Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Gold vs Cash in a Financial Crisis - Richard_Mills
2.Current Stock Market Rally Similarities To 1999 - Chris_Vermeulen
3.America See You On The Dark Side Of The Moon - Part2 - James_Quinn
4.Stock Market Trend Forecast Outlook for 2020 - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Who Said Stock Market Traders and Investor are Emotional Right Now? - Chris_Vermeulen
6.Gold Upswing and Lessons from Gold Tops - P_Radomski_CFA
7.Economic Tribulation is Coming, and Here is Why - Michael_Pento
8.What to Expect in Our Next Recession/Depression? - Raymond_Matison
9.The Fed Celebrates While Americans Drown in Financial Despair - John_Mauldin
10.Hi-yo Silver Away! - Richard_Mills
Last 7 days
PAYPAL WARNING - Your Stimulus Funds Are at Risk of Being Frozen for 6 Months! - 5th Apr 20
Stocks Hanging By the Fingernails? - 5th Apr 20
US Federal Budget Deficits: To $30 Trillion and Beyond - 5th Apr 20
The Lucrative Profitability Of A Move To Negative Interest Rates - Pandemic Edition - 5th Apr 20
Visa Denials: How to avoid it and what to do if your Visa is denied? - 5th Apr 20 - Uday Tank
WARNING PAYPAL Making a Grab for US $1200 Stimulus Payments - 4th Apr 20
US COVID-19 Death Toll Higher Than China’s Now. Will Gold Rally? - 4th Apr 20
Concerned That Asia Could Blow A Hole In Future Economic Recovery - 4th Apr 20
Bracing for Europe’s Coronavirus Contractionand Debt Crisis - 4th Apr 20
Stocks: When Grass Looks Greener on the Other Side of the ... Pond - 3rd Apr 20
How the C-Factor Could Decimate 2020 Global Gold and Silver Production - 3rd Apr 20
US Between Scylla and Charybdis Covid-19 - 3rd Apr 20
Covid19 What's Your Risk of Death Analysis by Age, Gender, Comorbidities and BMI - 3rd Apr 20
US Coronavirus Infections & Deaths Trend Trajectory - How Bad Will it Get? - 2nd Apr 20
Silver Looks Bearish Short to Medium Term - 2nd Apr 20
Mickey Fulp: 'Never Let a Good Crisis Go to Waste' - 2nd Apr 20
Stock Market Selloff Structure Explained – Fibonacci On Deck - 2nd Apr 20
COVID-19 FINANCIAL LOCKDOWN: Can PAYPAL Be Trusted to Handle US $1200 Stimulus Payments? - 2nd Apr 20
Day in the Life of Coronavirus LOCKDOWN - Sheffield, UK - 2nd Apr 20
UK Coronavirus Infections and Deaths Trend Trajectory - Deviation Against Forecast - 1st Apr 20
Huge Unemployment Is Coming. Will It Push Gold Prices Up? - 1st Apr 20
Gold Powerful 2008 Lessons That Apply Today - 1st Apr 20
US Coronavirus Infections and Deaths Projections Trend Forecast - Video - 1st Apr 20
From Global Virus Acceleration to Global Debt Explosion - 1st Apr 20
UK Supermarkets Coronavirus Panic Buying Before Lock Down - Tesco Empty Shelves - 1st Apr 20
Gold From a Failed Breakout to a Failed Breakdown - 1st Apr 20
P FOR PANDEMIC - 1st Apr 20
The Past Stock Market Week Was More Important Than You May Understand - 31st Mar 20
Coronavirus - No, You Do Not Hear the Fat Lady Warming Up - 31st Mar 20
Life, Religions, Business, Globalization & Information Technology In The Post-Corona Pandemics Age - 31st Mar 20
Three Charts Every Stock Market Trader and Investor Must See - 31st Mar 20
Coronavirus Stocks Bear Market Trend Forecast - Video - 31st Mar 20
Coronavirus Dow Stocks Bear Market Into End April 2020 Trend Forecast - 31st Mar 20
Is it better to have a loan or credit card debt when applying for a mortgage? - 31st Mar 20
US and UK Coronavirus Trend Trajectories vs Bear Market and AI Stocks Sector - 30th Mar 20
Are Gold and Silver Mirroring 1999 to 2011 Again? - 30th Mar 20
Stock Market Next Cycle Low 7th April - 30th Mar 20
United States Coronavirus Infections and Deaths Trend Forecasts Into End April 2020 - 29th Mar 20
Some Positives in a Virus Wracked World - 29th Mar 20
Expert Tips to Save on Your Business’s Office Supply Purchases - 29th Mar 20
An Investment in Life - 29th Mar 20
Sheffield Coronavirus Pandemic Infections and Deaths Forecast - 29th Mar 20
UK Coronavirus Infections and Deaths Projections Trend Forecast - Video - 28th Mar 20
The Great Coronavirus Depression - Things Are Going to Change. Here’s What We Should Do - 28th Mar 20
One of the Biggest Stock Market Short Covering Rallies in History May Be Imminent - 28th Mar 20
The Fed, the Coronavirus and Investing - 28th Mar 20
Women’s Fashion Trends in the UK this 2020 - 28th Mar 20
The Last Minsky Financial Snowflake Has Fallen – What Now? - 28th Mar 20
UK Coronavirus Infections and Deaths Projections Trend Forecast Into End April 2020 - 28th Mar 20
DJIA Coronavirus Stock Market Technical Trend Analysis - 27th Mar 20
US and UK Case Fatality Rate Forecast for End April 2020 - 27th Mar 20
US Stock Market Upswing Meets Employment Data - 27th Mar 20
Will the Fed Going Nuclear Help the Economy and Gold? - 27th Mar 20
What you need to know about the impact of inflation - 27th Mar 20
CoronaVirus Herd Immunity, Flattening the Curve and Case Fatality Rate Analysis - 27th Mar 20
NHS Hospitals Before Coronavirus Tsunami Hits (Sheffield), STAY INDOORS FINAL WARNING! - 27th Mar 20
CoronaVirus Curve, Stock Market Crash, and Mortgage Massacre - 27th Mar 20
Finding an Expert Car Accident Lawyer - 27th Mar 20
We Are Facing a Depression, Not a Recession - 26th Mar 20
US Housing Real Estate Market Concern - 26th Mar 20
Covid-19 Pandemic Affecting Bitcoin - 26th Mar 20
Italy Coronavirus Case Fataility Rate and Infections Trend Analysis - 26th Mar 20
Why Is Online Gambling Becoming More Popular? - 26th Mar 20
Dark Pools of Capital Profiting from Coronavirus Stock Markets CRASH! - 26th Mar 20
CoronaVirus Herd Immunity and Flattening the Curve - 25th Mar 20
Coronavirus Lesson #1 for Investors: Beware Predictions of Stock Market Bottoms - 25th Mar 20
CoronaVirus Stock Market Trend Implications - 25th Mar 20
Pandemonium in Precious Metals Market as Fear Gives Way to Command Economy - 25th Mar 20
Pandemics and Gold - 25th Mar 20
UK Coronavirus Hotspots - Cities with Highest Risks of Getting Infected - 25th Mar 20
WARNING US Coronavirus Infections and Deaths Going Ballistic! - 24th Mar 20
Coronavirus Crisis - Weeks Where Decades Happen - 24th Mar 20
Industry Trends: Online Casinos & Online Slots Game Market Analysis - 24th Mar 20
Five Amazingly High-Tech Products Just on the Market that You Should Check Out - 24th Mar 20
UK Coronavirus WARNING - Infections Trend Trajectory Worse than Italy - 24th Mar 20
Rick Rule: 'A Different Phrase for Stocks Bear Market Is Sale' - 24th Mar 20
Stock Market Minor Cycle Bounce - 24th Mar 20
Gold’s century - While stocks dominated headlines, gold quietly performed - 24th Mar 20
Big Tech Is Now On The Offensive Against The Coronavirus - 24th Mar 20
Socialism at Its Finest after Fed’s Bazooka Fails - 24th Mar 20
Dark Pools of Capital Profiting from Coronavirus Stock and Financial Markets CRASH! - 23rd Mar 20
Will Trump’s Free Cash Help the Economy and Gold Market? - 23rd Mar 20
Coronavirus Clarifies Priorities - 23rd Mar 20
Could the Coronavirus Cause the Next ‘Arab Spring’? - 23rd Mar 20
Concerned About The US Real Estate Market? Us Too! - 23rd Mar 20
Gold Stocks Peak Bleak? - 22nd Mar 20

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter


Understanding the Costs of Healthcare

Politics / Healthcare Sector Oct 04, 2009 - 07:58 AM GMT

By: D_W_MacKenzie


Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleRising costs are the main issue in the debate over healthcare reform. Most everybody thinks of healthcare as expensive, but there is much confusion over these costs. On September 9, President Obama attempted to clarify cost issues concerning the medical industry. The federal government will supposedly reduce costs, curtail abuses, and make healthcare services more affordable.

The president proposes creating a low-cost market for health insurance. Previously uninsured people would be required, with some exemptions, to buy health insurance — so as to avoid high-cost emergency-room visits. Businesses would be compelled to provide insurance, with some exemptions for the smallest businesses. The federal government would also promote preventative care and nonprofit health clinics.

Senator Baucus has proposed a new plan whereby people who do not buy health insurance will be fined $3,800. These fines will force people to buy insurance, and this will spread costs more broadly.

Economist Paul Craig Roberts criticizes proposals for forcing people to buy insurance. He argues that fining people who cannot afford health insurance is like "solving the homeless problem by requiring the homeless to purchase houses." Roberts recognizes that fines forcing more people to buy health insurance are the equivalent of a new tax. He objects to this new tax on the grounds that it is imposed on those who cannot afford it.

Roberts believes that taxes for healthcare should be apportioned according to the "ability-to-pay" principle. He favors a "single-payer, not-for-profit healthcare system." According to him, private healthcare does not work because of expensive medical technology, malpractice suits, bureaucratic third-party-payer costs, and the "cost" of shareholder returns.

The remarks that the president, Senator Baucus, and Paul Roberts have made regarding profits and executive compensation reveal problems with their understanding of economics. The president, for instance, sees profits and high executive salaries in insurance companies as unnecessary costs, fat that can be cut from the health industry. In economic terms, however, profits represent success in satisfying consumers of particular products at relatively low costs.

Successful executives keep revenues high by gaining market share and satisfying customers in large numbers. They also keep financial costs low by cutting waste in the use of labor, capital, and supplies. High profits are often a sign that companies are serving their consumers at a low cost.

The president's remarks regarding profits and executive salaries likely derive from the hostility towards all profits characteristic of many people on the Left (such as Michael Moore), rather than from sound economic reasoning. Executives earn high salaries by delivering high profits to owners, and high profits derive in part from keeping costs under control. Would a nonprofit, single-payer (i.e., taxpayer-funded) system also be run on a cost-minimizing basis?

"High profits are often a sign that companies are serving their consumers at a low cost."

The basic choice we have to make is between healthcare based on the profit motive and healthcare based on some kind of service principle. On the one hand, corporations do make profit by developing new drugs for consumers, and by manufacturing medical supplies and equipment. On the other hand, nonprofit clinics do exist, medical professionals do perform pro bono services, and some companies do donate medical supplies and equipment. But what serves the public best: private profit seeking, or the desire to do public service?

Of course, we don't want to assume that all profits and executive salaries derive from efficient management. Some executives increase the profitability of their operations through lobbying the government to secure state-granted privileges and subsidies.

Roberts recognizes such problems with special interests. Senator Baucus proposes that people be pressured into buying more insurance, but Roberts notes that Baucus has taken large campaign contributions from insurance companies. Lobbying by special-corporate interests generates profits that are "fat in the system" and should be cut.

But will increased government involvement in the healthcare industry cause more or less corporate lobbying? Both mandated-private and single-payer, nonprofit insurance proposals will likely increase wasteful lobbying by corporate interests.

The real question is, how far can we replace legitimate profit seeking with public service? Some people donate time and goods to healthcare. It is also true that some people work at Medicare or the Center for Disease Control because they want to do public service. But how much more of this conscientious public service can we expect? Other people seek federal jobs for an easy path to early retirement, or for power. The president is assuming a ready supply of capable and conscientious public servants, as well as effective means of managing and organizing healthcare along bureaucratic lines.

In the absence of market prices and profits, large-scale organization requires central planning. The idea of such planning scares many people, and rightly so. The planning of entire national economies during the 20th century ended in disaster. Large public bureaucracies have also exhibited significant problems with waste and rigidity.

These problems exist for specific reasons: central planning suffers from the defect that small groups of leaders or officials cannot possibly understand local conditions in modern industries like healthcare. The modern world is simply too complex to be planned. Of course, the private system of profit and loss also has defects, but we must be careful in identifying the source of the worst problems with profit seeking.

"Income taxes create a bias in favor of healthcare funding through insurance."

President Obama wants to further politicize the medical industry. He seems to assume that private profit seeking is wasteful. The president would be right if he specifically criticized profiteering through the manipulation of public policies. Since the medical industry is heavily regulated, we should expect that part of its profits serves special interests rather than consumers.

But the president's complaint about executive pay and profits in general is more in line with the socialist idea that profits necessarily serve a particular interest group — capitalists — at the expense of everybody else.

There are, of course, other sources of waste in the current healthcare system. Laws that mandate coverage of minor and routine healthcare services increase private administrative costs. For that matter, income taxes create a bias in favor of healthcare funding through insurance, rather than through per-service fees charged directly to consumers.

Third-party administrative costs could be slashed simply by removing the current bias towards healthcare financing through so-called insurance (as opposed to through true insurance for high-cost/low-probability health events). Frivolous and fraudulent lawsuits have also imposed high costs through inflated malpractice-insurance rates. Would either single-payer or mandated-insurance proposals decrease these costs?

We have three options: our current system, permeated by ill-gotten politicized profits and wasteful special-interest lobbying; a largely untried privatized system, based on private profits and limited private charity; and a system of centralized, single-payer healthcare through public bureaucracies. The type of compromises that the president proposed in his September 9 speech have already been tried and failed. We already have regulation by bureaucratic agencies.

Public bureaucracies have well-known and well-deserved reputations for rigidity, waste, and, at times, abuse. The private sector has a bad reputation in the healthcare industry, but that is largely due to the fact that healthcare has already been politicized.

Obama's plan for healthcare amounts to a self-fulfilling prophecy: if we further politicize the healthcare industry its profits will be even less justifiable, and public options will gain legitimacy. Paul Craig Roberts has seen ahead of this curve, and recognizes that a centralized, single-payer system might have some advantages over a politicized system of government mandates favoring private-corporate interests.

But the idea that we must choose between public healthcare and politicized-private healthcare is false. We can also move to depoliticize the healthcare industry. A depoliticized, free market in healthcare would be run on the basis of profits that are for the most part earned through cost efficiency and customer service.

A truly competitive health industry of this kind would best serve American consumers. Unfortunately, we are as far from approaching this situation as President Obama is from comprehending its merits.

D.W. MacKenzie teaches economics at the Coast Guard Academy. (The contents of this paper do not reflect official views of The U.S. Coast Guard Academy.) Send him mail. See D.W. MacKenzie's article archives. Comment on the blog.

© 2005-2019 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules