Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. The Trump Stock Market Trap May Be Triggered - Barry_M_Ferguson
2.Why are Central Banks Buying Gold and Dumping Dollars? - Richard_Mills
3.US China War - Thucydides Trap and gold - Richard_Mills
4.Gold Price Trend Forcast to End September 2019 - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Money Saving Kids Gardening Growing Giant Sunflowers Summer Fun - Anika_Walayat
6.US Dollar Breakdown Begins, Gold Price to Bolt Higher - Jim_Willie_CB
7.INTEL (INTC) Stock Investing to Profit From AI Machine Learning Boom - Nadeem_Walayat
8.Will Google AI Kill Us? Man vs Machine Intelligence - N_Walayat
9.US Prepares for Currency War with China - Richard_Mills
10.Gold Price Epochal Breakout Will Not Be Negated by a Correction - Clive Maund
Last 7 days
Thomas Cook COLLAPSE! 300,000 Passengers Stranded, Flights Cancelled, Planes Grounded - 23rd Sep 19
Massive Stock Market Price Reversion May Be Days or Weeks Away - 22nd Sep 19
How Russia Seized Control of the Uranium Market - 22nd Sep 19
Dow Stock Market Trend Forecast Update - 21st Sep 19
Is Stock Market Price Revaluation Event About To Happen? - 21st Sep 19
Gold Leads, Will the Rest Follow? - 21st Sep 19
Are Cowboys Really Dreaming of... Electric Trucks? - 21st Sep 19
Gold among Negative-Yielding Bonds - 20th Sep 19
Panicky Fed Flooding Overnight Markets with Cash - 20th Sep 19
Uber Stock Price Will Crash on November 6 - 20th Sep 19
Semiconductor Stocks Sector Market & Economic Leader - 20th Sep 19
Learning Artificial Intelligence - What is a Neural Network? - 20th Sep 19
Precious Metals Setting Up Another Momentum Base/Bottom - 20th Sep 19
Small Marketing Budget? No Problem! - 20th Sep 19
The Many Forex Trading Opportunities the Fed Day Has Dealt Us - 19th Sep 19
Fed Cuts Interest Rates and Gold Drops. Again - 19th Sep 19
Silver Still Cheap Relative to Gold, Trend Forecast Update Video - 19th Sep 19
Baby Boomers Are the Worst Investors in the World - 19th Sep 19
Your $1,229 FREE Tticket to Elliott Market Analysis & Trading Set-ups - 19th Sep 19
Is The Stock Market Other Shoe About To Drop With Fed News? - 19th Sep 19
Bitcoin Price 2019 Trend Current State - 18th Sep 19
No More Realtors… These Start-ups Will Buy Your House in Less than 20 Days - 18th Sep 19
Gold Bugs And Manipulation Theorists Unite – Another “Manipulation” Indictment - 18th Sep 19
Central Bankers' Desperate Grab for Power - 18th Sep 19
Oil Shock! Will War Drums, Inflation Fears Ignite Gold and Silver Markets? - 18th Sep 19
Importance Of Internal Rate Of Return For A Business - 18th Sep 19
Gold Bull Market Ultimate Upside Target - 17th Sep 19
Gold Spikes on the Saudi Oil Attacks: Can It Last? - 17th Sep 19
Stock Market VIX To Begin A New Uptrend and What it Means - 17th Sep 19
Philippines, China and US: Joint Exploration Vs Rearmament and Nuclear Weapons - 17th Sep 19
What Are The Real Upside Targets For Crude Oil Price Post Drone Attack? - 17th Sep 19
Curse of Technology Weapons - 17th Sep 19
Media Hypes Recession Whilst Trump Proposes a Tax on Savings - 17th Sep 19
Understanding Ways To Stretch Your Investments Further - 17th Sep 19
Trading Natural Gas As The Season Changes - 16th Sep 19
Cameco Crash, Uranium Sector Won’t Catch a break - 16th Sep 19
These Indicators Point to an Early 2020 Economic Downturn - 16th Sep 19
Gold When Global Insanity Prevails - 16th Sep 19
Stock Market Looking Toppy - 16th Sep 19
Is the Stocks Bull Market Nearing an End? - 16th Sep 19
US Stock Market Indexes Continue to Rally Within A Defined Range - 16th Sep 19
What If Gold Is NOT In A New Bull Market? - 16th Sep 19
A History Lesson For Pundits Who Don’t Believe Stocks Are Overvalued - 16th Sep 19
The Disconnect Between Millennials and Real Estate - 16th Sep 19
Tech Giants Will Crash in the Next Stock Market Downturn - 15th Sep 19
Will Draghi’s Swan Song Revive the Eurozone? And Gold? - 15th Sep 19
The Race to Depreciate Fiat Currencies Is Accelerating - 15th Sep 19
Can Crypto casino beat Hybrid casino - 15th Sep 19
British Pound GBP vs Brexit Chaos Timeline - 14th Sep 19
Recession 2020 Forecast : The New Risks & New Profits Of A Grand Experiment - 14th Sep 19
War Gaming the US-China Trade War - 14th Sep 19
Buying a Budgie, Parakeet for the First Time from a Pet Shop - Jollyes UK - 14th Sep 19
Crude Oil Price Setting Up For A Downside Price Rotation - 13th Sep 19
A “Looming” Recession Is a Gold Golden Opportunity - 13th Sep 19
Is 2019 Similar to 2007? What Does It Mean For Gold? - 13th Sep 19
How Did the Philippines Establish Itself as a World Leader in Call Centre Outsourcing? - 13th Sep 19
UK General Election Forecast 2019 - Betting Market Odds - 13th Sep 19
Energy Sector Reaches Key Low Point – Start Looking For The Next Move - 13th Sep 19
Weakening Shale Productivity "VERY Bullish" For Oil Prices - 13th Sep 19
Stock Market Dow to 38,000 by 2022 - 13th Sep 19 - readtheticker
Gold under NIRP? | Negative Interest Rates vs Bullion - 12th Sep 19
Land Rover Discovery Sport Brake Pads and Discs's Replace, Dealer Check and Cost - 12th Sep 19
Stock Market Crash Black Swan Event Set Up Sept 12th? - 12th Sep 19
Increased Pension Liabilities During the Coming Stock Market Crash - 12th Sep 19
Gold at Support: the Upcoming Move - 12th Sep 19
Precious Metals, US Dollar, Stocks – How It All Relates – Part II - 12th Sep 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Nadeem Walayat Financial Markets Analysiis and Trend Forecasts

Liar Loans Were Not The Problem: Don't Worry About Re-Sets...Just A Scare Like Y-2K

Housing-Market / US Housing Aug 21, 2009 - 01:15 PM GMT

By: Andrew_Butter

Housing-Market

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleYears ago I got a project building a credit scoring system for a bank that did auto loans in Dubai, it was a lot of fun, I got hold of tons of data, did a multivariate regression analysis, and the result was absolutely useless.


About the only thing that really worked was if the borrower owned a dog; owning a dog and paying your debts on time are incredibly well correlated. Now that's an idea, how about instead of "cash for clunkers"..."cash for puppies?"

The reason was that everyone lied on the applications, we did some audit trails it was a disaster. In the last meeting I ever had with that client I suggested that perhaps it might be a good idea to hook the borrowers up to a lie detector when they filled out their forms. That marked one of the low points in my otherwise (broadly) un-tarnished career of "exceeding customer expectations".

I remembered that incident when I saw all the press about "Liar Loans".

Apparently the credit crunch was not caused by incompetent and crooked bankers, it was caused by liars, presumably therefore if a way can be found to stop people lying then the world can be saved and we can all live happily ever after. Q.E.D.

There is another explanation:
In the olden days everyone assumed that everyone else was lying, and a lot of the time they were. In those days what the smart bankers used to look at very hard was the "pound of flesh".

The point of course which was conveniently forgotten in the mad rush to load up as much money out of bonuses as possible, is that it's not what the collateral could have sold for yesterday that matters (mark-to-market on the day the loan was written), it's what you can sell it for when the realization hits that the guy you handed over a bunch of money to a year or two ago never had any intention of paying it back (and didn't).

Prove it!!
One wouldn't have thought that after thousands of years of bankers finding out by painful trial and error that (a) many people lie, and (b) if you can't sell the collateral for more than you advanced you lose money (or more precisely the people who own the bank that foolishly agreed to employ you looses money, (and these days so do the taxpayers); but you don't care because you got your bonus. That's of course the secret of any bank robbery, be long-gone before anyone finds out).

Be that as it may, I was looking at the results of a study done by a team from Columbia University led by Dr. Wei Jiang which as far as I know represents the most coherent study of the mortgage market in USA (http://www.columbia.edu/~wj2006/liars_loan.pdf).

But I don't agree with the conclusion (which was that Liar Loans were what caused the credit crunch (and implicitly there is a lot more trouble to come). That's an over-simplification but...round numbers.

Where I think they went wrong (and I'm trying to persuade them to run my numbers, which they might, perhaps); was that they didn't put the value of "pound of flesh" (at the point in time you might want to sell it, in other words what International Valuation Standards calls "Other-Than-Market-Value"), into the pot.

Which I suppose is understandable since only 17,000 people read the article I wrote on this last September, and Market Oracle is hardly "mainstream".  Anyway with Dr. Wei's kind permission I have done some rough analysis.

This is one of the charts they published (the dotted lines are mine).

Then I did something very "un-scientific", I extrapolated the chart they published (those are the dotted lines), to get an estimate of the delinquency after 48 months for all the data of the various times of when the loan was written except Jan/Feb 08 since that was not half a year (if you eyeball the chart you can see that there is typically a sort of leveling off after the initial flurry, and I used the slope of 2004 2nd quarter as a template).

Then I plotted that against the estimate of market mispricing of the US housing market which I published in September 2008 (http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article6250.html), and I explained a bit in a piece on Bubble Economics recently (http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article12114.html).

Just for reference the mispricing is the difference between "mark-to-market" value and the "other than market" value worked out using International Valuation Standards.

Anyway, this is how it looked (I put in the 28 month data as was shown just as a comparison, the problem with that is (a) it's less data and (b) the dynamics of all the lines hadn't stabilized; but the picture looks pretty much the same):

Well that works for me better than any story about the credit crunch being the fault of liars.

What that says is that 98% of the delinquency rate can be predicted from knowing what the level of mispricing of the housing market was at the time of writing the loan (and that algorithm predicts the delinquency 8% at the 95% confidence level).

OK so we can attribute the remaining 2% of the credit crunch to liars. Big Deal (actually it doesn't work like that but I think it is highly unlikely that "Liar Loan" as a variable would trump mispricing and I strongly suspect there would be an auto-correlation).

So what's Liar Loans got to do with it?

In my opinion it's co-incidental.

The reason why there were so many liar loans at the end of that sad saga was that was when they were "scraping the barrel", and they reached a point where (a) anyone could get a loan and (b) the dumb bankers didn't care a toss about the probable value of the collateral in 48 months time (and by the way you could work out other than market value then, just the idiot bankers were too focused on their bonuses to bother, or perhaps they didn't know how?  (That wouldn't surprise me either)).

CONCLUSION
I know everyone is in a mad funk about what happens when the "Re-sets" start kicking in, but I don't buy that.

What matters is how much people paid for their house compared to what it's worth now, or more precisely what it will be worth in two years time.

And that's not going to get much worse, no-one will be selling now unless they are forced to, and remember that people fool themselves that their houses are worth more than they actually are...the line goes like this..."hey honey are we in negative equity?".

To which the only sensible answer (if you want to sleep), is "don't worry your pretty little head about that sweetheart, of course we aren't". And if you can lie to your sweetheart why can't you lie to that jerk in a suit?

The resets are going to come and go like Y-2K, house prices will stabilize at about 40% peak to trough average (10% to go or so (http://seekingalpha.com/article/153182-u-s-housing-one-dead-cat-bounce-two-sucker-rallies-to-go)), then after a while they will start to pick up, and the world will go on.

And people will still lie to each other.

By Andrew Butter

Andrew Butter is managing partner of ABMC, an investment advisory firm, based in Dubai ( hbutter@eim.ae ), that he setup in 1999, and is has been involved advising on large scale real estate investments, mainly in Dubai.

© 2009 Copyright Andrew Butter- All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

Andrew Butter Archive

© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Comments

Kenneth Dost
24 Aug 09, 20:47
Liar Loans

Hello, is anybody home in the real world. Over 70% of subprime loans were given to those borrowers who actually qualified for prime loans that were steered into subprime loans by crooked and unscrupulous brokers. Liar loans? more like cover up while the brokers skate away and good and honest Americans are losing their homes.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules