Demand Building for Gold and Silver as Currency of Legal Tender for Merchant Services
Commodities / Gold & Silver Feb 27, 2008 - 12:45 PMBy: Alex_Wallenwein
" Gold & Silver Accepted Here"- The fact that euros are accepted by many stores in New York City has made the news lately and is well known in gold investor circles. It is yet another symptom of the ongoing demise of the US dollar. The good news for these New York City merchants - and for all others nationwide - is that gold and silver will not be far behind and offer far better advantages as dollar-alternatives.
You may think that honest-to-goodness currency demand for gold and silver is non-existent in the US and that this will remain so until the legal tender laws are repealed (as currently proposed by Representative Ron Paul's dual HR 42756 and HR 4683 approach) - but that is not necessarily true. Such demand will soon begin to build, regardless of Ron Paul's efforts in Congress - and it will take off very fast.
Here is why:
Until now, merchants or service providers labored under the quite incorrect assumption that offering their goods for gold and silver would be unprofitable, and a waste of time because of a number of factors.
Factors That Used to Limit the Currency-Use of Gold:
- A widespread, but incorrect, application of Gresham's law to the situation at hand;
- A lack of public understanding of the advantages of PMCs by the public;
- Legal tender laws prohibiting the issuance and the "utterin" or "passing" of non-official precious metals coins (like 18 USC 486, the law the Liberty Dollar ran up against);
- Tax laws that inhibit the free exchange of gold or silver for goods and services by imposing difficult to satisfy accounting burdens;
- Insufficient numbers of consumers own spendable gold or silver or are aware of their availability..
Yet, none of these reasons really prevent merchants from profitably offering their wares for gold. (Whenever the word "gold" is used from here on forward, it should be understood to include silver).
The dollar's rapid decline and the accompanying credit crunch and world economic slowdown are changing the picture for gold-as-currency dramatically. Gold has always been - and will always be "money", but its actual widespread use as a circulating medium of exchange has been stifled by the above listed factors. Let's go through them, one by one, to see if they really pose such severe obstacles to the use of gold as a viable currency.
1. Gresham's Law - Turned on Its Head
The applicability of Gresham's law really depends on the inconsistency between the face value and the actual bullion value of a coin (in the case of a gold coin standard), or the overprinting of paper receipts for gold (under a classical gold standard). Neither condition exists today.
What we have today is a universal "fiat standard", if you will. The question to be examined is whether Gresham's law really dictates that fiat (bad money) will always drive out or prevent the widespread circulation of good money (gold).
In truth, when ( not "if") gold becomes more widely used, it will have a tendency to drive out bad money in our current set-up. This will be achieved largely by merchants' offering significant gold discounts for their goods.
The main reason nobody buys with gold is that it is hard to see why purchasing an item for gold will be a benefit to the buyer.
In a rising gold/declining dollar environment, merchants can easily afford to offer tremendous savings to their customers by deep-discounting their goods for gold-paying customers. Whatever revenue "loss" may accrue to them at the time of the purchase will be made up in the future by the dollar-price appreciation of the gold earned over time.
Not only that, but the merchant also gets to stock up on valuable gold as a form of currency-hedge without having to make any layout of already earned funds. It works just like income tax withholding. If you don't see your money going out of your wallet or bank account, you just don't care as much. (Unlike income tax withholding, earning gold obviously is a benefit, of course.)
Further, by offering his customers such tremendous discounts, he makes them very interested in acquiring gold so they can take advantage of his offers. That, in turn, drives up demand for gold, which ends up supporting and further boosting its dollar-price increases - all to the benefit of both the merchant and the customer.
In the end, Gresham's law is turned on its head. By merchants offering deep discounts, the tendency to hoard the gold is either lessened or eliminated altogether.
2. Public Ignorance of Gold's Advantages:
This factor is eliminated almost automatically, and passively, by simply offering the discounts to gold-customers in the first place. People already get excited and start buying loads of stuff during so-called "tax holidays" offered by some states on certain days when certain products are exempted from their sales tax. Sales taxes are usually under ten percent. Imagine what a continuous "price holiday" of, say, 25 percent is offered. Customers will likely fall all over themselves to be able take advantage of that.
This way, without having to try and "educate" your customers about the ins and outs of Austrian economics, you - the merchant - give them a reason to educate themselves , and even if they continue in their completely ignorant bliss, they still understand that a "quarter off" is a good deal. That's all they need to know. If they want to know more, you can point them to an online FAQ page on your company's website.
3. Section 486 of Title 18, USC (one of the Legal Tender Laws) - Does Not Apply to Non-Coin Forms of Currency
The Liberty Dollar got sacked because it was plainly in violation of 18 USC Section 486, which reads as follows:
"Whoever, except as authorized by law, makes or utters or passes, or attempts to utter or pass, any coins of gold or silver or other metal, or alloys of metals, intended for use as current money, whether in the resemblance of coins of the United States or of foreign countries, or of original design, shall be fined under this title (!1) or imprisoned not more than five years, or both.
(That, of course, also kills the idea of creating a purely bullion-weight denominated physical gold currency for the time being, but using digital gold currencies and American Eagles is just as workable.)
Obviously, American Eagle bullion coins, declared by law to be legal tender, are excepted from the application of this statute. Only coins of "original design" or those resembling coins of foreign countries, if passed as current money, are covered.
That leaves paper bills (which we are not addressing here) and digital gold currencies - so we're clear of any legal challenges to the use of digital gold or American Eagles coins in day-to-day commerce within the United States.
4. Tax Laws Offer No Real Obstacle
Ordinarily, appreciation in the dollar-price of gold bullion is taxed at applicable capital gains rates. In the case of certain online digital precious metals currencies, however, this rule may not apply.
It may well be the case that such currencies are given the same tax treatment as other physical, nationally issued currencies of foreign countries, which means in effect that any gains or losses stemmming from fluctuations of the deollar against such currencies are treated as ordinary income gains or losses and are taxed as such.
Goldmoney, Pecunix, and eBullion are examples of digital PM currencies that may fall into this category because their official seats or registered offices are located offshore. E-gold, on the other hand, would be an example of a currency that would not be treated as 'foreign' since its registered office is located within the United States.
It is noteworthy here that Title 26, USC Section 988(e)(2) appears to provide for a $200 exclusion of gains accruing to individuals from transactions in foreign currencies.
If this reading of the statute is correct, it would mean that any gain from the purchase and subsequent sale of a digital gold currency is not taxed as long as the gain does not exceed $200. (As always, this is not to be taken as "legal advice" of any kind. Please consult a competent licensed attorney specializing in tax matters for clarification of the effect, meaning, and proper application of this statute .)
5. Lack of Spendable Gold in Public Possession - Easily Cured
The American public is largely ignorant of the possibility and advantages of not only accumulating, but also spending gold as currency. Because of that, very few Americans own spendable gold. That problem is easy to fix, though. The only real challenge will be to get enough merchants and service providers to get on board and start to accept gold in payment for their products and services.
As already discussed, the mere fact that such huge discounts are offered on some or all products a merchant sells will make customers curious. Very curious. A small hand-out brochure that explains just the most important facts about gold and its use as a store of wealth and currency in a falling fiat-dollar environment will go a long way toward educating Americans.
Without people first having a reason to be interested in gold, all efforts at educating the public will be in vain. To be effective, that reason can't be a purely theoretical one, though. Don't even try to convince people that gold keeps inflation at bay, etc. They just don't care. But give them a solid discount, and you'll be surprised haw fast they will learn the truth about inflation. The best thing is, this takes very little effort on the merchant's part. Once they are curious, just hand'em a brochure. That's all.
What If the Gold Price Drops?
If gold should drop again for any extended period, customers will still be attracted by the discounts. As long as they get their discounts, they'll still like the idea of buying gold and paying with gold. A falling gold price actually makes the idea of buying gold and paying with it to get the discount even more attractive because your customer now pays less for each additional unit of gold he buys.
The only thing that changes now is the benefit to the merchant. The discount, expressed in dollar terms, now increases the gold-proceeds he gains from the transaction. Who wants to complain about that?
For example: If the merchant operates an online retail outlet and his product normally costs $100, and he sells it to a gold-paying customer for a 25% discount applied to the dollar price, the customer has two choices:
A. The customer can go to his online gold account and use new fiat units to buy the gold he needs for the product. In that case he will exchange $75 in FRNs for gold grams. The customer will incur whatever exchange fee is charged by the digital gold currency (DGC) issuer, which will decrease the value of the discount to him. But because of the declining dollar-gold price, his $75 now buy more gold. You, the merchant, therefore end up with more gold!
B. If the customer decides to use previously exchanged, pre-existing gold-units from his account, he will of course incur no additional exchange fee. Yet, in a declining gold price environment, his previously acquired gold unit will have cost him more at the time he acquired it, so he loses there. He'll therefore need to calculate which “loss” is greater and proceed accordingly.
It is important here to remember that any 'loss' we are talking about here is only a minor reduction in the overall benefit of the discount to the customer, so the discount will still produce a net benefit to him, regardless. Also, the additional effort and inconvenience of having to make the above calculation is really no greater than maybe shopping with grocery store coupons.
Considering how many people voluntarily undergo the routines associated with shopping with coupons, the price incentive we are talking abou there is obviously greater than any adverse consideration of this sort. Try getting even anywhere near to an overall 25% savings out of supermarket coupons. Good luck!
What Happens During Gold Price Rises?
During times of gold price increases, the customer's conversion of new dollars into gold yields him less gold at each successive point in time than it did at the previously lower price. He can then use previously acquired gold from his gold account, rather than exchange new fiat-units at the now higher price. That saves him the exchange fees and allows him to avoid the now higher cost of gold. So he goes to his account, calculates the gold gram value of the 75 dollars as of the time of the purchase, and transfers the gold to the seller's account. No problem.
Since seventy five bucks now buy less gold, the merchant ends up with a little less gold than he would in a declining gold price environment. But he still gets the benefit of having earned stable and reliable, over time rising gold rather than fast declining fiat dollar units.
Overall, no matter what the short to medium term gold price trend is, everybody wins, albeit by varying degrees of gain:
- The merchant effortlessly and without out-of pocket cost accumulates a nice base of stable gold currency that he can exchange for either bullion and take delivery or back into fiat units at any time he chooses.
- He also ends up with a growing customer base of people who own gold, who can therefore pay him in gold, and who enjoy the resulting financial security and insulation form a total currency collapse that comes with that ownership.
- At any time of catastrophic currency collapse, both merchant and customer are protected, and the merchant has the added protection of having developed a customer base made up of people who can still buy things from him, regardless of how badly the dollar "bombs."
How to Calculate Physical Gold Transactions:
There already is a Silver & Gold Payment Calculator set up by Katherine Austin-Fitts of Solari and Franklin Sanders of The Moneychanger . It allows anyone to calculate any change to be given a customer who pays with American Eagles or any other country's gold or silver coins.
How Merchants Can Multiply Their Gold-Profits
On top of all this, merchants can take advantage of referral programs offered by several digital gold currency providers.
That means a merchant could purchase gold by going to the Small Business Goldmine referral link when buying gold for his own account. (Note: the DGC issuers we deal with do not have a multi-tier referral structure at this time.) He would lose no money thereby, since the price of gold grams remains the same, regardless of whether he buys directly or through the referral link.
He could then point his customers (or even his vendors) to his own referral link for their gold buying and steadily earn commissions, several levels down, completely passively and without any additional effort - apart from his already existing discount pricing for gold-paying customers and the informational material he provides them.
This will vastly multiply the use of gold and silver in day-to-day e-commerce transactions and create a significant additional level of support under gold and silver's fiat-currency price.
Of course, the same process can be duplicated in other countries, depending on their laws. That way, the world can go a long way toward transitioning to the use of gold and silver as a full-fledged parallel currency. This will happen in spite of the IMF and the world's system of central banks and big financial houses who exercise centralized control over markets and governments alike - and you, the long-time gold investor, will be very well off.
(The Small Business Goldmine was founded for the very purpose of helping to bring this transition about. Your support, in whatever form, whether financial in the form of a Euro vs Dollar Monitor subscription, or in the form of suggestions for improvements, criticism, introductions to helpful individuals and organizations, or otherwise, will be greatly appreciated.)
If we all work together, great days will be ahead for precious metals investors, free market advocates, friends of liberty, supporters of the rule of law, and business owners of every kind and their customers.
Got gold?
Alex Wallenwein
Editor, Publisher
The EURO VS DOLLAR MONITOR
Copyright © 2008 Alex Wallenwein - All Rights Reserved
Alex holds a B.A. degree in Economics and a juris doctorate in Law. His forte is research. In late 1996, he began to research how money is used by some to exert political and economic control over others' lives. In the process, he discovered that gold (along with silver) is the common man's antidote to this effort. In writing and publishing the Euro vs Dollar Monitor, he explains the dynamics of this process and how individuals can harness the power of gold in their efforts to regain their political and financial autonomy.
Just like driving your car, investing only makes sense if you can see where you are going. The Euro vs Dollar Monitor is the golden windshield wiper that removes the media's greasy film of financial misinformation from your investment outlook. Don't drive your investment vehicle without it!
Alex Wallenwein Archive |
Comments
Post Comment (Moderated)