Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. US Housing Market Real Estate Crash The Next Shoe To Drop – Part II - Chris_Vermeulen
2.The Coronavirus Greatest Economic Depression in History? - Nadeem_Walayat
3.US Real Estate Housing Market Crash Is The Next Shoe To Drop - Chris_Vermeulen
4.Coronavirus Stock Market Trend Implications and AI Mega-trend Stocks Buying Levels - Nadeem_Walayat
5. Are Coronavirus Death Statistics Exaggerated? Worse than Seasonal Flu or Not?- Nadeem_Walayat
6.Coronavirus Stock Market Trend Implications, Global Recession and AI Stocks Buying Levels - Nadeem_Walayat
7.US Fourth Turning Accelerating Towards Debt Climax - James_Quinn
8.Dow Stock Market Trend Analysis and Forecast - Nadeem_Walayat
9.Britain's FAKE Coronavirus Death Statistics Exposed - Nadeem_Walayat
10.Commodity Markets Crash Catastrophe Charts - Rambus_Chartology
Last 7 days
A Simple Way to Preserve Your Wealth Amid Uncertainty - 11th Aug 20
Precious Metals Complex Impulse Move : Where Is next Resistance? - 11th Aug 20
Gold Miners Junior Stcks Buying Spree - 11th Aug 20
Has the Fed Let the Inflation Genie Out of the Bottle? - 10th Aug 20
The Strange Food Trend That’s Making Investors Rich - 10th Aug 20
Supply & Demand For Money – The End of Inflation? - 10th Aug 20
Revisiting Our Silver and Gold Predictions – Get Ready For Higher Prices - 10th Aug 20
Storm Clouds Are Gathering for a Major Stock and Commodity Markets Downturn - 10th Aug 20
A 90-Year-Old Stock Market Investment Insight That's Relevant in 2020 - 10th Aug 20
Debt and Dollar Collapse Leading to Potential Stock Market Melt-Up, - 10th Aug 20
Coronavirus: UK Parents Demand ALL Schools OPEN September, 7 Million Children Abandoned by Teachers - 9th Aug 20
Computer GPU Fans Not Spinning Quick FIX - Sticky Fans Solution - 9th Aug 20
Find the Best Speech Converter for You - 9th Aug 20
Silver Bull Market Update - 7th Aug 20
This Inflation-Adjusted Silver Chart Tells An Interesting Story - 7th Aug 20
The Great American Housing Boom Has Begun - 7th Aug 20
NATURAL GAS BEGINS UPSIDE BREAKOUT MOVE - 7th Aug 20
Know About Lotteries With The Best Odds Of Winning - 7th Aug 20
Could Gold Price Reach $7,000 by 2030? - 6th Aug 20
Bananas for All! Keep Dancing… FOMC - 6th Aug 20
How to Do Bets During This Time - 6th Aug 20
How to develop your stock trading strategy - 6th Aug 20
Stock Investors What to do if Trump Bans TikTok - 5th Aug 20
Gold Trifecta of Key Signals for Gold Mining Stocks - 5th Aug 20
ARE YOU LOVING YOUR SERVITUDE? - 5th Aug 20
Stock Market Uptrend Continues? - 4th Aug 20
The Dimensions of Covid-19: The Hong Kong Flu Redux - 4th Aug 20
High Yield Junk Bonds Are Hot Again -- Despite Warning Signs - 4th Aug 20
Gold Stocks Autumn Rally - 4th Aug 20
“Government Sachs” Is Worried About the Federal Reserve Note - 4th Aug 20
Gold Miners Still Pushing That Cart of Rocks Up Hill - 4th Aug 20
UK Government to Cancel Christmas - Crazy Covid Eid 2020! - 4th Aug 20
Covid-19 Exposes NHS Institutional Racism Against Black and Asian Staff and Patients - 4th Aug 20
How Sony Is Fueling the Computer Vision Boom - 3rd Aug 20
Computer Gaming System Rig Top Tips For 6 Years Future Proofing Build Spec - 3rd Aug 20
Cornwwall Bude Caravan Park Holidays 2020 - Look Inside Holiday Resort Caravan - 3rd Aug 20
UK Caravan Park Holidays 2020 Review - Hoseasons Cayton Bay North East England - 3rd Aug 20
Best Travel Bags for 2020 Summer Holidays , Back Sling packs, water proof, money belt and tactical - 3rd Aug 20
Precious Metals Warn Of Increased Volatility Ahead - 2nd Aug 20
The Key USDX Sign for Gold and Silver - 2nd Aug 20
Corona Crisis Will Have Lasting Impact on Gold Market - 2nd Aug 20
Gold & Silver: Two Pictures - 1st Aug 20
The Bullish Case for Stocks Isn't Over Yet - 1st Aug 20
Is Gold Price Action Warning Of Imminent Monetary Collapse - Part 2? - 1st Aug 20
Will America Accept the World's Worst Pandemic Response Government - 1st Aug 20
Stock Market Technical Patterns, Future Expectations and More – Part II - 1st Aug 20
Trump White House Accelerating Toward a US Dollar Crisis - 31st Jul 20
Why US Commercial Real Estate is Set to Get Slammed - 31st Jul 20
Gold Price Blows Through Upside Resistance - The Chase Is On - 31st Jul 20
Is Crude Oil Price Setting Up for a Waterfall Decline? - 31st Jul 20
Stock Market Technical Patterns, Future Expectations and More - 30th Jul 20
Why Big Money Is Already Pouring Into Edge Computing Tech Stocks - 30th Jul 20
Economic and Geopolitical Worries Fuel Gold’s Rally - 30th Jul 20
How to Finance an Investment Property - 30th Jul 20
I Hate Banks - Including Goldman Sachs - 29th Jul 20
NASDAQ Stock Market Double Top & Price Channels Suggest Pending Price Correction - 29th Jul 20
Silver Price Surge Leaves Naysayers in the Dust - 29th Jul 20
UK Supermarket Covid-19 Shop - Few Masks, Lack of Social Distancing (Tesco) - 29th Jul 20
Budgie Clipped Wings, How Long Before it Can Fly Again? - 29th Jul 20
How To Take Advantage Of Tesla's 400% Stock Surge - 29th Jul 20
Gold Makes Record High and Targets $6,000 in New Bull Cycle - 28th Jul 20
Gold Strong Signal For A Secular Bull Market - 28th Jul 20
Anatomy of a Gold and Silver Precious Metals Bull Market - 28th Jul 20
Shopify Is Seizing an $80 Billion Pot of Gold - 28th Jul 20
Stock Market Minor Correction Underway - 28th Jul 20
Why College Is Never Coming Back - 27th Jul 20
Stocks Disconnect from Economy, Gold Responds - 27th Jul 20
Silver Begins Big Upside Rally Attempt - 27th Jul 20
The Gold and Silver Markets Have Changed… What About You? - 27th Jul 20
Google, Apple And Amazon Are Leading A $30 Trillion Assault On Wall Street - 27th Jul 20
This Stock Market Indicator Reaches "Lowest Level in Nearly 20 Years" - 26th Jul 20
New Wave of Economic Stimulus Lifts Gold Price - 26th Jul 20
Stock Market Slow Grind Higher Above the Early June Stock Highs - 26th Jul 20
How High Will Silver Go? - 25th Jul 20
If You Own Gold, Look Out Below - 25th Jul 20
Crude Oil and Energy Sets Up Near Major Resistance – Breakdown Pending - 25th Jul 20
FREE Access to Premium Market Forecasts by Elliott Wave International - 25th Jul 20
The Promise of Silver as August Approaches: Accumulation and Conversation - 25th Jul 20
The Silver Bull Gateway is at Hand - 24th Jul 20
The Prospects of S&P 500 Above the Early June Highs - 24th Jul 20
How Silver Could Surpass Its All-Time High - 24th Jul 20

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Get Rich Investing in Stocks by Riding the Electron Wave

Apple Pie, Economic Growth & Fatal Stock Market Flaws

Stock-Markets / Stock Markets 2014 Oct 09, 2014 - 10:05 PM GMT

By: Dan_Amerman

Stock-Markets

What is it that will actually determine: 1) how our retirement investments will perform, 2) at what age we will be able to retire, and 3) what our standard of living in retirement will be?

For the usual answers, we've been taught to turn to the assumptions of conventional financial planning.  But there's a problem with doing so, which is that the path that the economy and investments have actually taken over the last decade and more doesn't seem to have been anticipated in the usual assumptions.


What actually happened with the Financial Crisis of 2008 and the following Great Recession came as quite a surprise to many, as have the unusually low interest rates which are currently pushing back the planned retirement dates for many millions of people, even as these low rates reduce retirement standards of living.

In the interest of trying to avoid future surprises, perhaps we should start by asking some very common sense questions about retirement savings, that while absolutely essential – are rarely asked. Consider the following three:

1) Can the average person really become wealthier than the average person – or do things need to add up at some point?

2) Can an entire society create paper wealth at a far greater rate than the actual economic growth rate, and then simultaneously cash out this paper wealth into real goods and services?

3) If the economy is made up of corporations, individuals, and all levels of government – and the corporations and individuals, as well as state and local governments are all using investments to attempt to compound their wealth through the markets because neither the corporations, nor the individuals, nor the state and local governments can afford to pay for retirement promises and expectations without those investment sales – then who, precisely, is it that steps in and cashes their investments out?  And with what?

On the rare occasions that these questions are asked, traditionally the answers might involve professional jargon, equations and an elaborate network of interlocking academic theories (which depend on simplifying assumptions and unproven hypotheses to a much greater extent than the general public realizes).

However, there is a simpler path.

As an analogy, consider a fresh, hot pie.  Let’s call it an apple pie, though it could be blueberry or cherry if you prefer.  Whatever the kind, that pie smells delicious, you are hungry, and you'd like a big, fat slice of it.  The problem is, so do a lot of other people.  How large of a piece can you get? 

That depends on three things: 

1) how big the pie is;

2) how many people also want a piece; and

3) whether some people are allowed larger portions than others.

Let’s liken that pie to the national economy.  It's the United States economy that we'll be discussing here, but this can apply to pies of other nations as well.

Now the marvelous thing about economic pies is that in a growing economy they just keep getting bigger, year after year.  And acquiring ourselves a big piece of that pie in the future is the motivation for investing of course.  We all want as generous a portion of that expanding pie as we can get, and fortunately there are plenty of people willing to sell us future pieces of that pie.

Just how big is that succulent pie going to be?  Various reasonable long-term rates of return for our investments are suggested depending on the source and investment type, but a nice one is 8%.  Eight percent is a good number for example's sake, not just because it is nice and round, but it represents roughly what a particular type of calculation tells us is the long-term rate of return in the stock market. 

So we take $1,000 today, invest it for 30 years, and with annual compounding (reinvestment of our earnings as we get them) that $1,000 sitting in a tax-deferred account soars to a total of $10,062, including our profit of $9,062.  That is the amazing stuff of which financial planning is made!

The Economic Pie

Another approach is to look at the economic fundamentals of our pie.  That is, buying investments essentially means that we are buying an ownership interest in the economy.  When we buy shares of stock, we become owners of that corporation.  Given that the economy is primarily made up of corporations, by collectively owning those shares of stock, we as investors effectively own much of the private economy.

Over the long term in the previous century (1950-2000), the United States economy grew at about 3.5% per year after removing the effects of inflation (source:  Bureau of Economic Analysis).  Of that about 1.2% a year can be accounted for by population growth (source:  Census Bureau).  Adjusted for inflation, then, we have real growth – per person – in the economy of about 2.2% a year.  Now, take that same $1,000, and invest it for 30 years at a 2.2% rate, and it becomes worth… $1,921. 

Uh, oh.

It seems like there might be a problem there.  We buy investments expecting over 30 years to earn a 906% ($9,062) profit from our ownership interests in the economy.  But after accounting for inflation and population growth, the overall per capita economic pie has only grown 92% ($921).  So our expectations for growth in investment wealth are ten times larger than the growth in the real economy.

Pie Problems

I think you can see our pie problem, which is the difference between looking at the pie, and actually eating the pie.  Around fifty million Baby Boomers are planning on eating generous slices of a really big investment pie at some point down the road.  Not just all of the people who buy stocks and other investments directly, but also all of those who buy them through their retirement accounts, and indeed, anyone who is planning on getting a pension as part of their retirement.

So the issue is that when we add up all the different expectations for our future pieces of Investment Pie, and compare them to what in reality the total Economic Pie is likely to be – there just isn’t enough pie to go around. 

Now an individual can certainly earn a particularly fat slice of the pie, so long as they follow an investment strategy that works out very well indeed.  As some investors have in the past, and as others will in the future. 

However, getting back to one of those fundamental questions: how can everybody earn those big slices simultaneously, as the conventional investment models indicate they will?  How can one sixth of the entire population simultaneously have their real net worth increase 10 times faster (906/92) than the real per capita worth of the nation itself?

The amount of real wealth in terms of resources is growing far, far slower than people’s perceptions of their current and future wealth, as valued by their investment portfolios.  And we have an enormous group of people planning on actually selling those investment portfolios to get real resources, simultaneously, year after year.  How do we make it all add up?

The answer seems clear. Which is that they can earn that wealth on paper, but when it comes to real resources, it is unfortunately simply impossible for them to all to cash it out.  Like a pie, an economy is made up of the sum of its slices.  And when most of the people invested in that economy are all expecting their own slices to grow far faster than we know the overall pie is growing – an awful lot of people are likely to be very disappointed.

Historical Returns & Hypothetical Behavior

As long as we are asking questions, this is probably a good place to ask another:  if an 8% investment return rate and 2.2% per capita economic growth rate are both based on long term history – what’s the problem?  Obviously they can coexist, so why worry? 

The issue is not whether stocks can earn an 8% paper yield while the economy is growing 2% on a real per-capita basis – so long as more people are putting money into the markets than are pulling it out.  Because that can work just fine, as it has many years in the past. 

The issue is all the people who looked at that 8% yield, and said, “Hey, we just found a magic money machine!  All we have to do is assume 100% reinvestment of our investment earnings through our pensions, investment funds, IRAs and Keoghs, and all of society together can achieve financial security!  And we can run models using hypothetical investor behavior to prove it historically!”.

(The particulars for the Magic Money Machine are explored in more detail here.)

If we take an equation with a high growth rate – and let it run wild with no constraints – then the math seems to prove that we all become wealthy, or at the least financially secure.

Keep going in time, and the same math necessarily also proves that our cumulative wealth will grow until it is larger than the universe itself. 

Go still further out in time, and the mathematical equations will insist that each of our individual portfolios will grow until they are larger than the universe, too.

Uh oh. 

See, that’s the usual problem with running exponential equations with no outside constraints, and is the reason these equations are used with great caution in fields other than finance, or subjects other than our collective life savings.

The issue with that approach – which underlies most long term investment planning today – is that the 10 to 1 figure isn’t so much based on historical earnings as it is the hypothetical compounding.  All we’ve really done is demonstrate that exponential compounding is a powerful mathematical concept. 

Unfortunately there are indeed constraints, and cashing out real goods and services requires a real economic pie.  If we look at actual financial history, never before have we had so many people planning on eating such nice big slices of pie, and over such long retirements on top of that.  In the past, life spans were generally shorter, and the ownership of securities was concentrated in a much smaller segment of the population. 

We’ve made three big changes with our hypothetical investment models, which separate our current expectations from the historical yield analyses.

1) Never before have we had so many people – and such a large percentage of the population – investing in the markets .  

2) Long term exponential compounding of our wealth had not previously been the objective – or the majority's behavior.

3) (And this is the most important part), never has such a large segment of society attempted to simultaneously convert such high compounded wealth expectations into real resources, for year after year, over a period of decades. 

We have never before seen anything like this three way combination. Thus the ability of the markets to withstand this unprecedented test while delivering high rates of return is not based on history, but rather is unproven theory.

More Logic Flaws & Uncommon Questions

The 2nd half of this article (linked below) poses quite a few more questions while examining additional logic flaws in the agreed-upon conventional wisdom for how we should all invest.

Continue Reading The Article

Daniel R. Amerman, CFA

Website: http://danielamerman.com/

E-mail:  mail@the-great-retirement-experiment.com

Daniel R. Amerman, Chartered Financial Analyst with MBA and BSBA degrees in finance, is a former investment banker who developed sophisticated new financial products for institutional investors (in the 1980s), and was the author of McGraw-Hill's lead reference book on mortgage derivatives in the mid-1990s. An outspoken critic of the conventional wisdom about long-term investing and retirement planning, Mr. Amerman has spent more than a decade creating a radically different set of individual investor solutions designed to prosper in an environment of economic turmoil, broken government promises, repressive government taxation and collapsing conventional retirement portfolios

© 2014 Copyright Dan Amerman - All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer: This article contains the ideas and opinions of the author.  It is a conceptual exploration of financial and general economic principles.  As with any financial discussion of the future, there cannot be any absolute certainty.  What this article does not contain is specific investment, legal, tax or any other form of professional advice.  If specific advice is needed, it should be sought from an appropriate professional.  Any liability, responsibility or warranty for the results of the application of principles contained in the article, website, readings, videos, DVDs, books and related materials, either directly or indirectly, are expressly disclaimed by the author.


© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules