Best of the Week
Most Popular
1.Four Shocking Economic Bombshells Bernanke Did NOT Tell Congress About Last Week - Martin_D_Weiss
2.Obama Preparing to Attack Iran - Webster G. Tarpley
3.U.S. House Price Forecast 2010 to 2015 - Andrew_Butter
4.The Illuson of Economic Recovery, Major Indicators Point Towards Further Collapse - Bob_Chapman
5.Unusually Uncertain Outlook Shows The Fed is Killing the Economy - Washingtons_Blog
6.Economic Warnings From Niall Ferguson and Nassim Taleb - Gary_North
7.Gold Market Spooked by Deflationary Double-Dip Recession Fears - David_Galland
8.Stocks, Commodities and Financial Markets, The Shape of Things to Come - Steve_Betts
9.Elements of Deflation and the Super-Trend Puzzle - John_Mauldin
10.Wages and Subsistence - 24th July 10 - Ludwig von Mises
Last 5 Days Analysis
The Fed Flashes the Nuclear Quantitative Easing Trump Card - 29th July 10
You’ll Hate Your Gold So Much You’ll Want to Spit On It - 29th July 10
Austrian Business Cycle Theory Vs Keynesians - 29th July 10
Gold Promises and Currency Lies - 29th July 10
Investing for Deflation Part 2: More Reader Questions - 29th July 10
An Corporate Earnings Feast to Digest - 29th July 10
The Number of ETFs Exploding to Over 1,000 - 29th July 10
Stock Market Balancing on a Knife Edge... - 29th July 10
Escalating Violence From the Animal Liberation Front - 29th July 10
How to Pick Stocks in the ‘New Normal’ Economy - 29th July 10
Did BP Accidentally Tap Into the Rigel Gas Field? - 29th July 10
How Think Tanks, Foundations, Big Oil and the CIA Undermine Democracy - 29th July 10
Is WikiLeaks Release Anti-war Whistleblowing or Obama War Propaganda? - 29th July 10
Price Stability Not a Fed Priority - 29th July 10
Bill Gross Ponders "Deep Demographic Doo-Doo" - 29th July 10
Financials, Oil and Gold on the Move - 29th July 10
Kindergarten Double Dip Recession Economics - 28th July 10
Putting Money on the Junior Gold Miners - 28th July 10
Economists Miss Durable Goods Orders Slump - 28th July 10
2011: The Year Of The Tax Increase - 28th July 10
Banks Find A Bid After Basel Watered Down - 28th July 10
Profit From the Global Thirst for Clean Water - 28th July 10
Evolving Global Financial Crisis, U.S. Dollar Heading Down Again - 28th July 10
Investors Beware of Municipal Bonds as Defaults Soar - 28th July 10
Government Economic Lies, The Grossly Problematic Gross Domestic Product - 28th July 10
Economic Warnings From Niall Ferguson and Nassim Taleb - 28th July 10
Will U.S. House Prices Drive The 4.8% “Consensus” Nominal GDP Growth Forecast? - 28th July 10
Gold Counting Down to Assault on $1300 - 28th July 10
America's Vision: National Capitalism - 28th July 10
European Sovereign Debt Crisis, Running Through a Minefield Backwards - 27th July 10
Gold, Hoping for a Break - 27th July 10
Stock Market Take-Off Tuesday Already? - 27th July 10
The Unlimited Power of Suppressing the Interest Rate - 27th July 10
Should the Fed Pump Even More Money? - 27th July 10
Is the Star in Starbucks Fading? - 27th July 10
Nasty MLP ETF Indicator Flashing Investor Warning Signal Again - 27th July 10
NAFTA Has Resulted in Increased U.S. Unemployment - 27th July 10
WikiLeaks Exposes Imperialist War in Afghanistan - 27th July 10
A Decade of Falling House Prices - 27th July 10
The Continuing Crisis in the New World Order - 27th July 10
WikiLeaks and the Afghan War - 27th July 10
BP Hopes for a CEO Savior in American Robert Dudley - 27th July 10
Will China Grab the Credit-Rating Business? - 27th July 10
Unemployment is Worse Than We Know, Economic Recovery Challenge Harder Than We Think - 27th July 10
Plausible Gulf Oil Spill Scenario: Underground Blowout and Mudflow - 27th July 10
The 'I's' of the Illuminati - 27th July 10
Good Potential in Junior Gold Miners - 27th July 10
Three Emerging Economies Bucking the Depression Downtrend - 26th July 10
U.S. Financial Reform Bill is 2300 Pages of Gobbledygook - 26th July 10
Crude Oil and Natural Gas Trading Using Technical's or Fundamentals, Which is Better? - 26th July 10
The Deflationary Cycle Full Monty, Eight Risks That Will Cause Deflation - 26th July 10
Stocks Search for Direction Post Bank Stress Tests - 26th July 10
Crude Oil Headed Unimaginably Higher! - 26th July 10
Four Shocking Economic Bombshells Bernanke Did NOT Tell Congress About Last Week - 26th July 10
China Stock Market Ready to Surge 50%: Part II - 26th July 10
Why Second Quarter Corporate Earnings Haven’t Spurred a Stock Market Rally - 26th July 10
Stocks Stuck in Trading Range Despite Positive Corporate Earnings Reports - 26th July 10
The Illuson of Economic Recovery, Major Indicators Point Towards Further Collapse - 26th July 10
Money Supply Divergence TMS1 vs. TMS2 vs. M2, What does it Mean? - 26th July 10
The Breakup of the United States - 26th July 10
Inflation, The Coming Rice in Prices - 26th July 10
Stocks, Commodities and Financial Markets, The Shape of Things to Come - 25th July 10
Yes, You Can Time the Market – Here’s How! - 25th July 10
Mid 2010 Investment and Economic Thought - 25th July 10
SP-500, GLD and GDX Investor Sentiment Trumps Everything - 25th July 10
Charting the Stock Market is Similar to Tracking a Squirrel Crossing a Busy Street - 25th July 10
Stocks Bull Markets Generate Economic Growth - 25th July 10
Metals Investing in Burkina Faso, The Land of Upright People - 25th July 10
U.S. is Insolvent and Faces Bankruptcy as a Pure Debtor Nation - 25th July 10
Obama Preparing to Attack Iran - 25th July 10
U.S. Taxpayers the Largest Source of Taliban Revenue - 25th July 10
Credit Based on Consumption Not Savings, Real Bills Revisted - 25th July 10
Thoughts on the Economy - 25th July 10
Positive European Bank Stress Tests Sending Markets Higher - 25th July 10
The Golden Chalice and Gold’s Greatest Correction Since 1980 - 25th July 10
Wages and Subsistence - 24th July 10
Why Currencies Play an Important Role in Corporate Earnings - 24th July 10
Elements of Deflation and the Super-Trend Puzzle - 24th July 10
Making Sense of the Economic Puzzle - 24th July 10
Statistical View of Price Ranges for U.S. and China Stock Markets - 24th July 10
NATO Pulls Pakistan Into Its Global Network - 24th July 10
U.S. Jobless Claims and Housing Market Data Point to Worsening Economy - 24th July 10
U.S. Need Not Fear Sovereign Debt Crisis, Unlike Greece, It Actually Is Sovereign - 24th July 10
Shadow Banking Makes A Comeback - 24th July 10
U.S. Economy Never Came Out of Recession, Pray and Hold onto Gold - 24th July 10
Gold BubbleOmics Revisited - 23rd July 10
Gold Market Spooked by Deflationary Double-Dip Recession Fears - 23rd July 10
U.S. Dollar's Never-Ending Plunge and Its Gold Consequences - 23rd July 10
Gold and Silver For Investor Profit and Protection - 23rd July 10
Credit Deflation Lands in Britain - 23rd July 10
Gold Diverging Trend From Weak U.S. Monetary Inflation - 23rd July 10
Markets Stressful Finish To The Week - 23rd July 10
Oil Stocks XOI Undervalued - 23rd July 10
The Strategic Ramifications of a US-Led Withdrawal from Afghanistan - 23rd July 10
A Battle Royal in the S&P 500 Stocks Index - 23rd July 10
Gold Market Manipulation, Swaps Signal the Roadmap Ahead, BIS The Super SIV Solution - 23rd July 10
UK Stealth Economic Boom, GDP 1.1% Growth Catches Press and Academic Economists By Surprise - 23rd July 10
Three Dividend Stealth Stocks - 23rd July 10
Mortgage Debt … Credit Card Debt … Corporate Debt — It’s all Shrinking! - 23rd July 10
U.S. House Price Forecast 2010 to 2015 - 23rd July 10
Hungary Could Trigger Next Sovereign Debt and Credit Crisis Event - 23rd July 10
How to Buy Gold - 23rd July 10
Signing Financial Reform Is Signing Up For A New Struggle To Make It Real - 23rd July 10
Plan For America To Control Federal Deficit Spending - 23rd July 10

Free Instant Analysis

Free Instant Technical Analysis

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Robert Prechter's Stock Market Forecast to 2016

Credit Crisis Truth: The Real Story Behind the Collapse of AIG

Companies / Credit Crisis 2008 Sep 27, 2008 - 02:09 PM

By: Money_Morning

Companies

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleShah Gilani: In Part II of his three-story investigation of the credit crisis, Money Morning Contributing Editor Shah Gilani shows us how American International Group, a perfectly sound company that's survived for 89 years, was destroyed by some errant bets on a derivative security called a “credit default swap,” or CDS. It's a story you'll read nowhere else . Editor

There's nothing fundamentally wrong with the core insurance business units of American International Group Inc. ( AIG ). Nothing at all. What imploded the venerable insurance giant was an accumulation of misplaced bets on credit default swaps.


By the best estimates of the International Swaps and Derivatives Association and the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), often referred to as the central banks' central bank, the notional value of credit default swaps out in the market place is some $62 trillion , or 35 trillion British Pounds at an exchange rate of $1.78.

A credit default swap (CDS) is akin to an insurance policy. It's a financial derivative that a debt holder can use to hedge against the default by a debtor corporation of sovereign. But a CDS can also be used to speculate.

A subsidiary of AIG wrote insurance in the form of credit default swaps, meaning it offered buyers insurance protection against losses on debts and loans of borrowers, to the tune of $447 billion . But the mix was toxic. They also sold insurance on esoteric asset-backed security pools – securities like collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), pools of subprime mortgages , pools of Alt-A mortgages , prime mortgage pools and collateralized loan obligations. The subsidiary collected a lot of premium income and its earnings were robust.

When the housing market collapsed, imploding home prices resulted in precipitously rising foreclosures. The mortgage pools AIG insured began to fall in value. Additionally, the credit crisis began to take its toll on leveraged loans and it saw mounting losses on the loan pools it had insured. In 2007, the company was starting to feel serious heat.

From its humble beginnings in China in 1919 – through the 40-year tenure of CEO Maurice R. “Hank” Greenberg , which ended ignominiously for Greenberg in 2006 – AIG grew aggressively. Greenberg grew and diversified the insurance giant, ultimately amassing a trillion-dollar balance sheet.

But not everything was Kosher .

In an effort to assuage analysts and maintain leverage, the firm entered into sham transactions to affect the appearance on its balance sheet of $500 million of loan-loss reserves, which analysts had been questioning as formerly declining. The result was a 2006 Securities and Exchange Commission enforcement action , a $1.6 billion settlement and the removal of Greenberg. Greenberg is still fighting civil charges related to his actions at the firm.

As 2007 progressed, so did the losses on AIG's books and credit default swaps. Once again, it appears that AIG tried to “manage” the problem through accounting maneuvers. Last February, for instance, AIG said that “its auditor had found a material weakness in its accounting.” It had not been properly valuing its CDO liabilities and swap-related write-downs. The losses were revealed to be in excess of $20 billion through this year's first quarter. The SEC is once again investigating, as are criminal prosecutors at the U.S. Justice Department and the U.S. Attorney's Office in Brooklyn.

After writing down assets against gains elsewhere, AIG posted cumulative losses of $18 billion over the last three quarters. In February, AIG posted $5.3 billion in collateral against credit default swap contracts it had written. In April, AIG had to post an additional $4.4 billion in collateral. When rating agencies Standard & Poor's , Moody's Investors Service ( MCO ) and Fitch Ratings Inc. , lowered the firm's ratings last Monday evening, it triggered an additional $14 billion collateral call as margin against AIG's credit default swaps.

The company didn't have the cash.

Indeed, the dire need for cash collateral on top of mounting losses on warehoused CDO “assets” on the company's balance sheet necessitated a massive infusion of capital. That's what happened to AIG.

But once again, there's the story – and there's the story behind the story.

There's a problem – an inherently systemic problem – and it has to do with how structured investments like tranched collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS), commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS), and credit default swaps on them and on corporate debts and loans are actually valued.

Individually, CDOs are hard to value. Suffice it to say, legend has it that constructing the cash flow payments on the first theoretical 3-tranche CDO (the simplest type of CDO) took a Cray Inc. ( CRAY ) supercomputer 48 hours. Now try and value credit default swaps on them!

Because there are so many different individual CDO securities, and because there are so many credit default swaps on so many of these CDOs, and so many swaps on individually referenced entity debts and loans, the only way to value them in a portfolio is by indexing.

That's right, there are indexes, and guess what? You can trade the indexes! Markit Group Ltd. , of London, constructs and manages the CDX, ABX, CMBX and LCDX family of credit-default-swap indexes. Investopedia has a decent little tutorial .

Here's the problem: If you own a portfolio of CDOs, and the only way to value them (or, at least, to develop a valuation that others are reasonably certain to respect), is by looking at them through the prism of an index of credit default swaps on them, you're at the mercy of the index. Your portfolio, your securities may not be so bad, but you may not really know based on mortgage-duration analysis and foreclosure events that you can't calculate. So you value, or mark-to-market , against the closest index.

Here's the rub. What if other speculators are selling short – that is, betting in anticipation of that index going down? What if large portfolio-hedgers are selling short the index to hedge the portfolio they can't sell because no one will buy it – because no one knows what it's worth?

It's crazy. And it gets worse.

What if you're running a profitable company that needs to borrow money, but credit default swaps (bets against your ability to pay back your debt) are expensive by virtue of speculators fear and greed, such that if any bank looks at where the CDS pricing on your paper is trading, they tell you: “Sorry, but we can't lend you money because the market for credit default swaps thinks you're a bad bet.”

You don't get the loan. You can't build your factory; you can't produce and have nothing to sell. The upshot: Now you actually are going out of business. Is this self-fulfilling?

Ponder this: Last Monday, as AIG was initially seeking $20 billion in capital and actually had it in hand (by virtue of a deal with New York insurance regulators), traders were bidding up credit default swaps on AIG's debt and loans so furiously that based on the insurance premiums traders were actually paying for default insurance on AIG… the company was already dead . Self-fulfilling?

Credit default swaps are creating a downward spiral in the capital markets, driving up the cost of capital, and squeezing out all manner of borrowers. And these speculative bets run amok are undermining all U.S. Federal Reserve and U.S. Treasury Department efforts to “liquefy” the system. If this keeps up, the credit default market could sink the U.S. economy into a recession/depression that will make the Great Depression look like a day at the beach.

Anyone got a towel?

[ Editor's Note : Contributing Editor R. Shah Gilani has toiled in the trading pits in Chicago, run trading desks in New York, operated as a broker/dealer and managed everything from hedge funds to currency accounts. In this special three-part investigation, Gilani draws upon the experiences and network of contacts developed from his time as a professional trader and hedge-fund manager to provide Money Morning 's readers with the “real story” of the credit crisis . Part I appeared Friday . Part III appears tomorrow (Tuesday). In his new column, " Inside Wall Street ," Gilani promises to use similar insights to take readers on a journey through the "shadowy back alleys" of the U.S. capital markets - and to conduct us past the "velvet rope" that guards Wall Street's most-valuable secrets. By doing so, Gilani hopes to provide us with investment ideas with the biggest profit potential. If the whipsaw markets we're experiencing lead to the so-called market “Super Crash” that many analysts fear, Money Morning readers will have much less to fear than most investors, since they'll be able to capitalize on the once-in-a-lifetime profit plays that we detail in a new report. For a copy of that report - which includes a free copy of CNBC analyst Peter D. Schiff's New York Times best-seller, " Crash Proof: How to Profit from the Coming Economic Collapse " - please click here . ]

News and Related Story Links :

By Shah Gilani
Contributing Editor

Money Morning/The Money Map Report

©2008 Monument Street Publishing. All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright laws of the United States and international treaties. Any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including on the world wide web), of content from this website, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Monument Street Publishing. 105 West Monument Street, Baltimore MD 21201, Email: customerservice@moneymorning.com

Disclaimer: Nothing published by Money Morning should be considered personalized investment advice. Although our employees may answer your general customer service questions, they are not licensed under securities laws to address your particular investment situation. No communication by our employees to you should be deemed as personalized investment advice. We expressly forbid our writers from having a financial interest in any security recommended to our readers. All of our employees and agents must wait 24 hours after on-line publication, or 72 hours after the mailing of printed-only publication prior to following an initial recommendation. Any investments recommended by Money Morning should be made only after consulting with your investment advisor and only after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company.

Money Morning Archive

© 2005-2010 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Comments


Post Comment (Moderated)




(Note Commenting Issue: If after Submitting you are returned to the Main Index Page then due to site caching your comment has not been accepted. Solution - Click the Browser Back Button to the article page and Press PAGE REFRESH (you should see the message "You are not authorized to carry out this operation") Now re-enter your comment (ignoring the notice) - If all's well then you will remain on the article page after submitting, a moderator will check and authorise the comment. Alternatively EMAIL to comments @ marketoracle.co.uk , quoting the article number.

FREE Deflation Survival GuideFREE Updated 118 Page Independant Investor E-book