Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Investing in a Bubble Mania Stock Market Trending Towards Financial Crisis 2.0 CRASH! - 9th Sep 21
2.Tech Stocks Bubble Valuations 2000 vs 2021 - 25th Sep 21
3.Stock Market FOMO Going into Crash Season - 8th Oct 21
4.Stock Market FOMO Hits September Brick Wall - Evergrande China's Lehman's Moment - 22nd Sep 21
5.Crypto Bubble BURSTS! BTC, ETH, XRP CRASH! NiceHash Seizes Funds on Account Halting ALL Withdrawals! - 19th May 21
6.How to Protect Your Self From a Stock Market CRASH / Bear Market? - 14th Oct 21
7.AI Stocks Portfolio Buying and Selling Levels Going Into Market Correction - 11th Oct 21
8.Why Silver Price Could Crash by 20%! - 5th Oct 21
9.Powell: Inflation Might Not Be Transitory, After All - 3rd Oct 21
10.Global Stock Markets Topped 60 Days Before the US Stocks Peaked - 23rd Sep 21
Last 7 days
Peloton 35% CRASH a Lesson of What Happens When One Over Pays for a Loss Making Growth Stock - 1st Dec 21
Stock Market Sentiment Speaks: I Fear For Retirees For The Next 20 Years - 1st Dec 21 t
Will the Anointed Finanical Experts Get It Wrong Again? - 1st Dec 21
Main Differences Between the UK and Canadian Gaming Markets - 1st Dec 21
Bitcoin Price TRIGGER for Accumulating Into Alt Coins for 2022 Price Explosion - 30th Nov 21
Omicron Covid Wave 4 Impact on Financial Markets - 30th Nov 21
Can You Hear It? That’s the Crowd Booing Gold’s Downturn - 30th Nov 21
Economic and Market Impacts of Omicron Strain Covid 4th Wave - 30th Nov 21
Stock Market Historical Trends Suggest A Strengthening Bullish Trend In December - 30th Nov 21
Crypto Market Analysis: What Trading Will Look Like in 2022 for Novice and Veteran Traders? - 30th Nov 21
Best Stocks for Investing to Profit form the Metaverse and Get Rich - 29th Nov 21
Should You Invest In Real Estate In 2021? - 29th Nov 21
Silver Long-term Trend Analysis - 28th Nov 21
Silver Mining Stocks Fundamentals - 28th Nov 21
Crude Oil Didn’t Like Thanksgiving Turkey This Year - 28th Nov 21
Sheffield First Snow Winter 2021 - Snowballs and Snowmen Fun - 28th Nov 21
Stock Market Investing LESSON - Buying Value - 27th Nov 21
Corsair MP600 NVME M.2 SSD 66% Performance Loss After 6 Months of Use - Benchmark Tests - 27th Nov 21
Stock Maket Trading Lesson - How to REALLY Trade Markets - 26th Nov 21
SILVER Price Trend Analysis - 26th Nov 21
Federal Reserve Asks Americans to Eat Soy “Meat” for Thanksgiving - 26th Nov 21
Is the S&P 500 Topping or Just Consolidating? - 26th Nov 21
Is a Bigger Drop in Gold Price Just Around the Corner? - 26th Nov 21
Financial Stocks ETF Sector XLF Pullback Sets Up A New $43.60 Upside Target - 26th Nov 21
A Couple of Things to Think About Before Buying Shares - 25th Nov 21
UK Best Fixed Rate Tariff Deal is to NOT FIX Gas and Electric Energy Tariffs During Winter 2021-22 - 25th Nov 21
Stock Market Begins it's Year End Seasonal Santa Rally - 24th Nov 21
How Silver Can Conquer $50+ in 2022 - 24th Nov 21
Stock Market Betting on Hawkish Fed - 24th Nov 21
Stock Market Elliott Wave Trend Forecast - 24th Nov 21
Your once-a-year All-Access Financial Markets Analysis Pass - 24th Nov 21
Did Zillow’s $300 million flop prove me wrong? - 24th Nov 21
Now Malaysian Drivers Renew Their Kurnia Car Insurance Online With Fincrew.my - 24th Nov 21
Gold / Silver Ratio - 23rd Nov 21
Stock Market Sentiment Speaks: Can We Get To 5500SPX In 2022? But 4440SPX Comes First - 23rd Nov 21
A Month-to-month breakdown of how Much Money Individuals are Spending on Stocks - 23rd Nov 21
S&P 500: Rallying Tech Stocks vs. Plummeting Oil Stocks - 23rd Nov 21
Like the Latest Bond Flick, the US Dollar Has No Time to Die - 23rd Nov 21
Why BITCOIN NEW ALL TIME HIGH Changes EVERYTHING! - 22nd Nov 21
Cannabis ETF MJ Basing & Volatility Patterns - 22nd Nov 21
The Most Important Lesson Learned from this COVID Pandemic - 22nd Nov 21
Dow Stock Market Trend Analysis - 22nd Nov 21

