Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. US Housing Market House Prices Bull Market Trend Current State - Nadeem_Walayat
2.Gold and Silver End of Week Technical, CoT and Fundamental Status - Gary_Tanashian
3.Stock Market Dow Trend Forecast - April Update - Nadeem_Walayat
4.When Will the Stock Market’s Rally Stop? - Troy_Bombardia
5.Russia and China Intend to Drain the West of Its Gold - MoneyMetals
6.BAIDU (BIDU) - Top 10 Artificial Intelligence Stocks Investing To Profit from AI Mega-trend - Nadeem_Walayat
7.Stop Feeding the Chinese Empire - ‘Belt and Road’ Trojan Horse - Richard_Mills
8.Stock Market US China Trade War Panic! Trend Forecast May 2019 Update - Nadeem_Walayat
9.US China Trade Impasse Threatens US Lithium, Rare Earth Imports - Richard_Mills
10.How to Invest in AI Stocks to Profit from the Machine Intelligence Mega-trend - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
IBM - Investing in AI Machine Intelligence Stocks - 25th May 19
Seasonal Dysfunction: Why Generations of Gold and Silver Investors Are Having Such Difficulty - 25th May 19
Employment - The Good and the Bad of Job Automation - 25th May 19
Gold Mining Mid-Tier Stocks Fundamentals - 25th May 19
Buy This Pick-and-Shovel 5G Stock Before It Takes Off - 25th May 19
China Hang Seng Stocks Index Collapses and Commodities - 24th May 19
Costco Corp. (COST): Finding Opportunity in Five Minutes or Less - 24th May 19
How Free Bets Have Impacted the Online Casino Industry - 24th May 19
This Ultimate Formula Will Help You Avoid Dividend Cutting Stocks - 24th May 19
Benefits of a Lottery Online Account - 24th May 19
Technical Analyst: Gold Price Weakness Should Be Short Term - 24th May 19
Silver Price Looking Weaker than Gold - 24th May 19
Nigel Farage's Brexit Party EU Elections Seats Results Forecast - 24th May 19
Powerful Signal from Gold GDX - 24th May 19
Eye Opening Currency Charts – Why Precious Metals Are Falling - 23rd May 19
Netflix Has 175 Days Left to Pull Off a Miracle… or It’s All Over - 23rd May 19
Capitalism Works, Ravenous Capitalism Doesn’t - 23rd May 19
The Euro Is Bidding Its Time: A Reversal at Hand? - 23rd May 19
Gold Demand Rose 7% in Q1 2019. A Launching Pad Higher for Gold? - 23rd May 19
Global Economic Tensions Translate Into Oil Price Volatility - 22nd May 19
The Coming Pension Crisis Is So Big That It’s a Problem for Everyone - 22nd May 19
Crude Oil, Hot Stocks, and Currencies – Markets III - 22nd May 19
The No.1 Energy Stock for 2019 - 22nd May 19
Brexit Party and Lib-Dems Pull Further Away from Labour and Tories in Latest Opinion Polls - 22nd May 19
The Deep State vs Donald Trump - US vs Them Part 2 - 21st May 19
Deep State & Financial Powers Worry about Alternative Currencies - 21st May 19
Gold’s Exciting Boredom - 21st May 19
Trade War Fears Again, Will Stocks Resume the Downtrend? - 21st May 19
Buffett Mistake Costs Him $4.3 Billion This Year—Here’s What Every Investor Can Learn from It - 21st May 19
Dow Stock Market Trend Forecast 2019 May Update - Video - 20th May 19
A Brief History of Financial Entropy - 20th May 19
Gold, MMT, Fiat Money Inflation In France - 20th May 19
WAR - Us versus Them Narrative - 20th May 19
US - Iran War Safe-haven Reasons to Own Gold - 20th May 19
How long does Google have to reference a website? - 20th May 19
Tory Leadership Contest - Will Michael Gove Stab Boris Johnson in the Back Again? - 19th May 19
Stock Market Counter-trend Rally - 19th May 19
Will Stock Market “Sell in May, Go Away” Lead to a Correction… or a Crash? - 19th May 19
US vs. Global Stocks Sector Rotation – What Next? Part 1 - 19th May 19
BrExit Party EarthQuake Could Win it 150 MP's at Next UK General Election! - 18th May 19
Dow Stock Market Trend Forecast 2019 May Update - 18th May 19
US Economy to Die a Traditional Death… Inflation Is Going to Move Higher - 18th May 19
Trump’s Trade War Is Good for These 3 Dividend Stocks - 18th May 19
GDX Gold Mining Stocks Fundamentals Update - 17th May 19
Stock Markets Rally Hard – Is The Volatility Move Over? - 17th May 19
The Use of Technical Analysis for Forex Traders - 17th May 19
Brexit Party Set to Storm EU Parliament Elections - Seats Forecast - 17th May 19
Is the Trade War a Catalyst for Gold? - 17th May 19
This Is a Recession Indicator No One Is Talking About—and It’s Flashing Red - 17th May 19
War! Good or Bad for Stocks? - 17th May 19
How Many Seats Will Brexit Party Win - EU Parliament Elections Forecast 2019 - 16th May 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

U.S. House Prices Analysis and Trend Forecast 2019 to 2021

Bring on the Empty Silver ETFs?

Commodities / Gold & Silver Apr 20, 2007 - 07:35 PM GMT

By: Roland_Watson

Commodities

This week has been a busy week for silver as announcements of two silver ETFs were made to the media. When I read the words "silver" and "ETF" I was part hoping it was finally the silver stocks ETF I mentioned in the latest issue of my newsletter. However, it was not to be as the third silver ETF was announced by the Zurich Cantonal Bank along with their platinum and palladium ETFs. It will start trading on the 10th May.

I asked for the prospectus and got some documents in German. I ran it through Google translator and got some extra items of information.


  • This is an ETF targeting institutional and high net worth investors. Further information suggests it is only available to Swiss investors.
  • It is also not bought via shares but by physical ounces. The silver is stored in 30kg bars which presumably equates to the 1000oz bars held by the Barclays silver ETF.
  • Subscribers to the ETF can also take delivery of the physical metal they have previously bought but only in 1000oz bars.
  • Also for the bears, the ETF can be shorted.

Going by the size of their already running gold ETF ($380M or about 560,000 ounces of gold), I don't expect it to outdo the Barclays silver ETF. At a gold silver ratio of 50 that equates to 28 million ounces of silver, far less than the 135 million ounces currently with Barclays. So this ETF seems more limited in scope than the Barclays ETF, but nevertheless shows the continued interest that is being generated in the realm of precious metals investment.

Now no sooner had I completed my thoughts on this ETF than a fourth silver ETF was announced to investors the next day! This announcement came from the London based ETF Securities who will be setting up ETFs for gold, silver, platinum and palladium each backed by physical metal. There will also be an ETF which is a mix of all four metals. The firm denotes these physical metal vehicles as Exchange Traded Commodities (ETCs) rather than Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs). This is perhaps to distinguish them from the silver ETF and others that ETF Securities already run. Their current silver ETF is not backed by physical but merely tracks the price of silver using the DJ-AIG Silver Sub-Index. The two are distinguished by the titles ETFS Physical Silver and ETFS Silver.

So now silver investors have the choice of the Barclays ETF, the Zurich ETF and the ETFS ETF and ETC run from London. However, some may say that none of the above holds physical silver.

My aforementioned German translation says this:

" The ZKB Silver ETF exclusively invests into physical silver ."

and

" Contrary to existing ETFs, for which usually a basket of shares is the basis, the ZKB silver ETF invests only in physical silver ."

Is this implying that the Barclays silver ETF doesn't have any physical silver? I don't think it does unless ZKB like collecting lawsuits as a hobby. The first quote is merely saying that the ZKB silver ETF only holds physical silver and does not hold silver by proxy (e.g. derivatives, equities). The second quote is simply stating that their ETF is denominated in a different manner - ounces instead of shares. It is highly unlikely that one major bank would accuse another bank of silver subterfuge in their promotional literature!

But let us address the "empty ETF" theory. The Barclays silver ETF started trading on Friday 28th April 2006. Three weeks later, silver plunged from $15 to $9.50 and to this day has meandered between those two prices. Silver investors who are open to conspiracy theories blame the ETF. In fact, a recent article on the web suggested that the ETF is a fraud instrument to divert money from physical silver and also provide cash for the shorts to beat down silver more.

In my opinion this theory is wrong. People who specialize in gold tend to map their gold arguments onto silver. So if gold is perceived as being "managed" then so must silver. This is not so - even if gold was being micromanaged by government agencies and proxies.

The truth of the matter is that Barclays have every darned ounce they claim to have apart from when they have to hold a little cash and extract their admin fees. The problem for conspiracy theorists was when Barclays accumulated 130 million ounces without causing a default in the silver markets. Some thought this wasn't possible due to their perceived supply constraints in the silver market. This is an example of theory dictating to the facts rather than the other way round. Instead of accepting this, some people created "hidden" facts such as empty ETF vaults to nullify the open facts.

So what about the supposed non-appearance of a silver default? It wouldn't have escaped people's attention that silver had more than tripled in price since June 2003. Why had silver tripled in price? It had tripled because increasing demand has been putting pressure on supply hence the market adjustment in price to bring more silver to the marketplace to rebalance supply-demand. What does that tell us?

Basically, a silver supply constraint is not defined as silver at $50, $100 or more. It is defined as a sustained rise in the silver price. It is not defined by how long it takes to take delivery of physical silver; it is defined by an increasingly more expensive price. In other words, the silver supply problem is already here - it just arrived quietly and not with a sonic boom as some expected. So don't pick price targets, just go with the market flow and make your profits.

Now I don't know about anyone who didn't get their silver if they waited long enough and a delay is not a default. If you want to see a real default, check out the recent nickel market problems in London where defaulted contracts had to be settled in cash. This has not happened in the silver markets.

I have never had a problem getting hold of bars and coins - but I sure had to pay more for them as others jumped into the silver investor category. Indeed, the well known Goldmoney and CEF funds hold over 40 million ounces of silver and counting between them! Expect these funds plus the three ETFs mentioned to bring the silver haul into the hundreds of millions of ounces as this silver bull progresses.

Now all this does not mean that there will be no future crisis in the silver supply-demand balancing act, I believe there will be but for now the silver supply problem is no different to other commodity supply issues we are currently witnessing, albeit very profitable and easier to invest in (how many copper ETFs are there?).

But it is a supply problem nevertheless. Indeed, when ETF Securities announced their platinum ETC, the reaction by platinum producers produced another proof of why the Barclays silver ETF has all the silver it claims to have. The world's biggest platinum producer is Angloplat and it was sufficiently concerned about potential supply problems to state that it would not be providing metals for the platinum ETC.

Does this not remind us of the Silver Users Association who tried to get the SEC to reject the filing for the Barclays Silver ETF last year? Now if this ETF was a conspiracy to keep the shorts happy with a suppressed silver price, then why would the SUA try to get it stopped? The answer is simple; they knew it would be holding real physical silver in vast quantities and hence adding fuel to a silver price rise. So much for the silver shorts seeing this ETF as a brake on silver prices. In fact, not a few commentators thought a silver ETF could be a non-starter because of the potential disruption to supply. That so far has not proven to be the case and the same will probably go for the platinum ETFs.

So what was going on with Barclays and silver? Here is an alternative theory to what Barclays did before and after the ETF launch. It is as good as any conspiracy theory and probably just as improvable!

Up to a year before the ETF launch, I suggest Barclays were acquiring or placing orders for large quantities of silver while silver was still relatively cheap. Whether they did this through the futures market or direct from refiners, I don't know. They knew the silver bull was real and that the ETF anticipation would add extra impetus to the silver price so they decided to get silver while it was cheap. Why did they do this? So that when the ETF launched, they would have silver bought at $7 which they would later sell to ETF investors at double digit prices. The silver investors get their silver at current market prices and Barclays pocket the difference. Perfectly legal and I applaud them for their foresight in doing this. After all, that is the same plan we silver investors have for our smaller inventories - buy low and sell high!

Eventually, Barclays slowed down their silver acquisition around launch date and demand dropped enough to catalyze a correction in the silver price. Of course, Barclays may have got all this wrong and ended up holding a mountain of silver no one wanted. But I say that Barclays being the big investment house they are would have applied standard hedging techniques to ameliorate any losses to the downside. In summary, Barclays knew exactly what they were doing and they have perhaps been doing it again during the times of $10 silver in anticipation of more buyers at higher prices. That is my counter-theory to Barclays and silver and you can take it or leave it.

Is this in fact what happened? Of course, I have no way of knowing but it makes more sense than the theory that mega-bank corporations are worried about a tiny silver market whose size is dwarfed by markets which have a much bigger say in the fragility of fiat money, inflation and the economy. The multi-trillion dollar bond market is one example.

Is the price of little ole silver important to government and big business? Why should it be anymore than the price of zinc or lead? How many people in the world follow the price of silver as an indicator of fiat money weakness? Not many I suspect. The internationally accessed BBC News website does not even list the silver price on its commodity market page.

So there is no motive to manipulate the price of silver. That may have been done in decades past to support the American mining industry and stop the silver content of coins exceeding their face value but not now.

Now is different. Silver is floating in price and by the time this current phase of the silver bull market ends, a high grade supply of 300 million or more ounces of ETF, Goldmoney and CEF silver could be available to dump onto unsuspecting investors.

Let me tell you, THAT is a more frightening thought about ETFs than any conspiracy theory can care to suggest.

By Roland Watson
http://silveranalyst.blogspot.com

Further analysis of the SLI indicator and more can be obtained by going to our silver blog at http://silveranalyst.blogspot.com where readers can obtain the first issue of The Silver Analyst free and learn about subscription details. Comments and questions are also invited via email to silveranalysis@yahoo.co.uk .


© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules