Best of the Week
Most Popular
1.Stock Market in DANGER of Strangling the Bears to Death - Nadeem_Walayat
2. Germany Pivoting East, Exit US Dollar, Enter Gold Standard - Jim_Willie_CB
3.Flight MH17 – Kiev Flash Mob's Last False Flag? - Andrew_McKillop
4.Stock Market Crash Nightmare! - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Gold - The Million DOLLAR Question... - Rambus_Chartology
6.Gold And Silver – BRICS And Germany Will Pave The Way - Michael_Noonan
7.The Jewish Selfish Gene, People Chosen by God, Everyone Else is Goyim to Kill - Nadeem_Walayat
8.The Israeli Promised Land Dream - The Criminal Roadmap Towards “Greater Israel”? - Felicity Arbuthnot
9.Which Way is Inflation Blowing? Watch Commodities - Gary_Dorsch
10.U.S. Economy Quarterly Review and Implications for 2014-2015 - Lacy Hunt
Last 5 days
The Three Stocketeers: One for All and... - 2nd Aug 14
Significant Day in the Bitcoin Market - 2nd Aug 14
Gold Prices 1971 - 2014 in 3 Waves - 2nd Aug 14
Gold’s Seasonal Sweet Spot - Strongest Months Are August, September, November And January - 1st Aug 14 - GoldCore
Flagrant Rush To War In The Ukraine Crisis - 1st Aug 14
What Russian Sanctions Mean for Your Money - 1st Aug 14
The West's Reckless Rush Towards War with Russia - 1st Aug 14
Gold Price Advance Capped by the Dead Cat Dollar’s Recovery - 1st Aug 14
Big Banks Shift to Lower Gear Banking Operations - 1st Aug 14
Africa: New Land of Investor Opportunity? Pointing to the Positives - 1st Aug 14
Turning a Clinical Eye on Biotech Stocks with High Potential Investor Reward - 1st Aug 14
Gaza Death Cloud Hangs Over Sheffield Eid Festival 2014 at Millhouses Park - 1st Aug 14
Israels Final Solution of Turning Gaza Concentration Camp into a Grave Yard - 31st July 14
US Failure: Unintended Consequence - 31st July 14
Stock Market Breakdown! - 31st July 14
Echoes Of The Great War – Only An Echo In The Elite Mind - 31st July 14
This is Bad News for U.S. Economy and Stock Markets - 31st July 14
The Important Impact of This “Secret” Gold Agreement - 31st July 14
The Something For Nothing Society Death Spiral - 31st July 14
The Social Memory Dump, Shredding Society - 31st July 14
How Safe Are Unallocated Gold Bullion Accounts? - 31st July 14
USDJPY Big Bear Market - 31st July 14
No More School in Gaza Because All the Children are Dead Chant Israel's Jewish Fundementalists - 31st July 14
The Iron Dome Inside The Heads of Israel’s Leaders - 31st July 14
You Know a Politician or Talking Head is Clueless When….. - 31st July 14
Don't Get Married to Your Gold Stocks—It's a Performance-Based Relationship - 31st July 14
Stock Market Parabolic Collapse - Sowing the Seeds of the Next Depression - 30th July 14
How to Profit from the Russia Ukraine Conflict - 30th July 14
Greenspan: U.S. Economy Running Out of Buffer; Stock Market to See Significant Correction - 30th July 14
Rogue States And Loony Tunes - 30th July 14
Anne Elk’s Theory On Brontosauruses - 30th July 14
Our Totalitarian Future - Totalitarianism NOW! - 30th July 14
Stocks Bear Market Formation Revealed - 30th July 14
We Just Found “The Future” - 30th July 14
What the “Steak Bandit” Says About Asset Values - 30th July 14
Designer War By Default - Seven Types of Elite Madness - 30th July 14
Death of the U.S. Dollar? Gold an Inflation Hedge? Really? - 29th July 14
We’re Ready to Profit in the Coming Gold Price Correction—Are You? - 29th July 14
Their Economy Will Collapse, Including Ours - 29th July 14
Silver Prices – Megaphone Patterns - 29th July 14
Real U.S. Interest Rates - Fed Exit a Blue Pill? - 29th July 14
Why Israel Should NOT Exist, Just Like Any Other Rogue State - 29th July 14
Gold Still Looking Good - 29th July 14
Silver Price Set To Star - 29th July 14
Our Population Growth Totalitarian Future - 29th July 14
World War 1 Cause and Consequences - The Planned Destruction of Christendom - 29th July 14
Will Crashing Commodities Crash the Stock Market? - 29th July 14
Ukraine MH17 - Washington Thinks Americans Are Fools - 29th July 14
Stock Market Bubble Warning - 29th July 14
Gold Price and U.S. Dollar’s July Rally - 28th July 14
Second Quarter Corporate Earnings: Marching Toward a Strong Economic Recovery - 28th July 14
Time to Put a New Economic Tool in the Box - 28th July 14
Mossad in Gaza, Ukraine and the Cult Of The All-Powerful Elite - 28th July 14
Elliott Wave Gold Price Projection Since 1970 - 28th July 14
Investors Remain Uncertain As Stock Fluctuate Near Long-Term Highs - Will The Uptrend Extend? - 28th July 14
The Mass Psychology Of Decline - 28th July 14
Will the US Destroy the World? - Don’t Expect to Live Much Longer - 28th July 14
GDM and GDXJ Gold Stocks In-depth Look - 28th July 14
Stock Market One FINAL High? - 28th July 14
What It Means - Paradigm Collapse And Culture Crisis - 27th July 14
Wall Street Shadow Banking: You Can’t Taper a Ponzi Scheme: “Time to Reboot” - 27th July 14
6 Tips for Picking Winning Gold Mining Stocks - 27th July 14
Israel's War on Children, Exterminating the Palestinians Future - 27th July 14
Guilt By Insinuation - How American Propaganda Works - 26th July 14
Surprise Nuclear Attack On Russia To Liberate Ukraine - 26th July 14
Use "Magic" Of Gold/Silver Ratio To Greatly Increase Your Physical Holdings - 26th July 14
Derivatives Market Species Origins - Abuse, Props and Risks - 26th July 14
Stock Market Manipulation and Technical Analysis - 26th July 14
China’s Stock Market Finally Looks Like A Buy - 26th July 14
Ed Milliband Fears Israel Jewish Fundamentalist Gaza War Massacres Backlash - 26th July 14

Free Instant Analysis

Free Instant Technical Analysis


Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

The Biggest lie in Stock Market History Revealed

Three Reasons U.S. Housing Market Will Head Lower

Housing-Market / US Housing Mar 22, 2010 - 01:28 PM GMT

By: Q1_Publishing

Housing-Market

Diamond Rated - Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleIt’s one of the most pressing questions facing investors today.

Is the housing market about to recover?

With the housing market at the center of the credit crunch, any recovery in the housing market could quickly turn the Wall Street recovery into a Main Street recovery.


Consumers would start shopping again. Employment would rebound. And stocks would likely make the next move higher.

But we’re coming out of a genuine bubble decades in the making. And decades of overinvestment creating oversupply are rarely worked off in a couple of years.

That’s why the when you look at the true fundamentals of the housing market you can get a much better idea of when the market will recover, where prices are headed, and what it all means for the markets in the short and long term.

Back to Basics

In his annual letter to Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-A/B:NYSE), Warren Buffett said the light at the end of the housing tunnel isn’t far off:

Within a year or so, residential housing problems should largely be behind us. Prices will remain far below 'bubble' levels, of course, but for every seller or lender hurt by this there will be a buyer who benefits.

His rationale, in typical Buffett-like fashion, cut through all the weekly noise and focused on what mattered – supply and demand.

The world’s greatest investor noted that during the bubble years there were two million homes being built per year. He added that households were only being created at a rate of 1.2 million per year.

Supply was far outpacing demand and it couldn’t go on forever.

And it didn’t.

Long-time readers would naturally wonder, has Warren Buffett been reading the Prosperity Dispatch?

Five months ago the housing was still just showing its initial signs of recovery. The “temporary” tax credit for buying homes was about to expire and most expected the rebound in housing to be short-lived.

Our research, thanks in part to an extended lunch with some timber industry insiders, showed the herd was about to be proven wrong again.

We wrote:

Over the long run the outlook for housing is much different than it is now. It’s all because the fundamental driver of housing demand is population growth.

The Population Reference Bureau expects the population to grow at 0.9% per year through 2050. If we extrapolate the results of recent

Texas A&M University study, Housing Market Mirrors Population Growth, which correlates housing and population growth excluding the recent bubble years, the 0.9% population growth means housing demand will increase 1.12% per year.

That means 1.26 million new homes (105 million currently + 1.12% per year growth) will need to be built each year.

The current new housing construction rate is 660,000 per year.

During the bubble, supply was coming online way to fast. The market overshot. Now the market is undershooting as all the excess supply gets worked off in the market.

But when it comes to the fundamentals of supply and demand, we expect housing demand will rebound to around 1.2 million units per year in time.

That’s good news for all the companies that live off the housing demand like homebuilders, lumber producers, and companies that make drywall and bricks.

The real question is though, will housing prices actually recover? And if they do, by how much?

How to Know When the Bottom is In

In the post-housing bubble world, consumers look at what they can afford, not how much they can “flip” a house or how much equity they’re going to get while only paying interest on their mortgages.

That’s why we have to look at what really drives housing prices in a normalized housing market: income, rental rates, and interest rates.

They tell the full story of where housing prices are headed.

Price-To-Income

The charts below show the historical price-to-income ratio of houses (Hat tip, Calculated Risk):

The price-to-income ratio relates the national median housing price to the national median income level. Historically, they are about even.

As the chart shows, the housing bubble changed all that. Home buyers weren’t concerned with what they could afford. They focused on how much they could buy. As a result, the price-to-income ratio peaked at an unsustainable ratio of more than 1.6.

Jump ahead to today and the ratio has fallen by about 30% (no accident the median housing price fell about 30% too). But it’s still at the high end of the pre-bubble average at 1.1.

That means, on a relative to income basis, the houses are still overpriced and could easily fall another 10%. And if the market undershoots as it tends to do after bubbles, it could fall even more.

Price-to-Rent

The other key factor affecting the fundamental values of housing is rent.

After all, if housing prices fall too low relative to rent rates, investors will buy the houses to rent them out. Also, if prices are too high and rents too low, potential buyers would just rent because it’s actually much cheaper.

All that helps put a floor in housing prices.

The chart below shows the ratio of price-to-rent:

Once again, during the bubble relative housing prices were extremely skewed.

Housing prices went up, but rents did not go along with them. As a result, the price-to-rent ratio climbed to more than 1.7 at the peak.

At this point, investors were unable to rent their places to cover even most of the costs.
It was a situation that could not last. Either rents had to go up or prices had to go down.

Now that prices have fallen significantly, the price-to-rent ratio is much closer to the historical norm of about 1.1. However, at 1.2 it’s still too high and either rent have to go up or prices have to go down.

Given the other factors like price-to-income, it’s much more like prices will come down.

Interest Rates: The Wild Card

The final major factor affecting housing prices is interest rates. Since most homes are bought with borrowed money, the interest amount portion of a homebuyers’ mortgage payment will vary greatly with interest rates.

For example, someone who wants to buy a $200,000 house today with a 30-year mortgage would lock in the current 5% annual interest rate. The monthly payment would be $1,073 a month.

Interest rates, however, are at historically and unsustainable lows. As we’ve discussed in the past, they only have one way to go from here – UP.

In our example, a seemingly small 1% increase interest rates would push the monthly payment up to $1,199. A 2% increase would push the monthly mortgage payment up to $1,330. A 3% rate increase, which we expect to happen in the next couple of years, would push the monthly mortgage payment up to $1,467.

A 3% increase in interest rates would result in a 36% increase in the monthly payment a buyer would have to pay.

On top of all that, there are additional monthly expenses that are going up too. The largest of which are taxes. As states and local municipalities face widening budget deficits, they’ve turned to property taxes as a way to increase revenues. That just adds to the monthly costs of buying a home and would therefore just add to the downside.

Put all this together and interest rates rising will force housing prices down even more.

Houses are Still a Falling Knife

The three key elements of determining fundamental housing values all show housing prices are still too high.

At this time, we see a recovery in housing construction and demand, but we don’t see a recovery in housing prices anytime soon. Even after a 30% correction in prices, houses are still too expensive.

Now, we know the government has done everything it can to prop up the housing market. From tax credits to the Fed buying mortgage securities, no price has been too high.

The housing bubble was just like any other bubble. Prices must fall to a point where all the excess supply will be bought. All the costly government efforts have merely been delaying the inevitable.

So over the next few months the market will likely see a recovery in construction and Wall Street may view it as great news, we’ll still know housing is still in a bear market.

All is not lost though. Housing may not be a safe place to put your investment dollars to work, but in the next Prosperity Dispatch we’ll look at one spot that is. In fact, the last time this sector was this cheap, investors doubled their money in less than a year.

Until then. Good investing,

Andrew Mickey
Chief Investment Strategist, Q1 Publishing

Disclosure: Author currently holds a long position in Silvercorp Metals (SVM), physical silver, and no position in any of the other companies mentioned.

Q1 Publishing is committed to providing investors with well-researched, level-headed, no-nonsense, analysis and investment advice that will allow you to secure enduring wealth and independence.

© 2010 Copyright Q1 Publishing - All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.


© 2005-2014 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Comments

Laura
23 Mar 10, 00:08
Home sellers need to think competitively

You make a convincing case. If housing prices have further to fall, the home owners who wish to sell must continue to think competitively and make their homes stand out from the crowd. There is much that can modernize and enhance the look & feel of a home without having to spend a lot of money on major remodeling or adding square footage. Start with curb appeal, floors and paint, then move to kitchens and baths. Above all, homeowners must focus on cost-effective, high-value-added projects. Seek simplicity, comfort and value. I have more detail, including green ideas and a free report, "Home Remodeling Success Secrets," at http://TransformYourHouse.com.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

Free Report - Financial Markets 2014