Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Stock Markets and the History Chart of the End of the World (With Presidential Cycles) - 28th Aug 20
2.Google, Apple, Amazon, Facebook... AI Tech Stocks Buying Levels and Valuations Q3 2020 - 31st Aug 20
3.The Inflation Mega-trend is Going Hyper! - 11th Sep 20
4.Is this the End of Capitalism? - 13th Sep 20
5.What's Driving Gold, Silver and What's Next? - 3rd Sep 20
6.QE4EVER! - 9th Sep 20
7.Gold Price Trend Forecast Analysis - Part1 - 7th Sep 20
8.The Fed May “Cause” The Next Stock Market Crash - 3rd Sep 20
9.Bitcoin Price Crash - You Will be Suprised What Happens Next - 7th Sep 20
10.NVIDIA Stock Price Soars on RTX 3000 Cornering the GPU Market for next 2 years! - 3rd Sep 20
Last 7 days
Global Banking: Some Sectors Look as "Precarious as Ever" - 28th Oct 20
Silver Price Minor Dip Possible Before 2nd Major Upleg Starts - 28th Oct 20
�� How to Carve a Simple and Scary Pumpkin Face for Covid Halloween 2020 �� - 28th Oct 20
Gold Price One Last Dip Likely Then Major Upleg to New Highs - 28th Oct 20
Smart Money Is Going All-In On This New Gold Frontier - 28th Oct 20
Gold Stocks Still Correcting - 27th Oct 20
Gold and Crypto: Is This How Charts Look Before A Monetary Collapse? - 27th Oct 20
Silver's Coming Double Trigger Shotgun Price Explosion - 27th Oct 20
The $126 Billion Gold Opportunity in Australia - 27th Oct 20
Tips to Breeze through Your Spanish Classes Online - 27th Oct 20
Try The “Compounding Capital Gains” Strategy Today - 26th Oct 20
UK Coronavirus Broken Test and Trace System, 5 Days for Covid-19 Results! - 26th Oct 20
How the Coronavirus is Exacerbating Global Inequality, Hunger - 26th Oct 20
The Top Gold Stock for 2021 - 26th Oct 20
Corporate Earnings Season: Here's What Stock Investors Need to Know - 25th Oct 20
�� Halloween 2020 TESCO Supermarkes Shoppers Covid Panic Buying! �� - 25th Oct 20
Three Unstoppable Forces Set to Drive Silver Prices - 25th Oct 20
Car Insurance And Insurance Claims and Options - 25th Oct 20
Best Pressure Washer Review - Karcher K7 Full Control Unboxing - 25th Oct 20
Further Gold Price Pressure as the USDX Is About to Rally - 23rd Oct 20
Nasdaq Retests 11,735 Support - 23rd Oct 20
America’s Political and Financial Institutions Are Broken - 23rd Oct 20
Sayonara U.S.A. - 23rd Oct 20
Economic Contractions Overshadow ASEAN-6 Recovery - 23rd Oct 20
Doji Clusters Show Clear Support Ranges for Stock Market S&P500 Index - 23rd Oct 20
Silver Market - 22nd Oct 20
Goldman Sachs Likes Silver; Trump Wants Even More Stimulus - 22nd Oct 20
Hacking Wall Street to Close the Wealth Gap - 22nd Oct 20
Natural Gas/UNG Stepping GAP Patterns Suggest Pending Upside Breakout - 22nd Oct 20 -
NVIDIA CANCELS RTX 3070 16b RTX 3080 20gb GPU's Due to GDDR6X Memory Supply Issues - 22nd Oct 20