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Protect your Wealth by Investing in AI Tech Stocks

It is 1937 for the US Federal Reserve

Economics / Economic Depression Apr 16, 2008 - 05:21 PM GMT

By: Mick_Phoenix

Economics

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleThis Letter is a follow on from my article The Future Actions of The Federal Reserve and US Govt are known   in which, using the work of GB Eggertsson, we showed that the Fed/US Govt is following a plan to stimulate the economy and avoid a deflationary episode. Essentially the plan is to avoid the mistakes of the Depression and those of Japan in the 90's by using increased Government debt, monetized by the Fed, targeted directly at consumers. By employing a credible threat of an inflationary stance the Fed/US Govt hope to raise inflation expectations and therefore raise the price of assets. 


Whilst the groundwork for such actions are already in place as discussed previously, I now wish to concentrate on the effects such actions will have in the future.

Again, I have to write this article without recourse to my own thoughts to keep an objective viewpoint. I will be using GB Eggertsson again as a reference point. Although it would appear to narrow the perspective the fact that his Theory is in play and he is a member of the New York Fed staff would lend weight to his other work in this regard. In December 2005 Eggertsson published a paper entitled   " Great Expectations and the End of the Depression"  in which he laid out how the policies of President FD Roosevelt allowed the economy to depart from a deflationary environment.

What I want to show is that Eggertsson has based his theory on the successful polices and methods employed by FDR and what effect those policies had on the economy. Within the paper Eggertsson lays out arguments that support the FDR policies as the only credible approach to economic stimulus during a period of deflation. I believe that those policies are now being used to circumvent the current threat of a deflationary period caused by the credit crash.

Before we begin, I would like to show you a quote from the time as FDR enacted his policy change, referred to as a "regime change" (Sargent 1983 and Temin & Wigmore 1990):

"It is hard to overstate how radical the regime change was. "This is the end of Western civilization," declared Lewis Douglas, Director of the Budget, for example. (2) During FDR's fi rst year in o ffi ce several senior government o ffi cials resigned in protest. (3)"

(2) Cited in Davis (1986), p. 107. ( 3) These included Lewis Douglas. The acting Secretary of the Treasury, Dean Acheson, was forced to resign due to his oppisition to unbalanced budgets and the abolishment of the gold standard.

Clearly it was not the end of western civilisation at that time. What we do see is the turmoil that was created by adoption of the new regime. Such events could be compared to the arguments put forward by the recently retired US Comptroller General David M Walker.

History

Without going too deep into history we need to compare the performance of the overall economy during the FDR presidency with the previous 4 year period. Within the following quote from Eggertsson is an interesting observation about the growth of the monetary base:  

"The e ff ect of the FDR regime shift is clearly evident in the data. When FDR was inaugurated in March 1933 excessive de fl ation turned into modest in fl ation. There was little change in the trend growth of the monetary base around this turning point. Money growth did not start on a sustained upward trend until several months after prices started to rise. Similarly, the fi scal expansion happened with a substantial lag.

This evidence suggests that the recovery was driven almost exclusively by expectations about future policy. The comparison between FDR's fi rst term in o ffi ce (1933-37) and President Herbert Hoover's last (1929-33) is striking. Hoover's last term resulted in 26 percent de fl ation, while FDR's fi rst registered 13 percent in fl ation. Similarly, output declined by 30 percent from 1929-1933. This was the worst depression in US history. In contrast, 1933-1937 registered the strongest output growth (39 percent) of any four year period in the US history outside of war."

As can be seen in the following table (Eggertsson) 1933 marked the end of the contraction in GDP in dollar terms and the beginning of a large scale expansion of  public debt. Noticeable is the acceleration in the growth of the monetary base that begins in 1934, lagging the increase in public debt:

This would support the argument that the increase in debt raised inflation expectations, leading to an increase in monetary demand.

Form this we can infer, without reference to historical writings, that FDR was seen as credible in his regime change.  it was this credible approach that allowed inflation expectations to be seen as correct and for monetary requirements to change accordingly.

The Effects

As FDR took office, there was a noticeable turnaround in expectations. Firstly, lets see what the baseline was, according to Eggertsson:

" The reason for the collapse is that the central bank cannot lower interest rates enough to accommodate de fl ationary shocks, due to the zero bound on interest rates and is unable to change expectations about future policy. This creates a strong de fl ation bias. The de fl ation bias helps explain the severity of the Great Depression, because real interest rates were excessively high in 1929-33 due to double digit de fl ation. This choked spending, especially investment. "Money was king" during this period. Nobody was interested in investing when the returns from stu ffi ng money under the mattress were 10-15 percent in real terms. People gained more, in other words, from holding money than spending it."

Or as I said, why spend today when it will be cheaper tomorrow?  It is clear that to make the Eggertsson Theory work, the baseline conditions of the economy should be depressed before allowing the already prepared stimulus to be released. Compare the conditions in 1933 to those today:

The short-term nominal interest rate was close to zero during the Great Depression. The yield on three month Treasuries, for example, was only 0.05 percent in January 1933. Further interest rate reductions were clearly not feasible. Open market operations, in themselves, had no e ff ect, since money and government bonds were perfect substitutes. This explains why several observers at the time were skeptical of the e ff ectiveness of monetary policy and believed that open market operations were just like “pushing on a string”.

Despite this, however, monetary policy was far from powerless. While increasing the money supply at zero interest rate has no e ff ect, expectations about higher future money supply (once de fl ationary pressures have subsided and interest rates are positive again) have large e ff ects because they change people's expectations about the future price level, thus reducing real interest rates. What was needed to end the Depression was a regime shift that changed expectations about future policy in a credible way. This is precisely what FDR achieved.

With current 3 month yields at at 1.13% and inflation measures well above, it can be seen why the Fed/US Govt fear a deflationary scenario. The requirement for a credible policy that will result in rising inflation expectations is absolute, to ensure that neither the consumer or business is discouraged from spending or investing. (This has far-reaching consequences, for instance it would not be in the Fed interest to suppress the price of gold)

With this in mind, let us look at some of the effects that FDR policy regime change had post 1933:

Price Levels

Investment

Commodity Prices

Stocks

Again, it is clear to see that the expectations of rising inflation based on a credible policy had an almost instant effect on assets and prices before fiscal and monetary policy had time to make their actual changes felt.

Comparisons to Today

To read the rest of this Occasional Letter please visit www.caletters.com

By Mick Phoenix

To contact Michael or discuss the letters topic E Mail mickp@livecharts.co.uk .

Copyright © 2008 by Mick Phoenix - All rights reserved.

Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilizing methods believed reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any trading losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Do your own due diligence.

Mick Phoenix  Archive

© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in