Best of the Week
Most Popular
1.Spain Ignores Scotland Lesson as Catalan Independence Referendum Could Spark Civil War - Nadeem_Walayat
2.Used Car Buying From UK Dealer Top Tips, CarMotion.co.uk Real Customer Experience - N_Walayat
3.Spanish New Civil War Begins as Madrid Regime Storm Troopers Quell Catalan Independence Rebellion - Nadeem_Walayat
4.Virgin Media Broadband Down, Catastrophic UK Wide Failure! - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Are the US Markets setting up for an Early October Surprise? - Chris_Vermeulen
6.The Pension Storm Is Coming To Europe—It May Be The End Of Europe As We Know It -John_Mauldin
7.Stock Market Crash 2018; Will it Prove to be Another Buying Opportunity - Sol_Palha
8.The Profoundly Personal Impact Of The National Debt On Our Retirements - Dan_Amerman
9.Stock Market as Good as it Gets; Like 2000 With a Twist -Gary_Tanashian
10.1987 Stock Market Crash 30th Anniversary Greatest Investing Lesson Learned - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
Bitcoin Hits $6,000, $100 Billion Market Cap As Helicopter Ben and Jamie Demon Warn The End Is Near! - 22nd Oct 17
Time for Caution in Gold Miners - 22nd Oct 17
“Great Rotation” Ahead; Will it Be Inflationary or Deflationary? - 21st Oct 17
The Trigger for Volatility, Rates and the Next Crisis - 21st Oct 17
Perks to Consider an Agent for Auto Insurance - 21st Oct 17
Emerging Megatrends Hurting Consumers - 21st Oct 17
A Catalyst of the Stock Market Bubble Bust - 21st Oct 17
Silver Stocks Comatose - 21st Oct 17
Stock Investors Ignore What May Be The Biggest Policy Error In History - 20th Oct 17
Gold Up 74% Since Last Stock Market Peak 10 Years Ago - 20th Oct 17
Labour Sheffield City Council Employs Army of Spy's to Track Down Tree Campaigners / Felling's Watchers - 20th Oct 17
Stock Market Calm Before The Storm - 20th Oct 17
GOLD Price Creates Bullish Higher Low - 20th Oct 17
Here’s the US’s Biggest Vulnerability in NAFTA Negotiations - 20th Oct 17
The Greatest Investing Lesson Learned from the 1987 Stock Market Crash - 20th Oct 17
Stock Market Time to Go All-in. Short, That Is - 19th Oct 17
How Gold Bullion Protects From Conflict And War - 19th Oct 17
Stock Market Super Cycle Wave C May Have Started - 19th Oct 17
Negative Expectations, Will the Stock Market Correct? - 19th Oct 17
Knowing the Factors Affect your Car Insurance Premium - 19th Oct 17
Getting Your Feet Wet In Crypto Currencies - 19th Oct 17
10 Years Ago Today a Stocks Bear Market Started - 19th Oct 17
1987 Stock Market Crash 30th Anniversary Greatest Investing Lesson Learned - 19th Oct 17
Virgin Media Broadband Down, Catastrophic UK Wide Failure! - 19th Oct 17
The Passive Investing Bubble May Trigger A Massive Exodus from Stocks - 18th Oct 17
Gold Is In A Dangerous Spot - 18th Oct 17
History Says Global Debt Levels Will Lead to Another Crisis - 18th Oct 17
Deflation Basics Series: The Quantity Theory of Money - 18th Oct 17
Attractive European Countries for Foreign Investors - 18th Oct 17
Financial Transcription Services – What investors should know about them - 18th Oct 17
Brexit UK Vulnerable As Gold Bar Exports Distort UK Trade Figures - 18th Oct 17
Surge in UK Race Hate Crimes, Micro-Racism, Sheffield, Millhouses Park, Black on Asian - 18th Oct 17
Comfortably Numb: Surviving the Assault on Silver - 17th Oct 17
Are Amey Street Tree Felling's Devaluing Sheffield House Prices? - 17th Oct 17
12 Real-Life Techniques That Will Make You a Better Trader Now - 17th Oct 17
Warren Buffett Predicting Dow One Million - Being Bold Or Overly Cautious? - 17th Oct 17
Globalization is Poverty - 17th Oct 17
Boomers Are Not Saving Enough for Retirement, Neither Is the Government - 16th Oct 17
Stock Market Trading Dow Theory - 16th Oct 17
Stocks Slightly Higher as They Set New Record Highs - 16th Oct 17
Why is Big Data is so Important for Casino Player Acquisition and Retention - 16th Oct 17
How Investors Can Play The Bitcoin Boom - 16th Oct 17
Who Will Be the Next Fed Chief - And Why It Matters  - 16th Oct 17
Stock Market Only Minor Top Ahead - 16th Oct 17
Precious Metals Sector is on Major Buy Signal - 16th Oct 17
Really Bad Ideas - The Fed Should Have And Defend An Inflation Target - 16th Oct 17
The Bullish Chartology for Gold - 15th Oct 17
Wikileaks Mocking US Government Over Bitcoin Shows Why There Is No Stopping Bitcoin - 15th Oct 17
How to Wipe Out Puerto Rico's Debt Without Hurting Bondholders - 15th Oct 17
Gold And Silver – Think Prices Are Manipulated? Look In The Mirror! - 15th Oct 17

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

3 Videos + 8 Charts = Opportunities You Need to See - Free

Stock Market Copper Metal Price Disconnect

Stock-Markets / Stock Markets 2013 May 31, 2013 - 06:44 PM GMT

By: Zeal_LLC

Stock-Markets

Anybody halfway attuned to the markets knows that copper has been a 21st-century rock star.  No longer just a boring industrial metal, copper is a flamboyant asset that has made fortunes for investors and speculators.  It’s soared a staggering 662% from its 2001 low to 2011 high.  And still today in the $3.25 region copper is nearly four-fold its 20-year pre-bull-market average.

Copper’s journey has of course played out under an umbrella of structurally strong fundamentals, but by no means has it been a lucid and linear trek.  Copper is a commodity after all, and volatility comes with the territory.  Over the last dozen years it’s seen wildly exuberant uplegs as well as crushing selloffs.


Driving copper’s interim movements are a confluence of fundamental, technical, and sentimental drivers.  And provocatively one of the stickiest in recent years is the flagship S&P 500 stock index (SPX).  As irrational as it sounds, there’s no denying the SPX’s influence on copper’s fortunes since early 2009.

Interestingly the catalyst for copper’s linkage to the SPX was 2008’s once-in-a-century stock panic.  Prior to the panic copper’s main price drivers tended to be more fundamentally based, supply and demand.  But with the panic’s splash damage causing a devastating 69% selloff in this metal, fundamentals essentially went out the door.

At its panic nadir copper was so fundamentally undervalued that its recovery would glom on to the greater stock-market recovery.  And for the SPX that recovery commenced following its secondary low in March 2009.  By that time the selling was finally exhausted.  And when sentiment turned, it was open season on any and all assets that had been pummeled during the panic.

As you can see in this chart, the SPX (red) powered higher in an initial upleg that led to a near double in only about a year.  Risk was also on, with the speculators putting big capital to work in the commodities realm.  Copper (blue) was of course a huge beneficiary, and it easily outpaced the SPX’s gains over this same stretch.

Following a mid-2010 correction the SPX again powered higher, resuming its recovery turned cyclical bull market.  And through the first half of 2011 it achieved numerous post-panic highs.  So what did copper do amidst this SPX climb?  Yep, you guessed it, it followed in the SPX’s steps.  Not only did it deliver its own post-panic highs, copper’s February 2011 apex was an all-time nominal high.

What I really want to bring attention to over this stretch is the correlation between the SPX and copper.  And this correlation is apparent not only visually, but mathematically.  From the SPX’s March 2009 low to the end of August 2011 the SPX and copper had a super-high correlation of 0.966, yielding an r-square of 93.3%.  This means that 93% of the daily behavior of copper’s price could be explained by the daily movement of the SPX.  Copper was slave to the SPX for well over two years!

Beginning in September 2011 this correlation started to soften.  While the SPX was consolidating following a strong correction, commodities continued to correct in a brutal selloff sparked by economic fears in Europe and a Fed head-fake here in the US.  And copper, being an economically-sensitive metal, got crushed to its September low.

When the beat down was finally over copper fell back in tow with the SPX, for the most part.  And as you can see in this chart, the SPX’s strong influence over copper persisted essentially through the end of 2012.  Though it didn’t achieve new highs like the SPX, nor was the mathematical correlation as tight, the directionality was quite harmonious.

Going into 2013 it wasn’t too much of a concern that copper wasn’t hitting new highs.  In a generally weak environment for commodities, copper was still 19% higher than its 2011 low while still being at high levels historically.  But as you can see, 2013 hasn’t been kind to this metal.  And it is not because the SPX has been dragging it lower.  In fact, with the SPX powering higher there’s been a clear disconnect of this multi-year relationship.

This disconnect is obviously quite curious.  And it of course begs the question, why did it happen?  Naturally there’s been a flurry of speculation tossed around, from copper’s bull market being over to the SPX leaving everything else in the dust as it floats on pure hubris.  Ultimately there’s countless ways to rationalize what’s been happening, but I believe there’s one fundamental driver that can shoulder a lot of the blame for copper’s fall, LME stockpiles.

The London Metal Exchange is the world’s premier non-ferrous metals exchange, where over 80% of global non-ferrous business is conducted.  And in addition to providing a market for trade and pricing, the LME manages a global network of warehouses that stores the physical metal.

This storage is quite important as not only does it serve to fulfill redeemed contracts, but it offers a place of refuge for excess supply.  Now since most of the copper that’s mined is shipped directly to the end user following refinement, the volume that flows through the LME warehouses is quite insignificant as far as the global trade goes.  But though this warehoused supply is small, it is vitally important as a buffer between producers and consumers.

LME stockpile levels are also important as they give traders an idea about the economic balance of the copper market.  Low and/or declining stockpiles indicate tighter supply, whereas high and/or rising stockpiles indicate excess supply due to overproduction and/or falling demand.

Naturally these factors can have a big influence on price.  And thanks to the LME’s ability to track stockpile levels on a real-time basis, we have a unique and accurate fundamental read on copper’s economic balance.  And a quick peek at current stockpile levels puts the copper-SPX disconnect in perspective.

To provide some context, over the last 5 years copper has been consumed globally at an average rate of about 53k metric tons per day.  So LME stockpile levels at 530k metric tons is equivalent to 10 days’ worth of copper.  And while 10 days of supply is most certainly not bull-ending copper-coming-out-of-our-ears levels, it hardly represents a tight economic balance.

What is tight is anything less than about 5 days.  And provocatively LME stockpiles were in this danger zone for 4+ years leading into the panic.  In fact, back in 2005 alarmingly-low LME stockpiles of only about one day’s worth of supply is what triggered copper to break out to new all-time highs.

To show how much of a price driver LME stockpile levels can be, check out the inverse correlation in the several years leading up to the panic.  During this time the miners were struggling to keep up with demand, resulting in stockpiles fluctuating between 2 to 4 days’ worth of supply.  As stockpiles approached support, prices would rise.  And as they approached resistance, prices would ease.  But this relationship that sported a strong correlation r-square of 73% was blasted apart by the infamous stock panic.

With the world coming to an end, the miners suddenly had a harder time finding buyers, which prompted more delivery to the LME warehouses.  LME stockpile levels thus skyrocketed in unison with copper’s plunge.  And ultimately the global economic uncertainty spawned by this panic would really throw levels out of whack in the subsequent years.

Overall it’s probably a good thing copper hitched to the SPX wagon following the panic.  If it didn’t, and stuck with its classic LME stockpile correlation, its price wouldn’t have had nearly the run due to the appearance that there was an ongoing ease on the economic imbalance that had strained supply.

Interestingly higher sustained stockpile levels following the panic build is partly a consequence of consumer-level inventory management.  Given the economic uncertainty manufacturers tightened inventories, either voluntarily or because they had to considering the lack of available credit.

Also veiled by the post-panic rise of LME stockpile levels was the true state of the copper market, which according to the International Copper Study Group (ICSG) still sported bullish near-term fundamentals.  Interestingly from 2009 to 2012 world refined copper production (of which about 85% comes from mining) fell short of meeting usage by 817k metric tons.  The copper market was actually in a supply deficit.

Though LME stockpiles didn’t decisively fall under that 5-day inventory threshold that starts worrying traders, they did trend down following the panic build.  And even though copper was still glued to the SPX, this downtrend no doubt supported copper’s higher prices.

Also supporting copper on the fundamental front was the fact that world refined copper usage hit successive record highs in 2010, 2011, and 2012 (20.5m metric tons).  We didn’t hear much about this from the mainstream media amidst the tub-thumping of their anti-commodities campaign!

This brings us to 2013.  And it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see why copper has disconnected from the SPX.  Since their low in October, LME copper stockpiles have soared a whopping 191% to this week.  Copper’s producers have pumped 403k metric tons of the metal into LME warehouses in just over 7 months.

This is a major build, the likes of which has only been seen once in copper’s entire bull market.  This other build was of course the panic build, and by quantity it only measured a smidgen higher at 439k metric tons.  At 614k metric tons today, LME copper stockpiles hold nearly 12 days’ worth of supply.  This also represents the highest absolute level in a decade.

Again these are not death-defying levels that alone would signify a bull-ending structural shift.  But they are enough to demonstrate a slackening of the tight balance we’re used to seeing.  And this fundamental slackening is justification for an ease in copper’s price.

And ease is exactly what copper’s price has done.  Copper has disconnected from the SPX’s melt-up to reunite with its old flame, LME copper stockpiles.  So now the question begs, what can we expect for copper going forward?  Unfortunately, its near-term outlook is pretty grim the way I see it.

The good news is the ICSG forecasts record refined copper usage in both 2013 (20.6m mt) and 2014 (21.4m mt).  The problem is this record usage is expected to scrub up with record production (21.2m mt in 2013 and 22.3m mt in 2014) that will push the balance back to a surplus.  And a surplus of 1.1m mt will easily offset the shortage seen in the previous few years.

Copper will also likely face downside pressure from an SPX selloff.  The stock markets are currently hitting a myriad of technical and sentimental extremes that are only seen at major toppings.  And they are well overdue for a major correction.

Copper already has that correlation history with the SPX.  And if sliding stock markets face no fundamental resistance, copper will most certainly experience compounded selling pressure.  Not much else diminishes confidence in the economy faster than falling stock markets, and this could spawn the perfect storm for economically-sensitive copper.

It’ll be interesting to see if a perceived or righteous weakening economy will finally reverse the upward trend on usage.  And if usage indeed goes down and prices stay weak, this will eventually have an adverse effect on mine production as the miners would naturally have a harder time finding buyers (higher-cost producers that have come online in recent years would also face pinched economics).

Overall I suspect we’ll see a myriad of drivers tossing this metal around at least for the near term, with the biggest still being LME stockpiles and the SPX.  And given copper’s forecasted production surplus coupled with an imminent SPX correction, we’ll almost certainly see a weaker copper price.

At Zeal we’ve long been bullish on copper and have made a lot of money for our subscribers over the years going long on its miners.  And we continue to be bullish on this indispensable industrial metal’s long-term outlook.  But in the interim there are just too many bearish factors pitted against it.

In our eyes it’s going to be a rough road ahead as nearly all sectors follow the SPX down.  And copper along with most other commodities will hardly be immune to the selling pressure.  But we do believe there is one sector that will thrive when most others are struggling, the precious metals.

The stars are currently aligned for the precious metals and their stocks to soar.  This sector’s fundamentals and technicals are wildly bullish.  And for a contrarian there couldn’t be a better sentimental setup to support a reversal of fortunes.

At Zeal we’ve been loading up on elite gold and silver stocks in our acclaimed weekly and monthly newsletters.  If you’d like to see which ones we’re recommending to our subscribers, get your subscription today!  And if you’d like detailed fundamental profiles on the stocks we own as well as a select group of other high-potential gold/silver miners that we believe will lead the charge, our wildly popular research reports are currently available at a discount.

The bottom line is following several years of copper moving in tandem with the SPX, 2013 has brought about a decisive disconnect.  While the SPX continues to melt up, copper has trended well to the downside.  And this disconnect was sparked by the rekindling of an old pre-panic relationship.

Soaring LME stockpiles have taken pressure off what’s been a tight economic balance.  And copper’s price could face more headwinds via an imminent SPX correction as well as a forecasted supply surplus over the next couple years.  Copper’s and stocks’ misfortunes should however open the door for precious metals to shine as investors seek alternatives.

By Scott Wright

So how can you profit from this information? We publish an acclaimed monthly newsletter, Zeal Intelligence , that details exactly what we are doing in terms of actual stock and options trading based on all the lessons we have learned in our market research as well as provides in-depth market analysis and commentary. Please consider joining us each month at … www.zealllc.com/subscribe.htm

Thoughts, comments, or flames? Fire away at scottq@zealllc.com . Depending on the volume of feedback I may not have time to respond personally, but I will read all messages. Thanks!

Copyright 2000 - 2013 Zeal Research ( www.ZealLLC.com )

Zeal_LLC Archive

© 2005-2017 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

Catching a Falling Financial Knife