Zafira B Leaking Water Under Car - 22nd Oct 20
The Copper/Gold Ratio Would Change the Macro - 21st Oct 20
Are We Entering Stagflation That Will Boost Gold Price - 21st Oct 20
Crude Oil Price Stalls In Resistance Zone - 21st Oct 20
High-Profile Billionaire Gives Urgent Message to Stock Investors - 21st Oct 20
What's it Like to be a Budgie - Unique in a Cage 4K VR 360 - 21st Oct 20
Auto Trading: A Beginner Guide to Automation in Forex - 21st Oct 20
Gold Price Trend Forecast into 2021, Is Intel Dying?, Can Trump Win 2020? - 20th Oct 20
Gold Asks Where Is The Inflation - 20th Oct 20
Last Chance for this FREE Online Trading Course Worth $129 value - 20th Oct 20
More Short-term Stock Market Weakness Ahead - 20th Oct 20
Dell S3220DGF 32 Inch Curved Gaming Monitor Unboxing and Stand Assembly and Range of Movement - 20th Oct 20
Best Retail POS Software In Australia - 20th Oct 20
From Recession to an Ever-Deeper One - 19th Oct 20
Wales Closes Border With England, Stranded Motorists on Severn Bridge? Covid-19 Police Road Blocks - 19th Oct 20
Commodity Bull Market Cycle Starts with Euro and Dollar Trend Changes - 19th Oct 20
Stock Market Melt-Up Triggered a Short Squeeze In The NASDAQ and a Utilities Breakout - 19th Oct 20
Silver is Like Gold on Steroids - 19th Oct 20
Countdown to Election Mediocrity: Why Gold and Silver Can Protect Your Wealth - 19th Oct 20
“Hypergrowth” Is Spilling Into the Stock Market Like Never Before - 19th Oct 20
Is Oculus Quest 2 Good Upgrade for Samsung Gear VR Users? - 19th Oct 20
Low US Dollar Risky for Gold - 17th Oct 20
US 2020 Election: Are American's ready for Trump 2nd Term Twilight Zone Presidency? - 17th Oct 20
Custom Ryzen 5950x, 5900x, 5800x , RTX 3080, 3070 64gb DDR4 Gaming PC System Build Specs - 17th Oct 20
Gold Jumps above $1,900 Again - 16th Oct 20
US Economic Recovery Is in Need of Some Rescue - 16th Oct 20
Why You Should Focus on Growth Stocks Today - 16th Oct 20
Why Now is BEST Time to Upgrade Your PC System for Years - Ryzen 5000 CPUs, Nvidia RTX 3000 GPU's - 16th Oct 20
Beware of Trump’s October (November?) Election Surprise - 15th Oct 20
Stock Market SPY Retesting Critical Resistance From Fibonacci Price Amplitude Arc - 15th Oct 20
Fed Chairman Begs Congress to Stimulate Beleaguered US Economy - 15th Oct 20
Is Gold Market Going Back Into the 1970s? - 15th Oct 20
Things you Should know before Trade Cryptos - 15th Oct 20
Gold and Silver Price Ready For Another Rally Attempt - 14th Oct 20
Do Low Interest Rates Mean Higher Stocks? Not so Fast… - 14th Oct 20
US Debt Is Going Up but Leaving GDP Behind - 14th Oct 20
Dell S3220DGF 31.5 Inch VA Gaming Monitor Amazon Prime Day Bargain Price! But WIll it Get Delivered? - 14th Oct 20
Karcher K7 Pressure Washer Amazon Prime Day Bargain 51% Discount! - 14th Oct 20
Top Strategies Day Traders Adopt - 14th Oct 20

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Get Rich Investing in Stocks by Riding the Electron Wave

The World Economy Stalls; Meanwhile Dubai Bounces Back: So what’s The Secret?

Economics / Economic Recovery Jan 20, 2012 - 08:09 AM GMT

By: Andrew_Butter

Economics

Diamond Rated - Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleOne of the few interesting things about Dubai is that it serves as a barometer for economic activity that happens largely outside of government and outside of OEDC.

I’m not talking blood diamonds or drug money, Dubai services a region that extends thousands of miles in all directions and the only thing that happens there that doesn’t happen elsewhere and is “illegal” in many of the places it services, is economic freedom. What’s interesting is that you can measure the pulse the global free-market by measuring the pulse of Dubai.


Although apart from counting cars on the freeway it’s not easy to understand what’s going on. For example in 2007 the GDP for 2006 was reported by the Dubai Municipality to be $46 billion, and yes I did check, I’m looking at a hard-copy right now; but there is no explanation I saw for how come mysteriously that got upwardly revised to $65 billion (i.e. + 40%). The latest number is for 2008…$93 billion; and there are no numbers for 2009 or 2010.

Who knows, perhaps $93 billion for 2008 was the right number? Certainly many people have said that the true size of economic value-added was under-reported if you compare to proxies. It’s hard to know because there is hardly any tax, no exchange control, and companies have no obligation to submit accurate accounts to anyone, and certainly not to their banks…so how do you measure GDP?

Meanwhile life goes on, water keeps coming down the pipes, electricity keeps coming down the wires, internet and phones still work, garbage gets collected, the streets are spotlessly clean, sewage gets treated and recycled to water the parks, gas is cheap, the police are efficient and most of the time they are a lot more charming than the police are in a lot of other places, and the planes still fly in and out on time.

How that gets paid for is another story, so is the mystery of who actually owes the $100 billion people keep talking about, or more to the point, what’s the collateral and if there is any, where is it?  Given that entities not “linked” or “related” to Dubai, but that are actually “owned” by the Dubai government, such as the electricity-company and Emirates Airlines, don’t appear to have any problem either servicing or raising debt.

Life is full of mystery, but one of the charms of Dubai is that you don’t get the feeling of the heavy hand of government looking up your skirt and meddling with things they don’t understand. They just make sure everything works, and let the rest just happen; that part’s called free-enterprise; remember that idea?

Anyway, regardless, it’s not hard to work things out; for example a good starting point for a quick navigational fix always used to be hotel statistics because there is a tax like a VAT, and so there is data, and the data used to get aggregated and published quite promptly. Sadly no data has been published since Q3-2008 which was just before the bust, at least none that I could find. But no worries, the hotels exchange data, so with a bit of digging you can find out.
The timeline I like particularly is for 4-Star and 5-Star city hotels, i.e. not on the beach. That roughly disaggregates the tourist market from the business market, and although there is a lot of overlap, it’s a guide; and the best thing is that I got good data going back to 1987.

The reason I like that data is because in the days when I used to stand up in front of people telling fairy-stories about why they should believe my 15-year revenue projections for hotel developments, in Dubai I always used to start off with this graph:

The story went like this, (a) GDP explains total lodging revenue, which makes sense, it’s called “share of pocket”, (b) GDP is quite predictable so you can use that to predict lodging revenues (c) it’s not hard to know roughly how much new supply there will be in the next five years because it takes that long to get from concept to handover for a decent sized hotel, and if you know how you can predict pretty accurately for ten and guess the other five, so (d) divide total revenues by total rooms and you get Revenue per Available Room (REVPAR), and you can adjust that to the market positioning of what you are planning, and (e) BINGO!!…give me the money!!

That works for other places too, try that in Hong Kong or Singapore where they do measure GDP very carefully every quarter, and they do publish their deliberations after 60 days, you get a similar correlation. So presumably that works the other way round, if you know hotel lodging revenues, you can figure out GDP?

If that still works, that says the Dubai economy lost 20% of its value in 2009 compared to 2008, and now it’s bounced back to where it was in 2008 or in other words 30% up in two years, measured in nominal US Dollars of course.

That sounds about right, looking at the other proxies, and OK Dubai’s real estate prices halved in 2009 compared to 2008 and probably a good part of the bubble in economic activity was caused by the bubble in house prices, as it was in America and Europe, just in Dubai that happened over about three years. But real estate prices are still on the floor, a lot of construction stopped and no one is planning new construction, so how come that proxy for economic activity went back up?

Could this be an example of what happens when governments don’t jump in to “save” the system and “manage” things, and just do what governments are supposed to do and simply make sure everything still works, and in particular make sure that the police understand they are servants of the public, not the other way around?

And the result, well if Dubai is any guide, you get a short-sharp pain, anyone who made a stupid investment gets punished and now and then you can spot specks on the horizon in the middle of the desert; which if you get closer you can see are people in dark suits standing looking a bit forlorn, scratching their heads and asking, “is this the collateral”…and low and behold, the free market picks up the slack.

Just for example, I was thinking of buying a house in Europe, I thought, they had a bubble, now they are having a bust, good time to buy. But I noticed the prices are way too high, and I suspect they are being artificially kept up by government and/or central banks, to maintain the status-quo.

