Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Ray Dalio: This Debt Cycle Will End Soon - John_Mauldin
2.Stock Market Dow Plunge Following Fake US - China Trade War Truce - Nadeem_Walayat
3.UK House Prices 2019 No Deal BrExit 30% Crash Warning! - Nadeem_Walayat
4.What the Oil Short-sellers and OPEC Don’t Know about Peak Shale - Andrew_Butter
5.Stock Market Crashed While the Yield Curve Inverted - Troy_Bombardia
6.More Late-cycle Signs for the Stock Market and What’s Next - Troy_Bombardia
7.US Economy Will Deteriorate Over Next Half Year. What this Means for Stocks - Troy_Bombardia
8.TICK TOCK, Counting Down to the Next Recession - James_Quinn
9.How Theresa May Put Britain on the Path Towards BrExit Civil War - Nadeem_Walayat
10.This Is the End of Trump’s Economic Sugar High - Patrick_Watson
Last 7 days
The stock market fails to rally each day. What’s next for stocks - 14th Dec 18
How Low Could the S&P 500 Go? - 14th Dec 18
An Industrial to Stock Trade: Is Boeing a BUY Here? - 14th Dec 18
Will the Arrest of Huawei Executive Derail Trade War Truce? - 14th Dec 18
Trump vs the Fed: Who Wins? - 13th Dec 18
Expect Gold & Silver to Pullback Before the Next Move Higher - 13th Dec 18
Dollar Index Trends, USDJPY Setting Up - 13th Dec 18
While The Stocks Bulls Fiddle With The 'Fundamentals,' Rome Burns - 13th Dec 18
The Historic Role of Silver - 13th Dec 18
Natural Gas Price Setup for a Big Move Lower - 13th Dec 18
How to Get 20% Off Morrisons Weekly Supermarket Shopping - 13th Dec 18
Gold Price Analysis: Closer To A Significant Monetary Event - 13th Dec 18
Where is the Stock Market Santa Claus Rally? - 12th Dec 18
Politics and Economics in Times of Crisis - 12th Dec 18
Owning Precious Metals in an IRA - 12th Dec 18
Ways to Improve the Value of Your Home - 12th Dec 18
Theresa May No Confidence Vote, Next Tory Leader Betting Market Analysis and Forecasts - 12th Dec 18
Gold & Global Financial Crisis Redux - 12th Dec 18
Wow Your Neighbours With the Best Christmas Projector Lights for Holidays 2018! - 12th Dec 18
Stock Market Topping Formation as Risks Rise Around the World - 11th Dec 18
The Amazing Story of Gold to Gold Stocks Ratios - 11th Dec 18
Stock Market Medium term Bullish, But Long Term Risk:Reward is Bearish - 11th Dec 18
Is a Deleveraging Event about to Unfold in the Stock Market? - 11th Dec 18
Making Money through Property Investment - 11th Dec 18
Brexit: What Will it Mean for Exchange Rates? - 11th Dec 18
United States Facing Climate Change Severe Water Stress - 10th Dec 18
Waiting for Gold Price to Erupt - 10th Dec 18
Stock Market Key Support Being Re-Tested - 10th Dec 18
May BrExit Deal Tory MP Votes Forecast, Betting Market Analysis - 10th Dec 18
Listen to What Gold is Telling You - 10th Dec 18
The Stock Market’s Long Term Outlook is Changing - 10th Dec 18
Palladium Shortages Expose Broken Futures Markets for Precious Metals - 9th Dec 18
Is an Inverted Yield Curve Bullish for Gold? - 9th Dec 18
Rising US Home Prices and Falling Sales - 8th Dec 18
Choosing Who the Autonomous Car Should Kill - 8th Dec 18
Stocks Selloff Boosting Gold - 8th Dec 18

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How You Could Make £2,850 Per Month

The Political Tide Against the Ratings Agencies

Politics / Credit Crisis 2011 Jul 08, 2011 - 02:31 AM GMT

By: Aftab_Singh

Politics

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleThe bane of our pseudo-capitalistic system is the blatant double standard that is upheld with respect to prices. If the money prices of things go up, that’s ok, and the saint behind this wholesome circumstance is typically elevated to greatness. However, if the money prices of things go down, there’s got to be a bad guy somewhere — and boy does he get hanged, drawn and quartered in the town square.


The ratings agencies are a group that has experienced the extremes of both worlds; during the upswing, they were the very standard of financial wizardry, and even rose to the status of being enshrined in the law. However, more recently, they’ve gone from being the ‘greatest’ to the latest victim of the barrage of hate flowing from the vocal cords of our public orators. Here, I try to shed some light on the seemingly convoluted subjects of the capitalistic price system, the notion of risk and regulation.

The Irony of Well-Established & Popular Ratings Agencies:

First of all, just to emphasize that I have no particular attachment to the rating agency companies, I should mention that the notion of a prominent and popular ratings agency is oxymoronic.

Risk is a peculiar subject that is scarcely understood by the herd. Safety in speculative financial assets is not found in those assets with the smallest historical variance from the mean (i.e. the smallest volatility), indeed, it can hardly be any demonstrable function of any past data. Rather, it is a function of matters that the herd cannot possibly accept. Safety (or a profound lack of safety) is found in those assets where consensual opinion is confused yet dogmatically convinced about a specific future. Hence, as I explained here, consensual conceptions of risk tend to defeat themselves. Consequently, we can say that any ratings agency that reaches the status of a large and well-respected institution is bound to get it wrong at the worst possible times. In short, the concepts of ‘accurate risk attribution’ and ‘popularity’ are mutually incompatible.

The Symmetry in Financial Markets: Exploding the ‘Up is Good, Down is Bad’ Fallacy:

As I often mention here on greshams-law.com, financial markets are ‘just’ arenas where people go to swap stuff. Forgive me for hammering the point home here, but stock markets are arenas where people go to swap stocks and money, commodity markets are arenas where people go to swap commodities and money, bond markets are arenas where people go to swap bonds and money… In this way, the thing and the money stand as equal counterparts in the arrangement. So, to praise prices rises as a fundamentally lovely thing, and to condemn price falls as an inherently dastardly thing is to commit a rather simple, yet frequently overlooked, double standard.

I am sure that a few may respond with; ‘the great thing about prices rises — especially in the stock market and/or in risk assets in general — is that the wealth effect is ignited in the economy’. This may be true, but it cannot escape the rudimentary simplicity of the principle above. All that can be said is that a proportion of market participants succumb to an illusion. A rise in the price of — say — the stock market, is (to be sure) good for the holders of stocks, but it isn’t good for the holders of cash!

Symmetry in the Effects of Ratings Agencies:

Something that has been bemoaned as a failing of the ratings agencies has been the tendency for downgrades in credit ratings to increase the swiftness with which prices decline. Such wails of woe are subject to the ‘up-good, down-bad’-fallacy described above. With the unviability of ratings agencies aside, we have to note that the effect of their ratings (and changes in ratings) work both ways. Just as downgrades have a tendency to worsen sell-offs, the upgrades had the tendency to exacerbate the buying sprees! Of course, politicians, arguably one of the greatest proponents of the ‘up-good, down-bad’ fallacy have come out all-blazing against the ratings agencies. As The Independent reported this morning:

The Leading credit ratings agencies were threatened with tighter regulation and break-up yesterday by some of Europe’s most powerful politicians.

The German finance minister, Wolffanf Schauble, said he could see no justification for Moody’s recent downgrade of Portugal’s debt and believed that limits should be put on the rating agencies’ “oligopoly”…

Jose Manuel Barroso, the president of the European Commission, claimed Moody’s downgrade of Portugal added to speculation in the markets and suggested an anti-Europe bias. The European Union, he said, planned to strengthen regulations overseeing the three majors, and said European legislators would also look into issues of “civil liability” for incorrect judgments by agencies on the credit worthiness of sovereign European nations, with an obvious focus on those currently under pressure – …

… The Greek foreign minister, Stavros Lambridinis, said the agencies’ actions in the debt crisis had been “madness”. The fierce attacks on the agencies’ integrity came after a shock downgrade of Portuguese debt to “junk” status by Moody’s sent stock markets and the euro sharply down, and sparked fears of another round of contagion.

Well, it looks like even politicians are wearing their conspiratorial hats now – the rating agencies are out to get them… Unlike us, however, they don’t put their money where their mouths are!

Regulation ad infinitum…

The unfortunate thing about the quote above is that there is an almost idiotic denial of reality involved. As Ayn Rand demonstrated in all of her fantastic novels, you can’t force people into success (with the gun). Moreover, you certainly cannot force people into being correct in their endeavors as futurologists! The whole concept of risk is based on the fact that the future is unknowable, so to attempt to regulate that out of existence is just incredibly silly! If they have failed for lack of inhuman characteristics, how is further regulation by humans going to help?

Conclusion:

The financial markets are symmetrical – upward moving prices do not remarkably accumulate loveliness. Moreover, all that is required to regulate the activities of market participants is the simplest thing in the world – the market.

Aftab Singh is an independent analyst. He writes about markets & political economy at http://greshams-law.com .

© 2011 Copyright Aftab Singh - All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.


© 2005-2018 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules