Most Popular
1. Dow Max Drawdown Bear Stock Market 2022 - Accumulating Deviations from the Highs - 21st Feb 22
2.Putin Starts WW3 in Ukraine, Will Use Tactical Nuclear Weapons, China Prepares Taiwan Blitzkrieg - 28th Feb 22
3.World War 3 Phase 1 - Putin WINS Ukraine War! - 25th Feb 22
4.INVESTORS SEDUCED by CNBC and the STOCK CHARTS COMPLETELY MISS the BIG PICTURE! - 10th Feb 22
5.Will There Be A 2024 US Presidential Election? - 3rd Mar 22
6.Gold and SIlver, Precious Metals Sector Is at a Terrific Buy Spot - 6th Feb 22
7.Why Putin Wants the WHOLE of Ukraine - World War 3 Untended Consequences - 6th Feb 22
8.Dow Stock Market Expected Max Drawdown 2022 - 19th Feb 22
9.Stock Market Calm In the Eye of the Inflation Storm - 4th Mar 22
10.M = F - Everything is Waving! Stock Market Forward Guidance - 7th Mar 22
Last 7 days
Why Ray Dalio is WRONG About China - Principles for Dealing with the Changing World Order - 24th May 22
Globalists Convene to Plan Central Bank Digital Currencies - 24th May 22
After Recent Highs, What’s Next for the Gold Junior Miners? - 24th May 22
Why APPLE Could CRASH the Stock Market! - 21st May 22
Why Is Crude Oil Ignoring US Inventories? - 21st May 22
Here is Why I’m Still Bullish on Gold Mining Stocks - 21st May 22
THE INFLATION MEGA-TREND QE4EVER! - 20th May 22
US Real Estate Investors – Is There An End In Sight? - 20th May 22
How Technology Affected the Gaming Industry - 20th May 22
How To Set And Achieve Reasonable Goals For Your Company - 20th May 22
How Low Could the Amazon (AMZN) Stock Price Fall? - 19th May 22
Bitten by FANG? Clocked by Cryptos? -- 'Air Pockets' Everywhere - 19th May 22
Northern General Hospital Orthopedics Fractures and and Ankle Clinic Consultations Real Patient Experience - 19th May 22
Cathie Wood Goes All in on Teladoc, ARKK INSANE Noob Investing Strategy! - 17th May 22
This is Anything but Positive for US Housing Market - 17th May 22
What Should We Do If There Is No Fed Monetary Policy Pivot? - 17th May 22
All Possible Ways to Earn Free Litecoin - 17th May 22
How low Could the Amazon Stock Price Fall? - 16th May 22
Cathy Wood ARKK INSANITY There is NO Coming Back! - 16th May 22
NASDAQ 100 Stock Market LOWER LOWS & LOWER HIGH - 16th May 22
Sanctions, trade wars worsen US inflation - 16th May 22
AI Tech Stocks Earnings BloodBath Buying Opportunity - 14th May 22
Futures Contract – Trading Crude Oil With USO - 14th May 22
How to Get Kaspersky Internet Security for 80% Discount! Do not Pay Renewal Price! - 14th May 22
Sagittarius A* Super Massive Black Hole Monster at Centre of Our Galaxy REVEALED! - 14th May 22
UK Public Debt Smoking Inflation Gun - 13th May 22
What Happens When the Stock Market Dip Keeps Dipping? - 13th May 22
Biden Seeks Inflation Scapegoats; Gold Advocate Wins GOP Primary - 13th May 22
Apple and Microsoft Nuts Are About to CRACK and Send Stock Market Sharply Lower - 12th May 22
The War on Gold Ensures the Dollar’s Downfall - 12th May 22

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Protect your Wealth by Investing in AI Tech Stocks

Vote Now - Should the US Attack Iran's nuclear and military infrastructure?

Politics / Iran Apr 10, 2007 - 12:42 PM GMT

By: Nadeem_Walayat

Politics

As the US military build up continues to gain momentum in the Persian Gulf, which includes some 50 warships comprising of 2 aircraft carrier battle groups. These military assets are reinforced by well established military bases in neighbouring countries, with hundreds of war planes to enable around the clock bombing capability.

Any attack against Iran would firstly be targeted at Iranian air bases and command and control structures as well as naval ports so as to limit the immediate retaliatory response, before around the clock bombing of the well dug in Iranian Nuclear facilities would take place.

We ask the question should the US attack Iran's nuclear & military infrastructure ?


Many articles have been published with reasons both for and against a US attack on Iran's nuclear facilities on the Market Oracle website -

Iran Crisis and the War of Blackmail - Crude Oil could go to New High

Iran - Iran - Iran - Despite release of British hostages, US Attack still Imminent

Shock and Awe II - The Consequences of an US attack on Iran

Iran crisis still ready to blow … US preparing to Attack

 

In summary, three reasons both for and against an US attack on Iran

YES - Iran's Nuclear infrastructure and military should be attacked because-

  1. Nuclear weapons in the hands of an Islamic fundamentalist regime in Iran that holds apocalyptic visions of martyrdom in the name of God, poses a far greater risk to the world then the consequences of the expected retaliatory action following a US attack on Iran.
  2. The US perceives Iranian interference in Iraq as one of the key reasons for the ongoing instability, as Iran attempts to increase its dominance over the region, and importantly significant crude oil reserves that the US is seeking to secure as US oil reserves dry up. .Therefore an attack that succeeds in destroying Iran's nuclear infrastructure would have the effect of diminishing Iranian influence in the region and help to stabalise Iraq enabling Iraqi oil to flow more freely.
  3. Iran is continuing to violate US resolutions calling on it to suspend Uranium enrichment.

NO - Iran should not be attacked because -

  1. Attacking Iran's nuclear infrastructure would require a massive aerial campaign and given that much of the infrastructure is widespread and well dug in numbering some 1500 targets, it is not wholly certain that the objective of destroying the infrastructure can be achieved. An attack would reinforce Iran 's resolve that the only deterrence against attack would be for Iran to double its efforts to secure a nuclear deterrence regardless of the consequences. Iran is still many years away from developing a nuclear weapon, therefore proper and serious diplomatic negotiations should be entered into which should include security guarantees against any attack against Iran by the US or Israel in exchange for Iran abandoning its nuclear programme. To date the Bush Administration has shown itself as totally inept in negotiating anything of substance with anyone let alone the Iranians.
  2. Iran's retaliatory response is expected to widen the war in the middle east, the conflagration will not only further destablise Iraq and Afghanistan but also aim to bring Israel into another war with Lebanon, and probably make the Gulf of Harmuz unusable to shipping of crude oil. The Iranian Shiite ideology of martyrdom has already taken 1,000,000 lives during the Iran / Iraq war and the hardline fundamentalist regime has taken countless iranian lives in, internal purges. The effect of a US attack would unite the country in favour of a new holy war, that would enable the regime to deploy countless millions of soldiers as cannon fodder against the new wider war. Therefore would the US have the stomach for US deaths on par with if not greater than that of Vietnam ? Attacking Iran is not the solution to the problem.
  3. The Price of Oil would likely rally to well beyond $80 and perhaps beyond $100. This would put a strain on already weakening western economies and raise the specter of stagflation, leading to higher interest rates and a resulting recession during 2008. The financial markets would panic on the attack, with especially heavy selling of dollar assets, and hurry the process along towards a recession in early 2008.

The Market Oracle Opinion Poll : Should the US Attack Iran's nuclear and military infrastructure?

YES - Iran should be attacked and its nuclear facilities destroyed.

NO - Iran's nuclear infrastructure should be dismantled via negotiations.

Click here to vote (Registration is Not necessary)

Click Here for results so far - Final Results and analysis will be published on 18th April 2007.

 

By Nadeem Walayat

Copyright © MarketOracle.co.uk 2007

The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Forecasting & Analysis online publication. We aim to cut through the noise cluttering traditional sources of market analysis and get to the key points of where the markets are at and where they are expected to move to next ! http://www.marketoracle.co.uk

Attention editors and publishers ! This article can be republished. Republished articles MUST include attribution to the author and the above short paragraph including links to MarketOracle.co.uk


© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Comments

Ruth
12 Apr 07, 04:55
Re: Vote Now - Should the US Attack Iran's nuclear and military infrastructure?
I wonder what happened to the comment I posted yesterday. I was serious, and my comment bears repeating:
1. Yes and No in this poll are not opposites. Both "choices" take is for granted that we all agree that it is necessary to dismantle Iran's nuclear power industry.
2. Asking human beings to vote whether or not to attack and slaughter the innocent people of another nation is an outrageous invitation to immorality. The Market Oracle editors might benefit from a look at some children and then a look in the mirror. Sure, it's fine for a business publication to focus on economic consequences, but it's going too far to imply that a crime against international law is a perfectly normal "option."

EDITOR COMMENT - Deleted with SPAM purge which occurs every hour or so.
defcon1
12 Apr 07, 11:11
Re: Vote Now - Should the US Attack Iran's nuclear and military infrastructure?
Of course the US is going to attack Iran, they stopped selling the US oil. In American eyes thats major blackmail and a threat to its national security. Alot of people don't get the extent of that. That's alot of power Iran is wielding and they need to grow up and be a big boy if they want nuclear power like the rest of the big boys who have nuclear power.


Nadeem_Walayat
12 Apr 07, 18:49
Re: Vote Now - Should the US Attack Iran's nuclear and military infrastructure?
The context of the poll is the build up to an attack against Iran as a consquence of its nuclear program.

The point is that one way or another its nuclear weapons programme will be dismantled.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in