Which is all very well if you are one of the lucky 70% of the population that either owns a house or owes the bank a house but they still let you live in it; but I suspect that’s not a recipe for long-term economic prosperity; although clearly I am in a distinct minority on that one.

What next?
The nice thing about a bubble and a bust is that afterwards you get to see where the “fundamental” was, and if you know that you can sometimes make predictions.

That’s the “pebble in the pond” theory which seems to work pretty good although it’s hardly “mainstream” economic theory. There again, there don’t seem to be many mainstream economic theories that can do anything more complicated than predict where the sun will come up tomorrow, and my niece, aged six, can do that.

To illustrate how accurate predictions based on the pebble in the pond idea can be, for example, that predicted the S&P 500 would turn the day it hit 675, then go up to 1200 or thereabouts, then reverse by about 15%, then go up to 1350 or so then reverse by 15% or so again, and then leisurely drift back up again.

Of course that’s not proof of anything; that could have happened if you had employed a chimpanzee to throw darts at a board with random numbers on it ranging from 400 to 4000 which was the range of outcomes predicted by all the best experts in the world over that period.

Sounds easy, but to get the pebble in the pond theory to deliver, you have to do a valuation, and not just a mark-to-market valuation; even a trained chimpanzee can do one of those, you got to figure out the fundamental, or what International Valuation Standards calls Other Than Market Value.

And THEN, you got to test it, by making a prediction in real time, and then see if it worked. If it doesn’t, then you can be pretty sure your valuation model was wrong; if it does then the probability your valuation is sound is equal to the ratio of the range of your prediction, compared to the range of possibilities, which can be approximated by the range of opinions of experts.

So if your prediction says the market will go up, and assuming the experts are divided over whether it will go down, sideways, or up, and it does go up, the probability your valuation model is wrong is One out of Three (33%). Do that two times in a row and its 33% x 33% = 11%...etc. Equally if you say the market will turn on the day it hits 675 , and on that day it ranged from 666 to 686, and the experts were saying (when you made the prediction), anything from 900 to 300, then the probability your valuation model was wrong, is 20/600 = 3.3%.

Worked out that way, the probability of getting the accurate predictions that were made using the pebble in the pond theory on the S&P 500; is one in 35 Million; which is ten times less than the probability used to decide whether you discovered a Higgs Boson or not.

So, perhaps the pebble in the pond theory could be more useful than mainstream, ideas like inflation targeting, the bit-of-froth model that Alan Greenspan was so fond of, and the models Goldman Sachs used to value AAA rated synthetic collateralized debt obligations for their customers?  Perhaps not, but if it’s right then that gets you the X on this chart.

Mm… that looks pretty sweet, eyeballing the red-line that says in 2008 about 20% of the economic activity in Dubai was generated by folks who were suffering from the sort of disequilibrium that many people experience when they drink a bottle of vodka.

But how do we know that red-line is correct?

Given that I just got one piece of hard data (the fundamental in 2009), plus some cranky idea about the time to fill in a hole is typically the same as the time it took to dig it, plus I’m guessing the bubble took off in about 2005 or 2006.

So now I’m thinking, what could be driving the economy of Dubai?

Well there is a billboard on the road to Abu Dhabi, partially covered in sand, which says “Where the Vision of Dubai Get’s Built”, but if you get out of your car and climb the hill to look behind, you will see there is just a huge expanse of sand with an occasional lost-suit wandering around, so I’m thinking; perhaps that’s not it?

Personally I put the driver of Dubai’s economy down to the limited instruction set line of the much loved and sadly departed H.H. Sheikh Rashid Al Maktoum….”I will build the infrastructure and the rest will follow”.

Which sounds a bit like something Milton Friedman or Ayn Rand might have said, except of course, (a) Rashid said it first, and (b) Rand also said that all Arabs (Muslims) are “totally primitive uncivilized racist savages”.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2uHSv1asFvU&feature=related

Oh well, perhaps there are things that can be learned from totally primitive uncivilized racist savages?

If Rashid was right, what drives the “rest”?

How about oil perhaps? Given that Dubai is a service economy that services a region awash with oil, even though it has none to speak of (about $2 billion a year worth).

This is a plot of 4-Star and 5-Star city-hotel lodging revenues, which as was explained, might just be a decent proxy for GDP, compared to oil prices:

Well that’s interesting, kind of puts the idea of the “fundamental” being a straight line to bed, that says the bubble wasn’t caused by property speculation, but by oil prices going crazy, and the oil prices bust, and well, so did Dubai’s economy.

What intriguing there is the dynamics might be an example about how bubbles spread, there was a bubble in oil prices, everyone who made money out of that started spending money in Dubai, the banks thought “WOW look at all that money, we can’t loose here”, and the hot money got put down buying real estate, and then the price of oil went down, and Dubai real estate prices went down, and the economy went down.

Another intriguing thing is that on that chart, the “fundamental” price for oil; (according to the pebble in the pond theory), crossed the Lodging Revenues line, at about the lodging revenues fundamental.

If you take the red line from this chart:

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article24849.html

And paste it on the other chart, you get this:

Well that fits at least on the two fundamentals, what that says is that regardless of any oil-bubble induced bubble-and-pops, lodging revenues in Dubai are likely to track the oil price fundamental.

The Future?

Perhaps the world is increasingly getting divided into the parts that have oil, or who alternatively make money out of the parts that have oil (like Dubai), and the parts that have to borrow money to import oil?

And the “have-nots” over the past few years have re-aligned their economies to a system where the process of borrowing money and not paying it back has been refined into an art-form; that has taken over from the old-fashioned system of creating real economic value-added, supported by banking systems based on lending money against carefully valued collateral in case the people they lend money too don’t pay it back, which is a really novel idea, and is certainly not “mainstream” these days.

Perhaps, just around the corner there will be that magic discovery which will turn the tide and ensure that never-again do decent civilized people  have to borrow money to pay totally primitive uncivilized racist savages so they can drive to work.

But there again, that’s what everyone was saying twenty years ago, now the quandary is what is the real “fundamental” for the price of oil?

Is it the price that the parts of the world that have to borrow money to buy it, and can just about afford to pay 3.3% of their GDP every year for that commodity, or does the recent volatility in the price suggest a new paradigm is emerging?

One where the “Other Than Market Value” is not what the customers can afford to pay, but the cost to discover, and bring to market, an equal supply of oil as has been discovered so far? I’m beginning to suspect the time oil gets priced on it’s replacement value (what it would cost to get hold of oil if all the existing producers decided to leave their oil in the ground waiting for the price to go up), that’s because the down-swing in oil prices predicted by the pebble in the pond theory, didn’t happen.

Right now I’m beginning to suspect that the OIK part of my oil valuation model might be wrong, and that there is starting to be either a “holding back” or perhaps the numbers for world GDP are counting less of the value-added that gets created outside the view of government?

Meanwhile, for now, the Saudis play the role of “fairy-godmother-of last-resort”, keeping things oiled so as not to stall the world economy; but no one knows how long that will last, before they start to run out, and I noticed they recently decided that $100 was “Fair Value”, up from $75 two years ago.

But regardless of whatever anyone says about what the GDP of Dubai is, I expect city hotel lodging revenues, will follow the path of the oil-price fundamental.

By Andrew Butter

Twenty years doing market analysis and valuations for investors in the Middle East, USA, and Europe. Ex-Toxic-Asset assembly-line worker; lives in Dubai.

© 2012 Copyright Andrew Butter- All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

Andrew Butter Archive

© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Comments

Mark Wickens
22 Jan 12, 11:18
Misrepresenting Rand

It’s strange that the author would misrepresent Ayn Rand and include a link that proves it. I guess he thinks his readers are lazy and/or stupid.


Andrew Butter
23 Jan 12, 09:46
Ayn Ryan is (was) Not A Racist

On the contrary, I don't think characterizing Ayn Rand as someone who favored "small government" that just provided infrastructure and the Rule of Law misrepresents her, so personally I'm a Big Fan!!

With regard to he views on who is a racist, and who is not, all I can say is that I think Rambo would have been a lot richer now if he had gone with Rand's ideas on Physics Envy, and put aside her ideas on Penis Envy.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules