Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. US Housing Market House Prices Bull Market Trend Current State - Nadeem_Walayat
2.Gold and Silver End of Week Technical, CoT and Fundamental Status - Gary_Tanashian
3.Stock Market Dow Trend Forecast - April Update - Nadeem_Walayat
4.When Will the Stock Market’s Rally Stop? - Troy_Bombardia
5.Russia and China Intend to Drain the West of Its Gold - MoneyMetals
6.BAIDU (BIDU) - Top 10 Artificial Intelligence Stocks Investing To Profit from AI Mega-trend - Nadeem_Walayat
7.Stop Feeding the Chinese Empire - ‘Belt and Road’ Trojan Horse - Richard_Mills
8.Stock Market US China Trade War Panic! Trend Forecast May 2019 Update - Nadeem_Walayat
9.US China Trade Impasse Threatens US Lithium, Rare Earth Imports - Richard_Mills
10.How to Invest in AI Stocks to Profit from the Machine Intelligence Mega-trend - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
Silver Short-Term Trend Analysis - 26th June 19
Iran and the Dying Days Of the US Empire - 26th June 19
Why a Saturated Online Gaming Market Spells Good News for Gamblers - 26th June 19
Natural Gas Sets Up Bottom Pattern - 26th June 19
Has Gold Price Broken Out Or Not? Technicals And Fundamentals - 26th June 19
Stocks and XAU Gold Miners Next Bull and Bear Markets are Now Set Up - 26th June 19
Gold Price Trend Forcast to End September 2019 - Video - 25th June 19
Today’s Pets.com and NINJA Loan Economy - 25th June 19
Testing the Fed’s Narrative with the Fed’s Data: QT Edition - 25th June 19
What "Pro Traders" use to Find Profitable Trades - eBook - 25th June 19
GDX Gold Stocks ETF - 25th June 19
What Does Facebook’s LIBRA New Crytocurrency Really Offer? - 25th June 19
Why Bond Investors MUST Be Paying Attention to Puerto Rico - 25th June 19
The Next Great Depression in the Making - 25th June 19
The Bad News About Record-Low Unemployment - 24th June 19
Stock Market New High, but…! - 24th June 19
Formula for when the Great Stock Market Rally Ends - 24th June 19
How To Time Market Tops and Bottoms - 24th June 19
5 basic tips to help mitigate the vulnerability inherent in email communications - 24th June 19
Will Google AI Kill Us? Man vs Machine Intelligence - 24th June 19
Why are Central Banks Buying Gold and Dumping Dollars? - 23rd June 19
Financial Sector Paints A Clear Picture For Stock Market Trading Profits - 23rd June 19
What You Should Look While Choosing Online Casino - 23rd June 19
INTEL (INTC) Stock Investing to Profit From AI Machine Learning Boom - 22nd June 19
Here’s Why You Should Drive a Piece of Crap Car - 22nd June 19
How Do Stock Prices React to Fed Interest Rate Cuts? - 22nd June 19
Gold Bull Market Breaking Out! - 21st June 19
Post-FOMC Commentary: Delusions of Grandeur - 21st June 19
Gold Scores Gains as Draghi and Powel Grow Concerned - 21st June 19
Potential Upside Targets for Gold Stocks - 21st June 19
Gold Price Trend Forcast to End September 2019 - 21st June 19
The Gold (and Silver) Volcano Is Ready to Erupt - 21st June 19
Fed Leaves Rates Unchanged – Gold & Stocks Rally/Dollar Falls - 21st June 19
Silver Medium-Term Trend Analysis - 20th June 19
Gold Mining Stocks Waiting on This Chart - 20th June 19
A Key Gold Bull Market Signal - 20th June 19
Money Saving Kids Gardening Growing Giant Sunflowers Summer Fun - 20th June 19
Investing in APPLE (AAPL) to Profit From AI Machine Learning Stocks - 20th June 19
Small Cap Stocks May Lead A Market Rally - 20th June 19 -
Interest Rates Square Minus Zero - 20th June 19
Advice for Financing a Luxury Vehicle - 20th June 19
Stock Market Final Blow Off Top Just Hit… Next Week Comes the FIREWORKS - 20th June 19
US Dollar Rallies Off Support But Is This A Top Or Bottom? - 19th June 19
Most Income Investors Are Picking Up Nickels in Front of a Steamroller - 19th June 19
Is the Stock Market’s Volatility About to Spike? - 19th June 19
Facebook's Libra Crypto currency vs Bitcoin: Five Key Differences - 19th June 19
Fed May Trigger Wild Swing In Stock Index and Precious Metals - 19th June 19
How Long Do Land Rover Discovery Sport Brake Pads Last? - 19th June 19
Gold Golden 'Moment of Truth' Is Upon Us: $1,400-Plus or Not? - 18th June 19
Exceptional Times for Gold Warrant Special Attention - 18th June 19
The Stock Market Has Gone Nowhere and Volume is Low. What’s Next - 18th June 19
Silver Long-Term Trend Analysis - 18th June 19
IBM - Watson Deep Learning - AI Stocks Investing - Video - 18th June 19
Investors are Confident, Bullish and Buying Stocks, but… - 18th June 19
Gold and Silver Reversals – Impossible Not to Notice - 18th June 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Gold Price Trend Forecast Summer 2019

Citigroup Stock Price Spread Market Manipulation Conspiracy or Free Market?

Companies / Market Manipulation Apr 21, 2009 - 03:01 AM GMT

By: Money_Morning

Companies

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleKeith Fitz-Gerald writes: BEIJING, PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF CHINA - From my vantage point here in Beijing this week, I find my mind drifting this morning closer to home and specifically back to Citigroup Inc. (C).


Shares are under pressure for reasons that most investors, particularly those who were looking for a repeat of Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS) - don’t understand - especially after a “favorable” conference call and results that were widely interpreted as positive. Others are taking it a step further and suggesting there’s a massive capitalist “conspiracy” at play in the financial sector - especially now that the government is so heavily involved.

While I’m not ruling out the fact that there’s some backroom-government maneuvering at work, my experience as a veteran trader suggests there’s a much more logical explanation - not unlike the infamous “Bin Laden Trade” rumor that I dispelled in the past, or the “Dark Pools” that I brought to light. Unfortunately - as was true of the Bin Laden and Dark Pools examples - the Citigroup case is shaping up as yet another example of a situation in which the proverbial “little guy” could get caught short once again as the Big Money crowd has its way and runs roughshod all over Wall Street.

It all comes down to Economics 101 - basic supply and demand. Here’s why.

When Simple Supply and Demand Isn’t so Simple After All

Most retail investors purchase shares in a company such as Citi on the assumption that it’s going rise in price over time. And that’s good for stock prices. Supply and demand tells us so.

Back in early March, for instance, when Citigroup Chief Executive Officer Vikram S. Pandit’s “we’ve made money” memo leaked into the mainstream press, the good news stoked investor demand for Citi’s shares - causing them to shoot up 38% in one day.

But as we all learned in Econ 101, there’s another part of this formula - supply. Even as investor demand was increasing, there’s also an incredible incentive to short the stock - in no small part due to Citi’s Feb. 27 announcement that it would exchange as much as $52.5 billion in preferred stock for common stock beginning in April at an approximate price of $3.25 per share. This all has to do with a type of trading known as “stock arbitrage,” meaning that sophisticated investors can play one value off another and profit from the difference.

In this case, the difference was between the value of Citi’s preferred shares - those that were part of the deal announced in February - and Citi’s common shares. Because there is enough money at work, the pressure from the arbitrageurs actually creates something of a reverse incentive for the banking giant’s common shares, to the effect that that the lower the price of the common shares when the conversion happens, the greater the profit traders who are in on the deal can make.

The bottom line: No matter how much the investing masses would like to see Citi’s share price increase, big money has been wagered that the bank’s stock price would fall first.

One Short Sale That’s in Short Supply

An investor who wanted to participate would have to buy Citigroup’s convertible preferred stock Series T, which closed Friday at $34.25. [Editor's Note: We prepared this piece and ran through these calculations using Friday's closing prices; however, Citi's shares fell a steep 19.45% yesterday (Monday) due to rising concerns that the bank's credit losses are continuing to mount.]

Under the terms of the deal announced in February, each $34.25 preferred share would convert to approximately 13.08 shares of common stock, which, at Friday’s price, was worth $47.73. This meant you could buy $47.73 worth of stock for $34.25 and lock in a 39.35% gain - again if the deal is not shelved or modified in any way, and assuming the $3.25 per share specified in February’s announcement remains set.

The risk is that the deal could be delayed or go away entirely depending on what the government’s so-called “stress tests” reveal, or if Citi simply decides it doesn’t want to play ball. Traders in on the deal are already dancing in the aisles. Those still on the outside are understandably drooling because the spread between Citi’s preferred shares and the common stock continues to widen. Adding fuel to the fire is the fact that repo desks all over Wall Street are calling in Citi’s shares, inducing bursts of forced short covering - which is making it even more difficult to put on new shorts.

To that end, when asked on a recent conference call whether the terms will change or the deal could go away, Citigroup Chief Financial Officer Edward J. “Ned” Kelly III said that he doesn’t think that will happen but still assigned a “5% chance the sun doesn’t come up,” Reuters said last week.

Conspiracy vs. Capitalism

If you’re a “glass-is-half-full” kind of investor (in short, an optimist), Kelly’s statement could be construed as a 95% confidence factor. Given that, I’m not surprised to have seen a huge jump in Citi options transactions. You may have noticed it, too. This means that there’s a huge contingent of traders who still want to participate in this potential arbitrage. But they are using derivatives to set up the same transaction - probably at a fraction of the cost and capital commitment.

Because Citi’s exchange offering pegs the $50 face value of Citi’s preferred shares against a market value of $34.25, the exchange terms include a 15% discount. Because regular Citi shares were trading at $3.65 on Friday, each preferred share was worth approximately 13.08 common shares, or $47.73. [At yesterday's close, Citigroup's preferred stock was trading at $29, and the common at $2.94].

Meanwhile - hang with me here - the difference between the price of Citi shares and the price set in the exchange offering is about 10%, which is nearly double the 5% difference of a week ago - a shift that reflects a change in the arbitrage value between the two.

Therefore, at a time when traders would normally have shorted the stock as part of the trade, they’re instead bypassing the rising cost of doing so by assembling what are called “synthetic shorts.” In case you’re not familiar with that term, synthetic shorts are a specialized type of options trade that involves buying puts and selling calls at the same strike prices to achieve the same risk/reward profile as an outright short in Citi stock. The advantage of a synthetic short is that you don’t have to go through the hassle of actually shorting the stock, or trying to borrow it in a hard-to-borrow market.

Not only does this make the trade infinitely more flexible, but potentially more profitable, too. As reported by Reuters, one hedge fund trader who is participating in the trade suggested that it could yield a “200% annualized profit, even after including the rising costs linked to shorting shares” - and that’s presumably true synthetically or otherwise.

At the end of the day, there’s no doubt there could be a massive conspiracy at work here. I’ve simply seen too much in my career and, in particular, in recent months to believe that many of the machinations we’re seeing are anything but deliberate monkey business.

Yet, I’ve also seen glimmers of pure capitalism at work and that’s what I think is really at play here - an aggressive and highly creative pursuit of profits.

As long as the spreads between preferred shares and common shares continue to widen, there’s uncertainty ahead. And as we know, uncertainty breeds opportunity.

At the end of the day it comes down to whether the investor wants to play it.

Money Morning/The Money Map Report

©2009 Monument Street Publishing. All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright laws of the United States and international treaties. Any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including on the world wide web), of content from this website, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Monument Street Publishing. 105 West Monument Street, Baltimore MD 21201, Email: customerservice@moneymorning.com

Disclaimer: Nothing published by Money Morning should be considered personalized investment advice. Although our employees may answer your general customer service questions, they are not licensed under securities laws to address your particular investment situation. No communication by our employees to you should be deemed as personalized investment advice. We expressly forbid our writers from having a financial interest in any security recommended to our readers. All of our employees and agents must wait 24 hours after on-line publication, or 72 hours after the mailing of printed-only publication prior to following an initial recommendation. Any investments recommended by Money Morning should be made only after consulting with your investment advisor and only after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company.

Money Morning Archive

© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules