Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Stock Markets and the History Chart of the End of the World (With Presidential Cycles) - 28th Aug 20
2.Google, Apple, Amazon, Facebook... AI Tech Stocks Buying Levels and Valuations Q3 2020 - 31st Aug 20
3.The Inflation Mega-trend is Going Hyper! - 11th Sep 20
4.Is this the End of Capitalism? - 13th Sep 20
5.What's Driving Gold, Silver and What's Next? - 3rd Sep 20
6.QE4EVER! - 9th Sep 20
7.Gold Price Trend Forecast Analysis - Part1 - 7th Sep 20
8.The Fed May “Cause” The Next Stock Market Crash - 3rd Sep 20
9.Bitcoin Price Crash - You Will be Suprised What Happens Next - 7th Sep 20
10.NVIDIA Stock Price Soars on RTX 3000 Cornering the GPU Market for next 2 years! - 3rd Sep 20
Last 7 days
From Recession to an Ever-Deeper One - 19th Oct 20
Wales Closes Border With England, Stranded Motorists on Severn Bridge? Covid-19 Police Road Blocks - 19th Oct 20
Commodity Bull Market Cycle Starts with Euro and Dollar Trend Changes - 19th Oct 20
Stock Market Melt-Up Triggered a Short Squeeze In The NASDAQ and a Utilities Breakout - 19th Oct 20
Silver is Like Gold on Steroids - 19th Oct 20
Countdown to Election Mediocrity: Why Gold and Silver Can Protect Your Wealth - 19th Oct 20
“Hypergrowth” Is Spilling Into the Stock Market Like Never Before - 19th Oct 20
Is Oculus Quest 2 Good Upgrade for Samsung Gear VR Users? - 19th Oct 20
Low US Dollar Risky for Gold - 17th Oct 20
US 2020 Election: Are American's ready for Trump 2nd Term Twilight Zone Presidency? - 17th Oct 20
Custom Ryzen 5950x, 5900x, 5800x , RTX 3080, 3070 64gb DDR4 Gaming PC System Build Specs - 17th Oct 20
Gold Jumps above $1,900 Again - 16th Oct 20
US Economic Recovery Is in Need of Some Rescue - 16th Oct 20
Why You Should Focus on Growth Stocks Today - 16th Oct 20
Why Now is BEST Time to Upgrade Your PC System for Years - Ryzen 5000 CPUs, Nvidia RTX 3000 GPU's - 16th Oct 20
Beware of Trump’s October (November?) Election Surprise - 15th Oct 20
Stock Market SPY Retesting Critical Resistance From Fibonacci Price Amplitude Arc - 15th Oct 20
Fed Chairman Begs Congress to Stimulate Beleaguered US Economy - 15th Oct 20
Is Gold Market Going Back Into the 1970s? - 15th Oct 20
Things you Should know before Trade Cryptos - 15th Oct 20
Gold and Silver Price Ready For Another Rally Attempt - 14th Oct 20
Do Low Interest Rates Mean Higher Stocks? Not so Fast… - 14th Oct 20
US Debt Is Going Up but Leaving GDP Behind - 14th Oct 20
Dell S3220DGF 31.5 Inch VA Gaming Monitor Amazon Prime Day Bargain Price! But WIll it Get Delivered? - 14th Oct 20
Karcher K7 Pressure Washer Amazon Prime Day Bargain 51% Discount! - 14th Oct 20
Top Strategies Day Traders Adopt - 14th Oct 20
AMD is KILLING Intel as Ryzen Zen 3 Takes Gaming Crown, AMD Set to Achieve CPU Market Dominance - 13th Oct 20
Amazon Prime Day Real or Fake Sales to Get Rid of Dead Stock? - 13th Oct 20
Stock Market Short-term Top Expected - 13th Oct 20
Fun Stuff to Do with a Budgie or Parakeet, a Child's Best Pet Bird Friend - 13th Oct 20
Who Will Win the Race to Open a Casino in Japan? - 13th Oct 20
Fear Grips Stock Market Short-Sellers -- What to Make of It - 12th Oct 20
For Some Remote Workers, It Pays to Stay Home… If Home Stays Local - 12th Oct 20
A Big Move In Silver: Watch The Currency Markets - 12th Oct 20
Precious Metals and Commodities Comprehensive - 11th Oct 20
The Election Does Not Matter, Stick With Stock Winners Like Clean Energy - 11th Oct 20
Gold Stocks Are Cheap, But Not for Long - 11th Oct 20
Gold Miners Ready to Fall Further - 10th Oct 29
What Happens When the Stumble-Through Economy Stalls - 10th Oct 29
This Is What The Stock Market Is Saying About Trump’s Re-Election - 10th Oct 29
Here Is Everything You Must Know About Insolvency - 10th Oct 29
Sheffield Coronavirus Warning - UK Heading for Higher Covid-19 Infections than April Peak! - 10th Oct 29
Q2 Was Disastrous. But What’s Next for the US Economy – and Gold? - 9th Oct 20
Q4 Market Forecast: How to Invest in a World Awash in Debt - 9th Oct 20
A complete paradigm shift will make gold the generational trade - 9th Oct 20
Why You Should Look for Stocks Climbing Out of a “Big Base” - 9th Oct 20
UK Coronavirus Pandemic Wave 2 - Daily Covid-19 Positive Test Cases Forecast - 9th Oct 20
Ryzen ZEN 3: The Final Nail in Intel's Coffin! Cinebench Scores 5300x, 5600x, 5800x, 5900x 5950x - 9th Oct 20
How Soon Will We See Stock Market SPX 4000? - 8th Oct 20
Stock Market Spy ETF Testing March Price Peak – What Do the Charts Say? - 8th Oct 20
5 Consequences of US Debt at $50 Trillion - 8th Oct 20
Long Term Cycles Suggest Stock Price Reversion Pending & Gold Price About To Explode High - 8th Oct 20
AMD Zen 3 Ryzen 5000 Launch - Performance, Prices Skews, Cinebench r20 Scores, 5800x, 5900x, 5950x - 8th Oct 20
Gold vs. Silver – Absolutely No Comparison - 8th Oct 20
Gold: Why You Should Be Wary of the "Consensus" - 8th Oct 20
UK Covid-19 Hospital Admissions and Deaths Since Testing Positive in 28 days Analysis - 7th Oct 20
Amazon Prime Day 2020 Sales Top Tips of How To Get Big Savings! - 7th Oct 20
Want To Win Big In Forex Trading? Leverage Is Your Friend - 7th Oct 20
Why I am Voting for Donald J. Hitler - 6th Oct 20
Markets Chop & Grind: Gold, Stocks & Commodities - 6th Oct 20
Silver Price Great Buy Spot Ahead of Second Big Upleg - 6th Oct 20
Forget RTX 3080 Get Zen 3 Ryzen 5900x / 5950x - GPU vs CPU - PC Bottlenecking - 6th Oct 20
How to Get Budgies / Parakeets to Eat Vegetables for the First Time - 6th Oct 20
How to Pick a Reputable Double Glazing Window Company - 6th Oct 20

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Get Rich Investing in Stocks by Riding the Electron Wave

Manipulated Rigged Crude Oil Prices And The Big Bounce

Commodities / Crude Oil Apr 21, 2010 - 06:40 AM GMT

By: Andrew_McKillop


Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleWorld oil trading mainly concerns "paper oil" contracts traded at a rate vastly higher than actual physical oil production, supply and demand. Paper oil contracts on crude and products cover volumes and quantities at least 60 to 80 times more than actual physical supply and demand. In the case of the USA, where the oil trading system started, the difference is even bigger - usually at least 100 times. The financial players who operate the market, ranging from private investment banks and brokers through commercial banks, hedge funds and high net worth individuals set the scene for price movements, and generate the price spikes and troughs the press and government like to blame on the oil industry, environmentalists and government, or on OPEC.

With the Goldman Sachs crisis, creating serious erosion of its Teflon imagee, attention will shift from GS action in CDOs and subprime debt-related paper, the focus of US Securities & Exchange Commission charges against GS, to the long and powerful role of America's most profitable private bank in shifting oil prices whenever it wants.

As all oil traders know, GS has for years been a principal maker and breaker of Nymex oil price movements, but the exact mechanisms and methods used by GS are clouded by careful hiding of the traces, and by herd instinct discretion on the part of market players, the press and media. What we know is that with the announcement of US SEC charges of fraud against GS on April 16, oil prices plunged along with gold prices. This sell-off quickly moved on and amplified to a wave of selling across the commodity space - casting the Goldman shadow far and wide. We then got the technical rebound and bargain hunter buying, bringing us to today's date.

What happens next has several options. GS could wriggle free from the opprobrium of US SEC charges, and a chorus of political voices, like that of the UK's Gordon Brown, sniffing public acclaim from attacking the black sheep financial manipulators and market riggers who were so generously aided by the same politicians, in 2008-2009.


Market rigging by financial players is not just a theory but a vital revenue strategy: volatile prices generate earnings but flat-line, slow changing prices produce little. Action to intensify the change of daily traded price up or down, at a time and in a way they know, but other market players do not is the prized target for the big boy players. To be sure, the risk of market rigging is recognized by all governments and specific laws exist to punish market rigging, but the process is slow, cumbersome and often low yield for the politicians initiating the hunt for kudos.

Sometimes however the scale and impact of the rigging is so big the process shifts to another scale. This could now concern Goldman Sachs, for one reason because it is accused by the US SEC of serious fraud, linked with the still-sensitive US "subprime" crisis of 2007-2008. When the press and media focus swivels back to this period, GS oil market playing, if not rigging, will again be commented. Old and not forgotten legal action concerning the bank but not against it, is likely to be aired again. At that time, average readers will be able to learn that Goldman Sachs may have had a big role in the extreme rise and then fall of traded oil prices through 2007-2008.

The biggest example could concern the "last leg" of the upward spiral in Nymex prices for WTI, near instantly transmitted to day traded oil prices on London's ICE, Singapore's IPE, Tokyo's Tocom and elsewhere. Several journalists have described how they think Goldman Sachs rigged oil prices through 2007-2008 and specially in spring and summer of 2008. One example was a 'Forbes' article of April 13, 2009 by two journalists who examined the sudden financial collapse of the big US oil pipeline company Semgroup Holdings. This company was basically betting that oil prices would not go beyond about US$ 120 a barrel for WTI grade in the first 6 months of 2008. Semgroup, advised by Goldman Sachs, and dealing with the Goldman Sachs subsidiary J. Aron & Co for oil contracts, went on to take increasingly speculative positions, buying oil futures needing oil prices to fall by ever large amounts, simply to cover Semgroup's accumulated and rising losses.

By end-June 2008, Semgroup had accumulated a loss-making position on its oil futures contracts, of about US$ 2.4 billion. Being unable to pay the fees and costs to maintain its contracts to buy oil at a future and low price it asked Goldman Sachs to lend, or organize the lending of finance for the the margin calls, which GS refused. The coup de grace for this sequence was the very fast, one way rise in daily settlement prices for WTI in May-June 2008, culminating with the ultimate peak of around US$ 147 a barrel reached in early July. Semgroup went into receivership, and both GS and its J. Aron & Co subsidiary made very large profits.

Lawyers for Semgroup, during its bankruptcy hearings, argued that Goldman Sachs had through various mechanisms, and deliberately driven up day traded oil prices for WTI grade oil on the Nymex by around US$ 15 to 30 a barrel above any possible rational price, based on supply and demand fundamentals. This was done, the lawyers argued, to benefit Goldman Sachs when its very big client Semgroup went bankrupt. Shortly after, and as we know, day traded oil prices on the US Nymex started falling very fast, and to low levels from the peak of over US$ 145 a barrel for WTI in July 2008. As we know, almost immediately after the "last leg up", day traded prices started plunging, to an extreme low around US$ 30 a barrel in December 2008.


The methods used by only a select few, very big financial players operating in commodity markets to move prices around as they want are moved up a mighty notch in power and reach when they have a commodity index. These players can use their own proprietary CI or commodity price index as a weapon of mass destruction. For Goldman this is the S&P GSCI, with a heavy oil and petroleum products weighting. Coupling CI ownership with banking clout and leverage, and a myriad of financial products able to cover the traces of any rigging or manipulation, only a few players can rival Goldman Sachs in the basic capability to move oil prices up and down when they want, by however much they want. These few players, who all want to stay in business, have every incentive to think and act the same way, but creatively.

To be sure, it is unlikely the US SEC or any European regulators like the UK FSA now homing in on GS will widen their enquiry terms to cover all financial players both able and likely to rig oil prices, as well as other commodity prices, when they want. As we already said, proving a certain market really was rigged at a certain time is difficult, and traces can disappear rather face. One was the immediate sequel to the US SEC announcement of April 16: first oil and gold prices slid by a large amount, then other commodities joined oil and gold. This merely shows a lot of futures contracts were sold or disposed of, rapidly.

More interesting is to forecast what happens to oil and gold, and other commodity prices in the wake of Goldman Sachs being accused of criminal fraud by a US government agency. At this time, and with or without the helping hand of GS, both oil and gold are high priced, well supported, and have serious potential for further appreciation. As we saw in 2008, when oil moves beyond the glass ceiling of US$ 100 a barrel, momentum can quickly build for further highs. Whether or not a market rigger, even the biggest and best among them is seeking to drive the momentum for their own benefit will only change the time taken to reach unknown and exotic high prices. After that we move into the realms of realpolitik, geopolitics and inflation.

As we know, since the oil price explosion and implosion in May-Dec 2008, private banks and other market players were discreet and low in activity through most of 2009, but have now pushed oil prices back above US$ 80 a barrel, with gold periodically edged towards US$ 1200 an ounce and platinum poised to move above US$ 1800 an ounce. This is with near-recession lingering in Europe and Japan and a nice-on-paper but not the real world, US jobless economic recovery. Attributing present oil and gold prices to Emerging Economy growth is difficult, making it necessary to more than simply guess the machine of market rigging is alive and well - whether Goldman Sachs is temporarily absent from the party or not. As the global economy fitfully recovers, mainly because there is no alternative, the coming commodity price bounce will even take GS by surprise - unless of course GS programmed it !

By Andrew McKillop

Project Director, GSO Consulting Associates

Former chief policy analyst, Division A Policy, DG XVII Energy, European Commission. Andrew McKillop Biographic Highlights

© 2010 Copyright Andrew McKillop - All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

© 2005-2019 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules