Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. The Trump Stock Market Trap May Be Triggered - Barry_M_Ferguson
2.Why are Central Banks Buying Gold and Dumping Dollars? - Richard_Mills
3.US China War - Thucydides Trap and gold - Richard_Mills
4.Gold Price Trend Forcast to End September 2019 - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Money Saving Kids Gardening Growing Giant Sunflowers Summer Fun - Anika_Walayat
6.US Dollar Breakdown Begins, Gold Price to Bolt Higher - Jim_Willie_CB
7.INTEL (INTC) Stock Investing to Profit From AI Machine Learning Boom - Nadeem_Walayat
8.Will Google AI Kill Us? Man vs Machine Intelligence - N_Walayat
9.US Prepares for Currency War with China - Richard_Mills
10.Gold Price Epochal Breakout Will Not Be Negated by a Correction - Clive Maund
Last 7 days
The Central Bank Time Machine - 23rd Aug 19
Stock Market August Breakdown Prediction and Analysis - 23rd Aug 19
U.S. To “Drown The World” In Oil - 23rd Aug 19
Modern Monetary Theory Could Destroy America - 23rd Aug 19
Seven Key Words That Explain "Stupidly High" Bond Market Prices - 23rd Aug 19
Is the Fed Too Late Prevent A US Housing Bear Market? - 23rd Aug 19
Manchester Airport FREE Drop Off Area Service at JetParks 1 - Video - 23rd Aug 19
Gold Price Trend Validation - 22nd Aug 19
Economist Lays Out the Next Step to Wonderland for the Fed - 22nd Aug 19
GCSE Exam Results Day Shock! How to Get 9 A*'s Grade 9's in England and Maths - 22nd Aug 19
KEY WEEK FOR US MARKETS, GOLD, AND OIL - Audio Analysis - 22nd Aug 19
USD/JPY, USD/CHF, GBP/USD Currency Pairs to Watch Prior to FOMC Minutes and Jackson Hole - 22nd Aug 19
Fed Too Late To Prevent US Real Estate Market Crash? - 22nd Aug 19
Retail Sector Isn’t Dead. It’s Growing and Pays 6%+ Dividends - 22nd Aug 19
FREE Access EWI's Financial Market Forecasting Service - 22nd Aug 19
Benefits of Acrobits Softphone - 22nd Aug 19
How to Protect Your Site from Bots & Spam? - 21st Aug 19
Fed Too Late To Prevent A US Housing Market Crash? - 21st Aug 19
Gold and the Cracks in the U.S., Japan and Germany’s Economic Data - 21st Aug 19
The Gold Rush of 2019 - 21st Aug 19
How to Play Interest Rates in US Real Estate - 21st Aug 19
Stocks Likely to Breakout Instead of Gold - 21st Aug 19
Top 6 Tips to Attract Followers On SoundCloud - 21st Aug 19
WAYS TO SECURE YOUR FINANCIAL FUTURE - 21st Aug 19
Holiday Nightmares - Your Caravan is Missing! - 21st Aug 19
UK House Building and House Prices Trend Forecast - 20th Aug 19
The Next Stock Market Breakdown And The Setup - 20th Aug 19
5 Ways to Save by Using a Mortgage Broker - 20th Aug 19
Is This Time Different? Predictive Power of the Yield Curve and Gold - 19th Aug 19
New Dawn for the iGaming Industry in the United States - 19th Aug 19
Gold Set to Correct but Internals Remain Bullish - 19th Aug 19
Stock Market Correction Continues - 19th Aug 19
The Number One Gold Stock Of 2019 - 19th Aug 19
The State of the Financial Union - 18th Aug 19
The Nuts and Bolts: Yield Inversion Says Recession is Coming But it May take 24 months - 18th Aug 19
Markets August 19 Turn Date is Tomorrow – Are You Ready? - 18th Aug 19
JOHNSON AND JOHNSON - JNJ for Life Extension Pharma Stocks Investing - 17th Aug 19
Negative Bond Market Yields Tell A Story Of Shifting Economic Stock Market Leadership - 17th Aug 19
Is Stock Market About to Crash? Three Charts That Suggest It’s Possible - 17th Aug 19
It’s Time For Colombia To Dump The Peso - 17th Aug 19
Gold & Silver Stand Strong amid Stock Volatility & Falling Rates - 16th Aug 19
Gold Mining Stocks Q2’19 Fundamentals - 16th Aug 19
Silver, Transports, and Dow Jones Index At Targets – What Direct Next? - 16th Aug 19
When the US Bond Market Bubble Blows Up! - 16th Aug 19
Dark days are closing in on Apple - 16th Aug 19
Precious Metals Gone Wild! Reaching Initial Targets – Now What’s Next - 16th Aug 19
US Government Is Beholden To The Fed; And Vice-Versa - 15th Aug 19
GBP vs USD Forex Pair Swings Into Focus Amid Brexit Chaos - 15th Aug 19
US Negative Interest Rates Go Mainstream - With Some Glaring Omissions - 15th Aug 19
GOLD BULL RUN TREND ANALYSIS - 15th Aug 19
US Stock Market Could Fall 12% to 25% - 15th Aug 19
A Level Exam Results School Live Reaction Shock 2019! - 15th Aug 19
It's Time to Get Serious about Silver - 15th Aug 19
The EagleFX Beginners Guide – Financial Markets - 15th Aug 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

The No 1 Gold Stock for 2019

Shanghai’s Stock Market Not A Bubble, SSE Targets 4000

Stock-Markets / Chinese Stock Market Dec 08, 2009 - 02:19 PM GMT

By: Andrew_Butter

Stock-Markets

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleThe talk about a bubble in China that was all over the place in July and August appears to be subsiding. I confess I know practically nothing about China. But what I know has always made me wary, it still does.

What I bring to the debate is simply that I claim to know something about bubbles, and although many people think I am a simple minded village idiot, my initial attempts at applying my models to the real world did at least give the right answer (the model predicted in January that the S&P 500 would bottom at 675 and that the rally would go up at least until the DOW hit 10,000).


OK two out of two on stock markets could be nothing more than luck, and my view that gold was (is) a bubble and that it would at some point head down to $600 looks right now about as dumb as Nouriel Roubini’s quip about a dead-cat-sucker-rally on 14th March.

The other day I noticed a paper flagged up by Zero Hedge about China and the possibility of a bubble:

http://zerohedge.blogspot.com/2009/07/chinese-stock-bubble-watch-for-critical.html

The paper is about the work of Diddier Sornette which as far as I gould understand is something about Chaos Theory and attempts to model the inflection point of bubbles based on the characteristics of the patterns of daily stock movements. Apparently the methodology was used successfully to predict the inflection point of the US housing bubble and the recent oil bubble although I have so far been unable to find a reference to that.

Their prediction made on 19th July was that the Shanghai Index would reverse, suddenly between July 17-27 and from looking at their chart go down to between 2,400 and 2,800.

I must say that they were bold; one of the first things I learnt from my recent initiation into the “predictions” business is that you never put both a number and a date.

This is what Zero Hedge had to say about that at the time:

Expanding on Cornelius' early piece on China, here is an analysis out of some BNP quants who for one reason or another are convinced the end's in sight. For those who are forgot where they put their Ritalin, here is the punchline:

This is what happened:

I’d say that regardless of where the analysts put their Ritalin, that was a pretty good result; I’d be interested to see where they say it’s going to go next.

But I don’t think that was a bubble popping:

My simple minded idea about bubbles is that they happen when market participants lose sight of fundamental value.

That can be caused by too much credit which allows “early adopters” to borrow money at “X”, buy assets at “Y” and then when what they can sell the asset for (to someone dumber than them), is a lot more than “X+Y”, they make lots of money (assuming they dump before the pump starts cavitating).

Another reason is if market participants convince themselves that the object of their affections has magical powers (when in reality that is not true). The Dot.com bubble was an example of that (aided by cheap credit), at that time the accepted method of valuation of a start-up was the summation of the inside leg measurement of the CEO raised to the power of “X”, which in time was proved to be an unreliable approach to doing valuation.

But that process historically has been long term, over at least six months maybe six years, not six weeks.

Also typically you don’t get the object of the bubble, going back to about the level that it popped within three months, when a bubble pops that’s it for a while.

So while I think that analysis looks pretty interesting (and I know that in my lifetime I will never fully understand how it works any more than I understand how the General Theory of relativity works), I don’t think it’s about bubbles.

The importance of valuation in understanding bubbles:

The way I look at bubbles, is first to try and figure out what the “fundamental value” of whatever it is that is supposedly bubbling is. Some people (Smithers, Tobin, Shiller) call that “Fair Value”, International Valuation Standards calls it Other-Than-Market-Value (OMV).

If you know that then you at least know by how much the market got distorted by the whatever it was that caused the bubble, and you also know that the more the distortion, the harder the fall will be, when the thing pops.

One of the main things I think I figured out is that in many bubbles, particularly for assets that are fundamentally useful (housing and stocks rather than tulips), the dip below the “fundamental” (OMV) is typically predicated by how much the market was distorted in the bubble; also the period of time that the market takes to get back to the OMV after the pop, is pretty much predicated by the preceding period of time there was a bubble.

That idea is summarised in this sketch:

The analogy that I have is that a bubble is like a pebble thrown into a still pond, and the up-wave (the bubble) is reflected in the down-wave (the bust) that follows:

I talk about that in more detail in:

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article12114.html
http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article15041.html

The problem with China

The problem with China is that I have no idea how to work out what the fundamental value (OMV) should be. 

The reason is that there just isn’t enough history, or perhaps there is.

Either way, in USA the stock market “fundamental” (i.e. the OMV) appears to track nominal GDP divided by long-term interest rates (LTIR), so perhaps it’s the same in China.

Not that I particularly believe the reported numbers for GDP and I have not clear idea about what long term interest rates are applicable, still that’s a start. Anyway assuming for the moment that perhaps LTIR (whatever they are), didn’t change much, the “fundamental “ought” to track nominal GDP if the Shanghai Index is a good proxy for what’s happening in China (and I have no opinion about that either – just a hypothesis).

(You can understand why I’m often called a village idiot; I basically don’t have much of an opinion on just about everything, a sort of Anti-Renaissance Man).

This is how it looks:

Based on that analysis my conclusion is:

1: If you believe the GDP numbers being put out by the Chinese government then the Shanghai Index is not a bubble right now, rather the reverse, it is a market in the process in recovering from a bubble that popped in late 2008.

2: Markets in recovery are the safest to invest in, there was one “after-shock” so far, expect two more before OMV is reached (a word of warning for the day-traders).

3: The opinion of this crystal-ball-peering village idiot is that the Index will go up to above 4,000 (could be 4,500) within six months.

4: Given that I don’t like gold (I think I must be allergic to it), I haven’t looked hard in a while by my impression is the S&P 500 will be lucky to drift sideways over the next six months, and I think long to medium term US Treasuries are a bubble (i.e. 10 Year and 30 year yields are set to go up, perhaps suddenly), putting something into the Shanghai Index would probably be a better bet than keeping money under the mattress.

By Andrew Butter

Twenty years doing market analysis and valuations for investors in the Middle East, USA, and Europe; currently writing a book about BubbleOmics. Andrew Butter is managing partner of ABMC, an investment advisory firm, based in Dubai ( hbutter@eim.ae ), that he setup in 1999, and is has been involved advising on large scale real estate investments, mainly in Dubai.

© 2009 Copyright Andrew Butter- All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

Andrew Butter Archive

© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules