Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Market Decline Will Lead To Pension Collapse, USD Devaluation, And NWO - Raymond_Matison
2.Uber’s Nightmare Has Just Started - Stephen_McBride
3.Stock Market Crash Black Swan Event Set Up Sept 12th? - Brad_Gudgeon
4.GDow Stock Market Trend Forecast Update - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Gold Significant Correction Has Started - Clive_Maund
6.British Pound GBP vs Brexit Chaos Timeline - Nadeem_Walayat
7.Cameco Crash, Uranium Sector Won’t Catch a break - Richard_Mills
8.Recession 2020 Forecast : The New Risks & New Profits Of A Grand Experiment - Dan_Amerman
9.Gold When Global Insanity Prevails - Michael Ballanger
10.UK General Election Forecast 2019 - Betting Market Odds - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
Gold and Silver - The Two Horsemen - 11th Nov 19
Towards a Diverging BRIC Future - 11th Nov 19
Welcome to the Zombie-land Of Stock Market Investing - 11th Nov 19
Illiquidity & Gold And Silver In The End Game - 11th Nov 19
Key Things You Need to Know When Starting a Business - 11th Nov 19
Stock Market Cycles Peaking - 11th Nov 19
Avoid Emotional Investing in Cryptocurrency - 11th Nov 19
Australian Lithium Mines NOT Viable at Current Prices - 10th Nov 19
The 10 Highest Paying Jobs In Oil & Gas - 10th Nov 19
World's Major Gold Miners Target Copper Porphyries - 10th Nov 19
AMAZON NOVEMBER 2019 BARGAIN PRICES - WD My Book 8TB External Drive for £126 - 10th Nov 19
Gold & Silver to Head Dramatically Higher, Mirroring Palladium - 9th Nov 19
How Do YOU Know the Direction of a Market's Larger Trend? - 9th Nov 19
BEST Amazon SMART Scale To Aid Weight Loss for Christmas 2019 - 9th Nov 19
Why Every Investor Should Invest in Water - 8th Nov 19
Wait… Was That a Bullish Silver Reversal? - 8th Nov 19
Gold, Silver and Copper The 3 Metallic Amigos and the Macro Message - 8th Nov 19
Is China locking up Indonesian Nickel? - 8th Nov 19
Where is the Top for Natural Gas? - 7th Nov 19
Why Fractional Shares Don’t Make Sense - 7th Nov 19
The Fed Is Chasing Its Own Tail; It Doesn’t Care What You Think - 7th Nov 19
China’s path from World’s Factory to World Market - 7th Nov 19
Where Is That Confounded Recession? - 7th Nov 19
FREE eBook - The Investment Strategy that could change your future - 7th Nov 19
Is There a Stock Market Breakout Ahead? - 6th Nov 19
These Indicators Aren’t Putting to an Economic Resurgence - 6th Nov 19
Understanding the Different Types of Travel Insurance - 6th Nov 19
The Biggest Gold Story Of 2020 - 6th Nov 19
Best Money Saving FREE Bonfire Night Fire Works Show Sheffield 2019 - 5th Nov 19
Is the Run on the US Dollar Due to Panic or Greed? - 5th Nov 19
Reasons Why Madrid Attracts Young Professionals - 5th Nov 19
Larger Bullish Move in USD/JPY May Just Be Getting Started - 5th Nov 19
Constructive Action in Gold & Silver Stocks - 5th Nov 19
The Boring Industry That Hands +500% Gains - 5th Nov 19
Stock Market Chartology vs Fundamentals - 4th Nov 19
The Fed’s Policy Is Like Swatting Flies with Nuclear Weapons - 4th Nov 19
Stock Market Warning: US Credit Delinquencies To Skyrocket In Q4 - 4th Nov 19
Stock Market Intermediate Topping Process Continues - 4th Nov 19
Stock Market $SPY Expanded Flat, Déjà Vu All Over Again - 4th Nov 19
How To Buy Gold For $3 An Ounce - 4th Nov 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How To Buy Gold For $3 An Ounce

The Dummies Guide To Valuing A CDO: Reference Barnett-Hart’s Thesis

Interest-Rates / Credit Crisis 2010 Mar 20, 2010 - 03:01 PM GMT

By: Andrew_Butter

Interest-Rates

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleThe “News” over the past eighteen months, is that the people who said that they knew how to do a rating on a CDO (Collateralized Debt Obligation), now say they don’t know how to do that.

And the people who said they knew how to value a CDO, or a RMBS (Residential Mortgaged Backed Security), now say they can’t do that either.


And The Reason Why? Well they realised that in fact they never knew how to do it in the first place, which is why they managed to lose “X” trillion for their employers or customers, which fortunately (for them) the American Taxpayer has agreed to pay back, on account of the fact that people who are completely clueless are essential for the proper functioning of the US economy.

That’s nice.

Although, on reflection, I’m quite glad I don’t pat US taxes.

I was reading A.K. Barnett-Hart’s now famous undergraduate thesis “The Story of the CDO Market Meltdown: An Empirical Analysis”. It’s impressive, it’s also a very well written and easy-to-read account of what happened; you can find a link to it here:

http://blogs.wsj.com/deals/2010/03/15/michael-lewiss-the-big-short-read-the-harvard-thesis-instead/

One of her conclusions, based on doing multivariate regression analysis was that the best predictor of a CDO default; is the year it was written, like if it used mortgages written in 2006 and 2007.  I’m not sure if I understood her table right but it looked like she got a 35% R-Squared on that.

Pity she didn’t put in the extent of mispricing of the housing market as a variable (housing was the fundamental asset that collateralized most of those instruments).

For example – here is a plot of data that I eyeballed from one of her charts (Fig 11), plotted against the extent of market mispricing that I calculated in September 2008:

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article6250.html

What that says is essentially confirming what Barnett-Hart was saying, i.e. that when the junk going into the CDO was 2006 or 2007 vintage, well, they blew up; but what that adds is putting a number to it, and identifying the key driver.

The straight line R-Squared is 88% for twenty points of data (love to have the actual but there you go), I suspect though the best-fit is an “S” curve which has a 92% R-Squared.

That’s a pretty similar result to the analysis that I did a while ago:

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article12918.html

That was looking at an analysis that I did of a study done by a team from Columbia University led by Dr. Wei Jiang which as far as I have seen represents the most coherent study of the mortgage market in USA (not as famous as Ms. Barnett-Hart but then she writes really nice, and dare I say it, she is a LOT prettier).

So two pieces of evidence that basically the level of toxicity is a function of how badly the geniuses misread the market mispricing, basically if the LTV you use is about right, then OK, defaults are low, like about zero.

You are a genius – collect $6 billion in fees.

BUT if the value you use for the “L” in the LTV is wrong – like by about 40% too high (I’m talking about reference “Other than Market Value here, not “What you might have sold the asset to some dumb bastard to yesterday” (M-2-M)),  then the chances of a default are well pretty much linear in line with the mispricing.

Except there is an “S-Curve” – which is normal in nature.

I used to work on a toxic-asset-assembly line, my job was to work out “V” , and I’m proud to say that every  “V’ that I worked out was the “V” in ten years time (that I said it would be).

Pretty boring stuff, but if you have money and you want to make you “V” go up, it’s a good idea to know what “V” really is today (outside of the “V” you can get from selling something to someone dumber than you).

Insofar as either rating or valuing a CDO (or any other sort of toxic asset is concerned), what this analysis shows is that 90% of that is about the “V”.

Work out the “V” and well, let the remaining 10% just take care of itself.

By Andrew Butter

Twenty years doing market analysis and valuations for investors in the Middle East, USA, and Europe; currently writing a book about BubbleOmics. Andrew Butter is managing partner of ABMC, an investment advisory firm, based in Dubai ( hbutter@eim.ae ), that he setup in 1999, and is has been involved advising on large scale real estate investments, mainly in Dubai.

© 2010 Copyright Andrew Butter- All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

Andrew Butter Archive

© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules