Best of the Week
Most Popular
1.Putin’s World: Why Russia’s Showdown with the West Will Worsen - John_Mauldin
2. Stocks Bull Market Grinds Bears into Dust, Is Santa Rally Sustainable? - Nadeem_Walayat
3. Gold and Silver 2015 Trend Forecasts, Prices to Go BOOM - Austin_Galt
4.Gold Price Golden Bottom? - Toby_Connor
5.Gold Price and Miners Soar on Huge Volume - P_Radomski_CFA
6.Stock Market and the Jaws of Life or Death? - Rambus_Chartology
7.Gold Price 2015 - EWI
8.Manipulated Stock Market Short Squeezes to Another All Time High - The China Syndrome - Nadeem_Walayat
9.Gold, Silver, Crude and S&P Ending Wedge Patterns - DeviantInvestor
10.Is the Gold And Silver Golden Rule Broken? - Michael_Noonan
Last 5 days
Is There A New Global Consensus About Cheating Investors To Reboot Employment? - 26th Nov 14
EUR/USD – Currency Bulls Don’t Give Up - 26th Nov 14
Swiss Gold Referendum A Golden Opportunity for Switzerland - 25th Nov 14
Silver: What COT Analysis Tells Us - 25th Nov 14
Stock Market Big, Bold and Ugly - 25th Nov 14
U.S. Dollar Near Top? Gold and Silver Trading, Platinum Breakout Invalidation - 25th Nov 14
Buy Fear - Easily Pick Up Profits on Stock Market Dips - 25th Nov 14
The Islamic State Reshapes the Middle East - 25th Nov 14
Gold Price Forecast 2015 - 25th Nov 14
The Swiss Referendum On Gold: What’s Missing From The Debate - 25th Nov 14
Clash of Generations - Why Millennials Still Live at Home; Not Jobs, Student Debt, or Housing - 25th Nov 14
Stock Market Reminiscent of Pompeii - 25th Nov 14
Once Upon A Time There Were Philosopher Kings - 24th Nov 14
The 2014 Crude Oil Price Crash Explained - 24th Nov 14
China Stock Investing - Follow the Money! - 24th Nov 14
122 Tonnes of Gold Secretly Repatriated to Netherlands - 24th Nov 14
What Causes the U.S. Dollar to Move? - 24th Nov 14
Stock Market Indexes New Highs - Will Uptrend Extend Even Further? - 24th Nov 14
All Hail the King U.S. Dollar - Trend Forecast - 24th Nov 14
Where Is China Economy On The Map Exactly? - 24th Nov 14
Most of The World Economies Panic - Is The US Next? - 24th Nov 14
Stock Market Exhaustion Gap? - 24th Nov 14
Gold Golden Gains Come After The Pain - 24th Nov 14
Crude Oil and Stock Market Setting The Stage For The Next Recession - 23rd Nov 14
This Publicly-Owned Bank Is Outperforming Wall Street - 23rd Nov 14
Who’s Ready For $30 Crude Oil Price? - 23rd Nov 14
Strategic, Methodological and Developmental Importance of Knowledge Consumption - 23rd Nov 14
Manipulated Stock Market Short Squeezes to Another All Time High - The China Syndrome - 23rd Nov 14
Gold Price 2015 - 22nd Nov 14
Stock Market Medium Term Top? - 22nd Nov 14
Is the Gold And Silver Golden Rule Broken? - 22nd Nov 14
Malaysia's Subsidy and Budget Deficit Conundrum - 22nd Nov 14
Investors Hated Gold at Precisely the Wrong Time: What About Now? - 22nd Nov 14
Gold and GLD ETF Selloff - 22nd Nov 14
Currency Wars, the Ruble and Keynes - 21st Nov 14
Stock Market Investor Sentiment in The Balance - 21st Nov 14
Two Biotech Stocks Set to Double on One Powerful Catalyst - 21st Nov 14
Swiss Gold Poll Likely Tighter Than Polls Suggest - 21st Nov 14
Gold's Volatility and Other Things to Watch - 21st Nov 14
Australia Stock Market and AUD Dollar Analysis (ASX200 and AUDUSD) - 21st Nov 14
New Algae Research May Have Uncovered an “Energy Forest” Under the Sea - 21st Nov 14
The Cultural and Political Consequences of Fiat Money - 20th Nov 14
United States Social Crisis - No One Told You When to Run, You Missed the Starting Gun! - 20th Nov 14
Euro-Zone Tooth Fairy Economics, Spain Needs to leave the Euro - 20th Nov 14
Ebola Threat Remains a Risk - New Deaths in Nebraska and New York - 20th Nov 14
Stock Market and the Jaws of Life or Death? - 20th Nov 14
Putin’s World: Why Russia’s Showdown with the West Will Worsen - 20th Nov 14
Making Money While The World Burns - 20th Nov 14
Why This "Quiet Zone" Is Now Tech Stocks Biggest Profit Sector - 20th Nov 14

Free Instant Analysis

Free Instant Technical Analysis


Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Gold Report 2015

Ellen Brown endorses Bernanke and QE2

Politics / Quantitative Easing Nov 26, 2010 - 05:06 AM GMT

By: Gary_North

Politics

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleIn my November 22 article announcing Ellen Brown's defection to the Federal Reserve, I wrote this:

If she tries to defend herself by saying, "This is consistent with what I have always said," then she is dumber than dirt, or else she thinks her followers are dumber than dirt.


She responded on November 24 with a long article saying that this was no defection.

Gary North, who purports to be an expert on the errors in my book Web of Debt, has evidently not actually read it. In an article posted on the Market Oracle on November 23, he says that in calling QE2 a "bold precedent," I have switched sides. He apparently missed the chapter I wrote on this subject, first published in "Web of Debt" in 2007, saying exactly what I am saying now.

The Federal Reserve is finally using its "quantitative easing" (QE) tool to good purpose, and I'm endorsing that, not just for our central bank but for any central bank anywhere that would be so bold.

We are back to these two choices: (1) she is dumber than dirt; (2) she thinks her followers are dumber than dirt. I really can't decide whether it's #2 or both #1 and #2.

I have never before argued publicly with anyone this intellectually ill-equipped. I have been at this for 45 years, and Ellen Brown is really, truly defenseless intellectually. Anyone who goes through my 52 original criticisms and my 30 responses to her responses will see why I make this judgment.

At this point, it is time for me to move to my next phase of criticism. My articles smoked her out. She finally came clean. She is – and says she always has been – a supporter of mass monetary inflation, no matter who prints the money. If the central bank does this, that's fine with her.

Having smoked her out, I now go to the next stage of my criticism. Ellen Brown is the Pied Piper of Greenbackism. Her goal now is to lead the Greenback faithful back into the camp of the Federal Reserve System.

She positioned Web of Debt as an anti-FED book. The cover pictures the FED as a spider.

If we are to believe her now, this was fake from day one. She never cared who does the inflating, she now says. If Bernanke will do it, that's fine with her, she now says.

In all my years of reading leftists – and she is a leftist – I have never seen anything like this. She built a following on this theme: "The Federal Reserve System is evil, because it is part of the fractional reserve banking system. The FED is privately owned. It does not issue real money. Real money is issued only by Congress." Then, in the space of four days, she tells her followers that the Federal Reserve is doing the right thing. It is in fact the model for all other central banks.

When you click through to the page where her latest article is posted, you will also find a posting by a reader who calls her on QE2's inflation. He cites TANSTAFFL: there ain't no such thing as a free lunch. Here is her answer – the monetary theory of her book, as I explained from the beginning.

We're not getting something for nothing. The government gets goods and services and pays for them with dollars, which represent claims on the American people for an equivalent sum in goods and services. The American people have received value and acknowledge that they owe value in return. That's what money is, and it should originate with the government, not with banks. It should, but our government won't do it, so the next best thing is to borrow from our own central bank, which creates the money and lends it interest-free. Rolled over indefinitely, that amounts to the same thing.

I have never seen anything like this. She built a large following with her book. Her following came to her because she was a forthright critic of the Federal Reserve System. Now she says that, while it is best to have Congress print the fiat money, "our government won't do it, so the next best thing is to borrow from our own central bank, which creates the money and lends it interest-free. Rolled over indefinitely, that amounts to the same thing."

Got that? The Federal Reserve System is "the next best thing."

It does no good to pursue her on this. Ellen Brown is beyond my powers of psychological analysis.

But what about her followers? They joined her because she was the most visible opponent of the Federal Reserve who was not a gold coin standard person, i.e., not an Austrian School critic of the FED. She seemed to have all the answers. She had that neat book cover, with the FED as a spider. But now, in just four days, she says there is no big difference between the FED's fiat money and Congress's fiat money (Greenbacks). The seeming differences, she says, "amount to the same thing."

They do? You mean the book cover was a huge fraud? You mean that the FED is not the evil spider? That is exactly what she means.

BETRAYAL

This is betrayal. I have never seen anything like this.

I have seen people switch. When Chicago School economist-judge Richard Posner went Keynesian in 2009 at the age of 70, overturning all of the work of a lifetime, he set the standard. But he has now been eclipsed by Ellen Brown. She switched, yet says she hasn't. This says, loud and clear, "I sucked you in, you dumb clucks!."

My guess is that most of her followers will not bat an eye. "We're with you, Ellen!" They are, indeed. They are now neutralized. They will say no more in criticism of the Federal Reserve System. The FED has now been baptized by the high priestess of fiat money. It is now sacrosanct – second only to Congress in the Holy of Holies.

This is fate of every crackpot movement. It attracts people who are upset with the world. They don't know exactly what is wrong, but something is. Then the crackpot comes with THE ONE TRUE ANALYSIS and the inevitable ONE TRUE ANSWER. Implement this solution, and the nightmare will end: no muss, no fuss.

There are always naive, trusting people who will join the ranks of the "liberated" hard core. They feel that they are part of SOMETHING REALLY BIG. They are part of THE WAVE OF THE FUTURE. The Communists attracted such people for over a century. Their brave new world went down in less than a year. It left them high and dry.

The Greenback movement has always been led by crackpots offering THE BIG SOLUTION. It has attracted people who want a leader. They don't care what the creed of the "church" is. They just want leadership. They want to follow.

They are sitting ducks.

Ellen Brown gave them hope: hope in fiat money issued by Congress. Now she has announced a bait-and-switch. She brought them into her circle by positioning herself as the FED's #1 critic. Then, three years later – 72 hours after I finish answering all 30 of her responses – she announced that the FED is the next best thing.

What does a person do who has been attracted to her by her forthright stand in The Web of Debt? She has just called him a fool. How? By calling me a fool.

He apparently missed the chapter I wrote on this subject, first published in "Web of Debt" in 2007, saying exactly what I am saying now.

He also failed to see this. He committed himself intellectually and emotionally to her, and now she calls him a fool, a chump, a rube. She calls all of her followers chumps.

"Stick with me, chumps. You have no idea where I'll lead you next. But you will follow. All of you will follow. I have led all of you into the land of Oz. I, in fact, am the Wizard. I can turn night into day. I can turn opposition to the FED into support of the FED. Above all, I can turn paper money into wealth. I said that from day one. You swallowed that, chumps. There is no limit to what you people will swallow."

She is right. There is no limit.

Gary North [send him mail ] is the author of Mises on Money . Visit http://www.garynorth.com . He is also the author of a free 20-volume series, An Economic Commentary on the Bible .

http://www.lewrockwell.com

© 2010 Copyright Gary North / LewRockwell.com - All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.


© 2005-2014 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Comments

Mike From Australia.
28 Nov 10, 20:06
Good grief

It's fine Gary.

All you need to do is come up with a cunning counter theory instead of making economics personal.

It is fine what she is doing, and you could use the opportunity to elaborate your own theories further.

Mike


John Williams
06 Dec 10, 14:29
Ellen Brown Compromising between lesser of 2 evils.

Ellen Brown is doing what people have done since modern government came in to being she is compromising on the lesser of two evils. Most of the population of the U.S. would agree they do the same thing every 2 years when elections come up. The point you seem to miss is that if interest is zero and money increases at the same rate as productivity %2-%3 percent a year their is no way inflation could result short of counterfeiters acquiring plates to print money.

As long as aggregate money growth is equivalent to aggregate productivity growth there will be no aggregate inflation or deflation once homeostasis is reached. The price of some goods may drop or rise depending on supply and demand but new products will be created to profit from the liquidity increases resulting from productivity increases or old goods will be dropped in response to countervailing forces but overall the system would be stable. Instead of focusing on the individual price of goods a sane monetary system would focus on the stability of the whole system by aligning currency increases to productivity increases. Productivity increases cannot be forecast but retroactive corrections can be instituted easily by printing less currency if to much money has been released vs productivity increases or raising the amount of currency produced if projections of productivity increases were low.

Decentralized state-banks who acted as mini feds and used profits to offset taxes such as North Dakota does or pure state-owned banks with healthy incentives for management who meet economic targets set by the state would be preferable to a centrally run economic system such as the fed which is a capitalist version of communism. Instead of the state directing how much toilet paper to make the fed directs where capital should go. The end result is the same as can be seen by the current state of affairs, a disaster. One centralized semi government institution cannot control the market of 350 million people no matter how much it delegates. It removes all flexibility and diversity leading to situations analogous to clones of plants, if one plant is susceptible to a disease it wipes them all out. State banks could return much needed decentralized diversity to the financial sector along with an enlightened self interest that does not solely look to short term individual profits but makes overarching goals and strategies that align individual prosperity with societal prosperity a main priority.

Interest can be incorporated but instead of repayment of interest depending on 3rd parties making future loans, since banks do not monetize accrued interest and spend it, state banks could immediately spend accrued interest on expenditures so it is immediately available to repay interest on existing loans. The repercussions of the current centralized system is that when banks stop lending we get a rapidly decreasing M3 money supply as it is sucked up to repay loans. This is exactly what has happened and can be verified by checking 3rd party M3 money supply estimates from the beginning of 2009 to now. If Government lent money and spent the interest immediately on expenditure taxes would drop drastically and interest repayment would not be dependent on future 3rd parties getting loans.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

Free Report - Financial Markets 2014