Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Market Decline Will Lead To Pension Collapse, USD Devaluation, And NWO - Raymond_Matison
2.Uber’s Nightmare Has Just Started - Stephen_McBride
3.Stock Market Crash Black Swan Event Set Up Sept 12th? - Brad_Gudgeon
4.GDow Stock Market Trend Forecast Update - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Gold Significant Correction Has Started - Clive_Maund
6.British Pound GBP vs Brexit Chaos Timeline - Nadeem_Walayat
7.Cameco Crash, Uranium Sector Won’t Catch a break - Richard_Mills
8.Recession 2020 Forecast : The New Risks & New Profits Of A Grand Experiment - Dan_Amerman
9.Gold When Global Insanity Prevails - Michael Ballanger
10.UK General Election Forecast 2019 - Betting Market Odds - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
Market Action Suggests Downside in Precious Metals - 15th Oct 19
US Major Stock Market Indexes Retest Critical Price Channel Resistance - 15th Oct 19
“Baghad Jerome” Powell Denies the Fed Is Using Financial Crisis Tools - 15th Oct 19
British Pound GBP Trend Analysis - 14th Oct 19
A Guide to Financing Your Next Car - 14th Oct 19
America's Ruling Class - Underestimating Them & Overestimating Us - 14th Oct 19
Stock Market Range Bound - 14th Oct 19
Gold, Silver Bonds - Inflation in the Offing? - 14th Oct 19
East-West Trade War: Never Take a Knife to a Gunfight - 14th Oct 19
Consider Precious Metals for Insurance First, Profit Second... - 14th Oct 19
Stock Market Dow Elliott Wave Analysis Forecast - 13th Oct 19
The Most Successful IPOs Have This One Thing in Common - 13th Oct 19
Precious Metals & Stock Market VIX Are Set To Launch Dramatically Higher - 13th Oct 19
Discovery Sport EGR Valve Gasket Problems - Land Rover Dealer Fix - 13th Oct 19
Stock Market US Presidential Cycle - Video - 12th Oct 19
Social Security Is Screwing Millennials - 12th Oct 19
Gold Gifts Traders With Another Rotation Below $1500 - 12th Oct 19
US Dollar Index Trend Analysis - 11th Oct 19
China Golden Week Sales Exceed Expectations - 11th Oct 19
Stock Market Short-term Consolidation Does Not change Secular Bullish Trend - 11th Oct 19
The Allure of Upswings in Silver Mining Stocks - 11th Oct 19
US Housing Market 2018-2019 and 2006-2007: Similarities & Differences - 11th Oct 19
Now Is the Time to Load Up on 5G Stocks - 11th Oct 19
Why the Law Can’t Protect Your Money - 11th Oct 19
Will Miami be the First U.S. Real Estate Bubble to Burst? - 11th Oct 19
How Online Casinos Maximise Profits - 11th Oct 19
3 Tips for Picking Junior Gold Stocks - 10th Oct 19
How Does Inflation Affect Exchange Rates? - 10th Oct 19
This Is the Best Time to Load Up on These 3 Value Stocks - 10th Oct 19
What Makes this Gold Market Rally Different From All Others - 10th Oct 19
Stock Market US Presidential Cycle - 9th Oct 19
The IPO Market Is Nowhere Near a Bubble - 9th Oct 19
US Stock Markets Trade Sideways – Waiting on News/Guidance  - 9th Oct 19
Amazon Selling Fake Hard Drives - 4tb WD Blue - How to Check Your Drive is Genuine  - 9th Oct 19
Whatever Happened to Philippines Debt Slavery?  - 9th Oct 19
Gold in the Negative Real Interest Rates Environment - 9th Oct 19
The Later United States Empire - 9th Oct 19
Gold It’s All About Real Interest Rates Not the US Dollar - 8th Oct 19
A Trump Impeachment Would Cause The Stock Market To Rally - 8th Oct 19
The Benefits of Applying for Online Loans - 8th Oct 19
Is There Life Left In Cannabis - 8th Oct 19
Yield Curve Inversion Current State - 7th Oct 19
Silver Is Cheap – And Getting Cheaper - 7th Oct 19
Stock Market Back to Neutral - 7th Oct 19
Free Market Capitalism: Laughably Predictable - 7th Oct 19
Four Fundamental Reasons to Buy Gold and Silver - 7th Oct 19
Gold and Silver Taking a Breather - 7th Oct 19
Check Engine Warning Light ECU Dealer Diagnostic Cost - Land Rover Discovery Sport - 6th Oct 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Stock Market Trend Forecast Oct - Dec 2019 by Nadeem Walayat

Gold Vs. Miners: The Wrong Question, Part I

Commodities / Gold and Silver 2011 Oct 13, 2011 - 12:34 PM GMT

By: Adrian_Ash

Commodities

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleYou want leverage in gold? Buy bullion. It keeps turning every 1% gain in gold mining stocks into a 2% rise...

SO WHY is it that gold mining stocks underperforming the metal so badly? "Gold stocks should be a levered bet on the price of gold...There has been a terrible underperfomance," as one UK forum posting said back in June.


"Thought this could be a good hedge against market meltdown but doesn't follow gold price," said another gold mining fund holder in August.

"Switched my portfolio to Blackrock Gold Acc in Feb. '11 with the naive thinking it would give me a good exposure to gold prices," said a third. "Gold has jumped 30% since then, but the fund is pretty much at the same price.

"I know there must be a lot of people in the same situation."

Too true. February 2011 saw retail investors using UK brokerage TD Waterhouse choose Blackrock Gold & General as the top holding in their tax-protected ISA accounts for the third year running. And why ever not? Over the 12 years to this spring, as Blackrock's own website says, its Gold & General Fund was the best-performing ISA product bar none. "Our investors," said TD Waterhouse, "appear to be seeking some solidity in light of the continued Eurozone sovereign debt crisis and concerns over possible future inflation."

But while solidity paid off, gold mining stocks did not. Over the next 6 months – and as the Eurozone debt crisis hit fresh peaks, and UK inflation held at 20-year highs above 5% year-on-year – gold put on 29% for Dollar investors and rose 27% for UK buyers. Gold equities, in contrast, lost 16% on the XAU index of US-listed producer stocks. Fighting the headwind of a falling Dollar, Blackrock's Gold & General fund could only cut that loss in half for its UK investors.



"We're confident the gap will close," said Evy Hambro, manager of the £3.3 billion mining-share fund ($5.2bn), to the Financial Times in September. "It has always closed in the past. This is an abnormally long one and an abnormally large one."

But how long? And how abnormal exactly? No one's expecting the answer which the data throw out.

"Gold shares historically outperform Gold Bullion in a rising market due to the operational gearing," says another UK-run gold fund in its sales literature. That's because, in a bull market for bullion, you'd expect Gold Mining firms to have "fixed or semi-fixed costs [but] rising revenue stream." So you might even expect that famed 2-to-1 or 3-to-1 leverage over the gold price cited so often in mining-stock stories online.

But no...

Percentage Point Performance Relative to Gold

 

YTD

1 yr

3 yr

5 yr

10 year

15 year

XAU Mining Index

-18

-29

56

-129

-198

-260

HUI Index

-7

-19

100

-98

257

-100

Barrick (ABX)

-14

-23

35

-108

-212

-207

Newmont (NEM)

3

-17

69

-121

-251

-267

US Global fund

-10

-24

154

-51

545

327

Tocqueville fund

-18

-27

195

-62

403

n/a

Van Eck fund

-15

-26

163

-55

474

0

BlackRock fund*

-30

-30

-31

-111

275

184

*Relative to gold in GBP               Source: BullionVault via Bloomberg, Yahoo

This table reviews the last 15 years of gold-equity action relative to the price of gold bullion, ignoring dividends from the miners. (Gold-mining investors have got used to ignoring them too, of course.) Three things jump out, as you can see:

• First, not all gold mining stocks, indices or managed funds are the same, not by a mile;
• The right miners (and the right funds) performed as expected if you bought them far enough back, outperforming gold bullion by a good margin since 1996 or 2001;
• Three years ago – October 2008 – was a one-time chance to pick up Gold Mining equity at such a wide discount, even shares in the biggest, lumbering producers have since beaten the investment return on plain gold bullion.

That opportunity to beat gold with stocks was very rare. Take the Philadelphia Stock Exchange's XAU index of gold and silver miners, for instance. Its plunge amid the Lehman Brothers' meltdown of 2008 made October that year the only month-end to offer the opportunity of out-performing gold bullion's gains today since the XAU index was launched in 1983. Yes, really.

On the Amex Gold Bugs Index (the HUI), only 12 separate months in the last 120 have now seen new buyers out-pace gold bullion at today's levels. For the UK's actively-managed BlackRock Gold & General, it's four months in the last nine years. For US Global Investors' gold fund, 11 months in the last six years, and for the Tocqueville Gold Fund, it's 20 months in the last eight years.

Underperformance in gold-mining equity is thus starting to look the norm, not the exception, relative to gold bullion. Not only the producers as a group, but also the two biggest gold stocks (Barrick and Newmont) and even the top-performing managed funds are lagging it badly over 5 years, 1 year, and 2011 to date. Leverage to the gold price it ain't.

Since Oct. 2006, in fact, every 1% move in the gold price has seen the gold mining producers add just 0.25% to their stock price on the XAU index. So far in 2011, they've turned every 1% gain into a 0.2% loss.

Since Oct. 2006, in fact, every 1% move in the gold price has seen the gold mining sector add just 0.4% to their stock price on the HUI index. So far in 2011, they've turned every 1% gain into a 0.2% loss on the XAU.

The question, therefore, isn't why the miners and funds are lagging gold. It's why does gold keep beating the equity? Why has it reversed the expected leverage, turning every 1% rise in gold mining stocks into a better than 2% gain since 2006...? And might it be that this "abnormality" is in fact critical to the underlying bull market in bullion?

By Adrian Ash
BullionVault.com

Gold price chart, no delay   |   Buy gold online at live prices

Formerly City correspondent for The Daily Reckoning in London and a regular contributor to MoneyWeek magazine, Adrian Ash is the editor of Gold News and head of research at www.BullionVault.com , giving you direct access to investment gold, vaulted in Zurich , on $3 spreads and 0.8% dealing fees.

(c) BullionVault 2011

Please Note: This article is to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it.


© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules