Best of the Week
Most Popular
1.Stocks Bear Market Apocalypse Imminent Crash Gets Nuked Again - Nadeem_Walayat
2.Gold And Silver – A Reality Check - Michael_Noonan
3.The Killer Ape, Human Evolution, Artificial Intelligence and Extinction End Game - Nadeem_Walayat
4.Stock Market S&P 500 Volatility-Based Price Probability Range - Richard_Shaw
5.A Stocks Bear Market Is Now More Likely Than Not - Richard_Shaw
6.Money Supply and the Fed’s Serious Inflation Risks - Zeal_LLC
7.More Selling for Stock Market, Gold? - Brad_Gudgeon
8.Gold, Silver Precious Metals: a Critical Week Ahead - Rambus_Chartology
9.Gold Price Change in Character - Gary_Savage
10.Advice for Biotech Investors: 'Hold Your Powder' 'til Winter - TLSReport
Last 5 days
Stock Market Rally May be Broken - 9th Oct 15
Gold Stocks Major Breakout - 9th Oct 15
Contrarian Investing - Being the 10th Man - 9th Oct 15
U.S. Can Expect Recession in 1-3 Years - 9th Oct 15
The Greater Economic Depression Deep State - 9th Oct 15
Financial Markets Calm Before the Storm? - 9th Oct 15
Stock Market History Calling, Says Performance will be Crappy for Another ~10 years! - 9th Oct 15
Why This Feels Like an Economic Depression for Most People - 9th Oct 15
Dr Copper Back from the Dead - Time to Buy or Blink - 8th Oct 15
Glencore Rout Blamed on Short Sellers Playing With CDS - 8th Oct 15
The Real Reason for the Refugee Crisis You Won’t Hear About in the Media - 8th Oct 15
US Stocks: The [Trend]Line Between Bull and Bear Market - 8th Oct 15
Bundesbank “Reassures” Re. Gold Bullion Reserves as Deutsche Bank Shocks With €6 Billion Loss Warning - 8th Oct 15
How Our Aversion To Change Leads Us Into Danger - 8th Oct 15
Moving Stem Cell Research Forward: Bernie Siegel of the Genetics Policy Institute - 8th Oct 15
Stock Market VERY IMPORTANT Turn Date - 7th Oct 15
The 5th Convergence…An Economic & Financial Superstorm That Will Devastate America - 7th Oct 15
Summers Grades Janet Yellen's Fed Performance 'Incomplete' - 7th Oct 15
Gold Versus Central Banks Paper Ponzi - 7th Oct 15
QE3 is Over Get Ready for QE4 - 7th Oct 15
How to Profit from Government Mandates in Biofuels - 7th Oct 15
A Key Oil Price Trend That Everyone Is Missing - 6th Oct 15
Stock Market Turn Appears to Have Been Made - 6th Oct 15
Designing a Dividend Growth Portfolio for a Specific Retirement Yield Objective - 6th Oct 15
Peter Schiff Predicts Gold Price Breakout - Video - 6th Oct 15
Theresa May Declares War on Immigration - Conference Speech Full Transcript - 6th Oct 15
Is Russia Plotting To Bring Down OPEC? - 6th Oct 15
Target Date Funds As Aid In Retirement Investment Portfolio Design - 6th Oct 15
Stocks Bear Market Apocalypse Imminent Crash Gets Nuked Again - 6th Oct 15
Redesigning Internet and Facebook to Explore Their Full Potentialities... - 5th Oct 15
Nightshades Curb Your Enthusiasm - 5th Oct 15
U.S. Recession Watch, High-Yield – Rising Defaults - 5th Oct 15
The Social Challenge to Find Humanity in Capitalism - 5th Oct 15
Fed Interest Rate Hike: "I don't care. It doesn't really make much of a difference" - 5th Oct 15
Gold Rose 2.2%, Silver Surged 5.4% After Poor Jobs Number On Friday - 5th Oct 15
Gold, Silver Precious Metals: a Critical Week Ahead - 5th Oct 15
Stock Market Correction Still in Force - 5th Oct 15
Gold Price Change in Character - 5th Oct 15
Putin’s Blitz Leaves Washington Rankled and Confused - 4th Oct 15
More Selling for Stock Market, Gold? - 4th Oct 15

Free Instant Analysis

Free Instant Technical Analysis

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Italian Prosecutor Charges Fitch and S&P Employees With Culpable Incompetence

Interest-Rates / Credit Crisis 2012 Nov 14, 2012 - 03:51 AM GMT

By: Andrew_Butter

Interest-Rates Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleI noticed that the public prosecutor in some remote corner of Italy is attempting to get a clutch of hapless employees of S&P and Fitch charged with…well I‘m not quite sure what? Public disorder…incompetence…economic terrorism…driving whilst under the influence of America?

Apparently about a year ago they downgraded Italy, which caused a bit of a stir, particularly since they released the news when the markets were open and didn’t warn the Italian government they were going to do that. Fitch of course are denying all charges, they maintain that they have the right to be as incompetent as they like and if they want to stamp AAA on the rump of a collateralized debt obligation lovingly fabricated by God’s Workers, prior to being sold to pension funds run by dumb foreigners who don’t read English too good, then that is up to them, particularly if they make good fees doing that.

I took a view on the Italian 10-Year eighteen months ago when the yield hit 6%, I said “BUY”, as is illustrated by this chart;

OK, that’s not one of my best predictions (not the worst either, I got gold more wrong than that in the past). And well, if you bought at 6% then and held, you would still be in the money, although you might have had a few moments of nervousness on the way; but if you had sold a month later at 5% (well I’m not going to give the whole story away am I?)…and then gone back in again at 6% you would have double-dipped.

There again my prediction of a fall to 4% in a year was, let’s say, somewhat optimistic; although there was an element of winding up the doomsayers in that, how many times must a doomsayer say the world is going to end…before it ends? There again also, if those economic terrorists from S&P and Fitch had not stepped in and started manipulating the market and spreading fear and panic for their own evil-ends, my prediction might have worked out. Personally I think they should be dressed up in orange jump-suits and blindfolds and get sent to Guantanamo for some good-old-fashioned water-boarding.

I noticed in the reports that one of the hapless Fitch incompetents apparently put out a memo that said Italian debt is owed mainly by foreigners, as I said, and as one of the less incompetent analysts at Fitch pointed out to the more incompetent one; that is not true. I say again:

  1. Total Italian debt burden (private plus public) is 250% of GDP (compared with over 350% in USA). Granted the public debt is 120% of GDP, but over 50% of that is owed to Italians living in Italy; hardly a flight-risk.
  2. Net external liabilities are 15% of GDP compared with more than 100% for Portugal and Greece.
  3.  The country makes things, it has tourism and it has opera, and food and football, and guys who live with their mom until they get married; until recently its trade deficit was negligible (goods + services). Right now that’s about 2% of GDP mainly due to having to buy oil on the spot market to replace oil traditionally supplied by Libya. By comparison, USA’s trade deficit is about 3.5% of GDP (last four quarters).

There was never any doubt that the Europeans would figure out a way to get around the rules so they could do a TALF (not a TARP), just like I predicted Mein Liebste Angela bless her heart would do in September 2011,

So I guess the world hasn’t quite come to an end and no one is using wheelbarrows or the electronic equivalent to buy groceries, just yet. Well fancy that? Of course the world could end tomorrow, now that’s something to look forward to.

With regard to the charges, the prosecutor says he has a strong case, and indeed it’s easy to see how a charge of incompetence by rating agencies, could fly. But is incompetence a crime?

Now that’s an interesting one, imagine the defense of the 9/11 mastermind. ”Well your honor I just told them to fly around and cause fear and panic, the fact they flew into a building is just because they were incompetent, how can you say that’s my fault?”

By Andrew Butter

Twenty years doing market analysis and valuations for investors in the Middle East, USA, and Europe. Ex-Toxic-Asset assembly-line worker; lives in Dubai.

© 2012 Copyright Andrew Butter- All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

Andrew Butter Archive

© 2005-2015 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

Biggest Debt Bomb in History