scotland would LOSE access to the UK SINGLE MARKET, one of Scottish exports worth more than £55bn to the rest of the UK, 36% of the Scottish economy, and more than four times the amount of Scottish exports to the EU.

Therefore the SNP in seeking to protect £12.3bn of exports to the EU, 8% of the Scottish economy, seek to sacrifice £55bn of exports to the UK, 36% of the Scottish economy, which demonstrates that the SNP's argument for Independence is wholly based on spite, determined to disrupt the Brexit negotiations with the ultimate objective of destroying the United Kingdom at any cost to Scotland AND the rest of the UK. If this is not fundamentalist fanaticism then what is it? For the arguments put forward by the SNP based on trade and access to markets does not stand up to any close scrutiny. The SNP's propaganda is akin to Trumpism i.e. wholly based on a fake reality.

Scotland losing access to the UK single market would be near FIVE TIMES as damaging to the Scottish economy then Scotland losing access to the European single market. And this is before one considers the fact that an Independent Scotland would have NO currency, which means Scotland would immediately need to adopt the Euro without any transitional period that is even if the euro-zone would allow such a destabilising event to take place.

The English Subsidy

The SNP in attempting to convince the Scottish people into commit collective suicide paints a fantasy picture of what an Independent Scotland would be, referring to building on Scotland's existing relative prosperity to the rest of the UK, one of average public spending far exceeding that of England which is why Scotland has free university education whilst English students are saddled with £40k+ of debt. Free prescriptions whilst English patients have to be pay more than £8 per item and the list goes on and on. And similar is true for Northern Ireland and Wales as the following table from the last Scottish Independence referendum illustrates:

However, what the SNP propaganda smoke screen tends to be effective at masking in the consciousness of at about half of the Scottish electorate is the fact that this huge disparity in public spending amounting to currently near £2,000 per head of population is as a consequence of the English subsidy. One of English tax payers forced to subsidise Scotland to the tune of £12 billion per annum that fills most of the black hole in Scotland's finances currently amounting to an annual budget deficit of £15bn per annum, some 10% per annum, far beyond that of bankrupt Greece!

Therefore one of the primary reasons why the people of England receive such a raw deal when it comes to quality of public services is as a consequence of being forced to subsidise the EU to the tune of £11bn a year and Scotland to the tune of £12bn a year, with another £15 billion going to Northern Ireland and Wales each year.

So if the SNP were able to con the Scottish electorate into committing suicide then at the end of the day once the dust has settled from the resulting chaos of ripping the UK apart then England should start to reap the benefits of no longer having to subsidise Scotland in perpetuity. Though of course there will be a heavy cost to England of a breakup of the UK that could total as much as £120bn, especially as a bankrupt Scotland would be in no position to service its share of Britain’s £1.8 trillion national debt.

Whilst it could take more than a decade before England starts to turn a profit from the breakup of the UK. For Scotland, well the Scottish economy would have jumped over the edge of a cliff where the impact of the loss of the English subsidy would be felt near instantaneously. The Scottish economy would be in free fall and it would not be too long before Scotland passes Greece on the way down as the loss of £12bn per annum would demand deep cuts in government spending that I am sure would result in the SNP permanently losing power in Holyrood for bringing about such a catastrophe onto the Scottish people.

Scotland would have NO £12 billion annual subsidy from the UK, and there is no way that the EU would pick up this annual bill, seeking to replace the UK a net £11billion contributor with an net £12 billion recipient, it will never happen in reality only in SNP fantasy.

The bottom line is that yes Scottish independence would mean pain for the rest of the UK, probably taking the UK a decade to fully recover from its consequences. However, for Scotland Independence would be catastrophic as there is the real risk that Scotland may not even survive intact from what would follow as bordering regions in severe permanent economic distress would soon start to demand their own referendums to re-join the UK.

Therefore as I stated in my recent in-depth analysis the Scottish people would once more vote NO to Independence and likely in greater number than in September 2014. Thus all that the SNP are doing is manifesting their hatred of England by attempting to undermine and subvert the Brexit will of the British people DURING the EU negotiations, i.e. attempting to inflict maximum damage to the United Kingdom, behaving as though they are an EU fifth column working in the interests of the European Union rather than in the interests of the United Kingdom and the Scottish people for if an Independence Referendum were held today then they KNOW THEY WOULD LOSE BADLY! Hence the game is one of disruption and subversion.

14 Mar 2017 - SNP Declare Scotland to Commit Economic Suicide Early 2019, 2nd Independence Referendum

Scottish People Will Vote NO to Independence

So Scottish Independence is just NOT going to happen! Because Scotland can NEVER BE INDEPEDENT, all that the SNP fanatics are seeking is a worse deal than that which Britain already has i.e. no opt outs, no rebate and part of the euro-zone, effectively to be Greece 2.0. The scottish people will see through this smoke screen and likely result in an even stronger vote to remain within the UK than in 2014.

Therefore we can all turn down the sound on our TV's whenever we hear shrill SNP voices as amounting to nothing more than the insane ramblings of IS fanatics, devoid of reasoned argument and rational thought who see EVERY EVENT through the prism of breaking up the UK.

Scotland will NOT vote for Independence in a Second Referendum! Furthermore I expect loss of a second referendum to be the nail in the SNP's political coffin as they see their dominance in Holyrood diminish over time at each election as the traditional parties make a comeback.

Thus Theresa May is correct to recognise that the tunnel vision SNP are playing straight into EU's hands by flat out rejecting holding a second Scottish Independence referendum until AFTER Brexit has been concluded. Therefore where the SNP are concerned everyone needs to practice turning down the volume or channel surf each time Nicola Sturgeon appears to screech demanding ever-endums.

All of which reinforces my view that the best strategy for Britain is to NOT play the game that the EU is attempting to engineer for the UK of which encouraging insurrection in the north of the UK is just one example.

This analysis continues in Part 2 where Game Theory answers the question of what Britain should and includes:

  • The BrExit Story
  • Britain Free to Trade with the rest of the World Again?
  • Britain a Victim of the EU Single Market
  • Playing the NATO Card
  • Britain Intelligence Super Power Covert War With the EU
  • Britain and Russia Interests Temporarily Align
  • Spain Warned Remember Falklands Over Gibraltar Subversion Attempts
  • FrExit to the Rescue?
  • Game Theory BrExit Conclusion
  • Consequences of Hard Brexit NO UK / EU Deal
  • UK Brexit Strategy

Part 2 - The BrExit War, Game Theory Strategy for What UK Should Do to Win

And ensure you are subscribed to my always free newsletter and youtube channel for forthcoming in-depth analysis and detailed trend forecasts.

Source and Comments:

By Nadeem Walayat

Copyright © 2005-2017 (Market Oracle Ltd). All rights reserved.

Nadeem Walayat has over 25 years experience of trading derivatives, portfolio management and analysing the financial markets, including one of few who both anticipated and Beat the 1987 Crash. Nadeem's forward looking analysis focuses on UK inflation, economy, interest rates and housing market. He is the author of five ebook's in the The Inflation Mega-Trend and Stocks Stealth Bull Market series that can be downloaded for Free.

Housing Markets Forecast 2014-2018The Stocks Stealth Bull Market 2013 and Beyond EbookThe Stocks Stealth Bull Market Update 2011 EbookThe Interest Rate Mega-Trend EbookThe Inflation Mega-trend Ebook

Nadeem is the Editor of The Market Oracle, a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication that presents in-depth analysis from over 1000 experienced analysts on a range of views of the probable direction of the financial markets, thus enabling our readers to arrive at an informed opinion on future market direction.

Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any trading losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors before engaging in any trading activities.

Nadeem Walayat Archive

© 2005-2022 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in