Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. US Housing Market Real Estate Crash The Next Shoe To Drop – Part II - Chris_Vermeulen
2.The Coronavirus Greatest Economic Depression in History? - Nadeem_Walayat
3.US Real Estate Housing Market Crash Is The Next Shoe To Drop - Chris_Vermeulen
4.Coronavirus Stock Market Trend Implications and AI Mega-trend Stocks Buying Levels - Nadeem_Walayat
5. Are Coronavirus Death Statistics Exaggerated? Worse than Seasonal Flu or Not?- Nadeem_Walayat
6.Coronavirus Stock Market Trend Implications, Global Recession and AI Stocks Buying Levels - Nadeem_Walayat
7.US Fourth Turning Accelerating Towards Debt Climax - James_Quinn
8.Dow Stock Market Trend Analysis and Forecast - Nadeem_Walayat
9.Britain's FAKE Coronavirus Death Statistics Exposed - Nadeem_Walayat
10.Commodity Markets Crash Catastrophe Charts - Rambus_Chartology
Last 7 days
The AI Mega-trend Stocks Investing - When to Sell? - 28th May 20
Trump vs. Biden: What’s at Stake for Precious Metals Investors? - 28th May 20
Stocks: What to Make of the Day-Trading Frenzy - 28th May 20
Why You’ll Never Get Another Stimulus Check - 28th May 20
Implications for Gold – 2007-9 Great Recession vs. 2020 Coronavirus Crisis - 28th May 20
Ray Dalio Suggests USA Is Entering A Period Of Economic Decline And New World Order - 28th May 20
Europe’s Coronavirus Pandemic Dilemma - 28th May 20
I Can't Pay My Payday Loans What Will Happen - 28th May 20
Predictive Modeling Suggests US Stock Markets 12% Over Valued - 27th May 20
Why Stocks Bear Market Rallies Are So Tricky - 27th May 20
Precious Metals Hit Resistance - 27th May 20
Crude Oil Cuts Get Another Saudi Boost as Oil Demand Begins to Show Signs of Life - 27th May 20
Where the Markets are heading after COVID-19? - 27th May 20
Silver Springboards Higher – What’s Next? - 26th May 20
Stock Market Key Resistance Breakout Is Where the Rubber Meets the Road - 26th May 20
5 Ways To Amp Up Your CFD Trading Today - 26th May 20
The Anatomy of a Gold Stock Bull Market - 26th May 20
Stock Market Critical Price Level Could Soon Prompt A Big Move - 25th May 20
Will Powell Decouple Gold from the Stock Market? - 25th May 20
How Muslims Celebrated EID in Lockdown Britain 2020 - UK - 25th May 20
Stock Market Topping Behavior - 24th May 20
Fed Action Accelerates Boom-Bust Cycle; Not A Virus Crisis - 23rd May 20
Gold Silver Miners and Stocks (after a quick drop) Ready to Explode - 23rd May 20
3 Ways to Prepare Financially for Retirement - 23rd May 20
4 Essential Car Trade-In Tips To Get The Best Value - 23rd May 20
Budgie Heaven at Bird Land - 23rd May 20
China’s ‘Two Sessions’ herald Rebound of Economy - 22nd May 20
Signs Of Long Term Devaluation US Real Estate - 22nd May 20
Reading the Tea Leaves of Gold’s Upcoming Move - 22nd May 20
Gold, Silver, Mining Stocks Teeter On The Brink Of A Breakout - 21st May 20
Another Bank Bailout Under Cover of a Virus - 21st May 20
Do No Credit Check Loans Online Instant Approval Options Actually Exist? - 21st May 20
An Eye-Opening Perspective: Emerging Markets and Epidemics - 21st May 20
US Housing Market Covid-19 Crisis - 21st May 20
The Coronavirus Just Hit the “Fast-Forward” Button on These Three Industries - 21st May 20
AMD Zen 3 Ryzen 9 4950x Intel Destroying 24 core 48 thread Processor? - 21st May 20
Dow Stock Market Trend Analysis and Forecast - 20th May 20
The Credit Markets Gave Their Nod to the S&P 500 Upswing - 20th May 20
Where to get proper HGH treatment in USA - 20th May 20
Silver Is Ensured A Prosperous 2020 Thanks To The Fed - 20th May 20
It’s Not Only Palladium That You Better Listen To - 20th May 20
DJIA Stock Market Technical Trend Analysis - 19th May 20
US Real Estate Showing Signs Of Covid19 Collateral Damage - 19th May 20
Gold Stocks Fundamental Indicators - 19th May 20
Why This Wave is Usually a Market Downturn's Most Wicked - 19th May 20
Gold Mining Stocks Flip from Losses to 5x Leveraged Gains! - 19th May 20
Silver Price Begins To Accelerate Higher Faster Than Gold - 19th May 20
Gold Will Soar Soon; World Now Faces 'Monetary Armageddon' - 19th May 20

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Coronavirus-stocks-bear-market-2020-analysis

Stock Market’s Breadth is Weak: Stocks Will Crash! Just Kidding

Stock-Markets / Stock Markets 2018 Oct 05, 2018 - 08:15 AM GMT

By: Troy_Bombardia

Stock-Markets

We’ve done 2 kinds of stock market studies recently.

  1. The U.S. stock market’s own price action.
  2. The U.S. stock market’s breadth.

Market studies related to the stock market’s own price action have mostly been bullish.

Market studies related to the stock market’s breadth have been mixed. Some are bullish, while others are very bearish.

So what gives? Why are some breadth studies so bearish? (e.g. Hindenburg Omen)


If you read the mainstream financial media’s headlines, it seems like the stock market is going to crash because “breadth is very weak”. They all sound something like this:

  1. The stock market (e.g. Dow) is going up, but most of the NYSE’s stocks are in a bear market! (Below their 200 dma).
  2. The Dow closed at an all-time high. However, 3x as many stocks on the NYSE hit 52 week lows vs 52w highs! Before, this only happened in December 1999!

Seems super bearish doesn’t it? I’ll admit, I kind of got sucked into this trap recently. But a little voice kept ringing in the back of my mind. “How is this possible? If most stocks are going down, and FANG stocks have been falling recently, who the hell is going up”? This is a purely mathematical question about how averages work.

Turns out “most stocks are going down right now” is a highly misleading statement.

I’ve reflected on a lot of market studies from 2017. Pretty much all the FAILED bearish studies were of the exact same sort: these “bearish NYSE breadth” studies.

*Breadth was flashing a super bearish sign every single month from January – December 2017. Meanwhile the stock market rallied incessantly.

So why have breadth indicators failed consistently over the past few years?

Never let the truth get in the way of a good story

Why is it that the NYSE’s breadth is so “bad” (only 55% of NYSE stocks are above their 200 dma) while 65% of the S&P 500’s stocks are above their 200 dma?

Because the NYSE no longer best reflects “the U.S. stock market”.

From Wikipedia:

The NYSE Index covers over 2000 stocks. More than 1600 are from U.S. corporations and over 360 are from foreign corporations. HOWEVER, foreign companies are very prevalent among the largest companies in the index. Of the 100 largest (by market cap), 55% are non-U.S. companies.

So straight away, you can see that the NYSE’s doesn’t accurately reflect the “U.S. stock market”. In a year like 2018 during which foreign stocks are being clobbered, it’s clear why the NYSE lags the S&P 500 so much (and why the NYSE’s breadth is so much worse than the S&P 500’s breadth).

Only 55% of NYSE stocks are above their 200 dma.

While 65% of S&P 500 stocks are above their 200 dma.

So why is it that in the past, these kinds of bearish NYSE breadth divergences marked the 2000 and 2007 tops? (more common during 1999 – 2000)

Because the world has changed

In the past (pre-2008), the NYSE mostly listed U.S. stocks. But with the advent of globalization, more and more foreign stocks are being listed on U.S. exchanges (e.g. Alibaba). This coincides with the rise of China. A lot of Chinese and foreign companies have listed their stocks on U.S. exchanges over the past 10 years (think Alibaba, Baidu, Tencent).

  1. Before the GFC, these breadth divergences in the NYSE accurately reflected breadth divergences in the “U.S. stock market”.
  2. Today, more and more “breadth divergences” in the NYSE reflect a divide between U.S. and foreign stocks. It doesn’t tell you much about breadth divergences in the U.S. stock market itself.

Year to date, foreign stocks have been slaughtered by Trump’s trade war while the U.S. stock market has gone up.

Looking at the actual data

Holy shit! Over the past few days, there were 3x more issues on the New York Stock Exchange that made 52 week lows vs. the number of issues that made 52 week highs!

These kinds of statements are very popular on financial media and fintwit, because everyone loves a good story about “how the stock market’s breadth is super weak and stocks will crash”.

But how many of these people have actually seen WHY breadth is “so weak”?

Here’s a glance at the actual data:

52 week highs

52 week lows

What do you see?

  1. The issues making 52 week highs are mostly stocks.
  2. The issues making 52 week lows are mostly bond funds and preferred.

As you can see, this isn’t exactly a “stock market breadth divergence”. This is more of a “stocks are going up while bonds are going down” divergence.

This is easy to understand. Bond prices are falling right now because interest rates are going up.

And as we’ve demonstrated in the past, rising interest rates aren’t bearish for the stock market. The stock market goes up more often than it goes down when interest rates rise.

Conclusion

So there you have it. Saying that “the stock market’s breadth is weak” because “the NYSE’s breadth is weak” is misleading. The NYSE doesn’t accurately reflect “the U.S. stock market”.

  1. Over the years, the NYSE is increasingly weighed down by foreign (non-U.S.) stocks.
  2. The NYSE has a lot of bond funds that fall when interest rates are rising.

The most accurate breadth indicator for the “U.S. stock market” = “the % of S&P 500 stocks that are above their 200 dma”. And right now, most S&P 500 stocks are above their 200 dma. Otherwise the equal-weighted version of the S&P 500 wouldn’t be rising as well. (That’s pretty much how averages work).

Lessons

Lesson #1

The first lesson is simple. Never take things at face value. Always dig a little deeper. Financial media has an incentive to sensationalize everything. After all, why let the truth get in the way of a good story, when a good story gets more eyeballs and attention? Compare these 2 headlines. Which do you think will get more clicks on CNBC?

  1. Here’s why the stock market will go up 7% next year.
  2. Here’s why the stock market will crash -30% next year.

Lesson #2

The second lesson is more technical. Going forward, I am going to post fewer of these market studies about breadth and post more market studies about the U.S. stock market’s (S&P 500’s) own price action.

Breadth indicators tend to give a LOT of false bearish signals. With so many breadth indicators out there, there will always be some that send bearish signals. I admit that I have fallen a little into this trap lately, so I am correcting myself now.

Lesson #3

For U.S. stock market breadth indicators, focus on indexes instead of exchanges. The S&P 500 includes AMERICAN companies. The NYSE and NASDAQ have a lot of foreign stocks (e.g. Baidu, Alibaba).

Times change, which means that the nature of various indicators change. The NYSE Index no longer reflects “the U.S. stock market” the way it used to.

Lesson #4

Be wary of market studies with limited data. You see this a lot:

“The stock market is doing XYZ right now. Since 1995-present, XYZ has only happened in 1999 and 2007”.

While this may have occurred in 1999 and 2007, it might have also occurred before a lot of big rallies in the 1980s and 1990s. Permabears love to use only data after 1999 because it increases the probability of a “bear market study”.

More data is always better than less.

Lesson #5

Ignore financial dogma, and examine the facts for yourself

Click here for more market studies

By Troy Bombardia

BullMarkets.co

I’m Troy Bombardia, the author behind BullMarkets.co. I used to run a hedge fund, but closed it due to a major health scare. I am now enjoying life and simply investing/trading my own account. I focus on long term performance and ignore short term performance.

Copyright 2018 © Troy Bombardia - All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.


© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules