Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Gold Final Warning: Here Are the Stunning Implications of Plunging Gold Price - P_Radomski_CFA
2.Fed Balance Sheet QE4EVER - Stock Market Trend Forecast Analysis - Nadeem_Walayat
3.UK House Prices, Immigration, and Population Growth Mega Trend Forecast - Part1 - Nadeem_Walayat
4.Gold and Silver Precious Metals Pot Pourri - Rambus_Chartology
5.The Exponential Stocks Bull Market - Nadeem_Walayat
6.Yield Curve Inversion and the Stock Market 2019 - Nadeem_Walayat
7.America's 30 Blocks of Holes - James_Quinn
8.US Presidential Cycle and Stock Market Trend 2019 - Nadeem_Walayat
9.Dear Stocks Bull Market: Happy 10 Year Anniversary! - Troy_Bombardia
10.Britain's Demographic Time Bomb Has Gone Off! - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
Stock Market Crash Edition - 26th Mar 19
Handy Ways to Boost Your Home Income - 26th Mar 19
US Treasury Bond Yield Inversion and Political Fed Cycles - 26th Mar 19
Golan Heights Oil all about the Shekels - 26th Mar 19
Falling Yields a Catalyst for The Gold Catalyst - 26th Mar 19
Can We Lock Up Rachel Maddow Now? - 25th Mar 19
Real US National Debt Might Be $230 Trillion - 25th Mar 19
Friday's Stock Market Sell-Off - New Downtrend or Just Correction? - 25th Mar 19
20 Days Left to Find Buying Opportunities In Gold - 25th Mar 19
Will the Historic Imbalance in Gold Stocks to Gold Price Resolve ? - 25th Mar 19
EasySMX Wireless Games Controllers Review - 25th Mar 19
Stock Market Short-term Top - 25th Mar 19
UK Population Growth - Latest ONS Immigration Statistics and Consequences - 24th Mar 19
The Fed Follows Trump's Tweets, And Does The Right Thing - 24th Mar 19
Yield Curves, 2yr Yield, SPX Stocks and a Crack Up Boom? - 24th Mar 19
Risk/Reward in Silver Favors Buying Now, Not Waiting for Big Moves - 23rd Mar 19
Similarities Between Stock Market Today and Previous Bull Market Tops - 23rd Mar 19
Stock Market DOW Seasonal Trend Analysis - 23rd Mar 19
US Dollar Breakdown on Fed Was Much Worse Than It Looks - 23rd Mar 19
Gold Mid-Tier GDXJ Stocks Fundamentals - 23rd Mar 19
Which Currency Pairs Stand to Benefit from Prevailing Risk Aversion? - 23rd Mar 19
If You Get These 3 Things Right, You’ll Never Have to Worry About Money - 22nd Mar 19
March 2019 Cryptocurrency Technical Analysis - 22nd Mar 19
Turkey Tourist Fakes Market Bargains Haggling Top Tips - 22nd Mar 19
Next Recession: Finding A 48% Yield Amid The Ruins - 22nd Mar 19
Your Future Stock Returns Might Unpleasantly Surprise You - 22nd Mar 19
Fed Acknowledges “Recession Risks”. Run for the Hills! - 22nd Mar 19
Will Bridging Loans Grow in Demand and Usage in 2019? - 22nd Mar 19
Does Fed Know Something Gold Investors Do Not Know? - 21st Mar 19
Gold …Some Confirmations to Watch For - 21st Mar 19
UKIP No Longer About BrExit, Becomes BNP 2.0, Muslim Hate Party - 21st Mar 19
A Message to the Gold Bulls: Relying on the CoT Gives You A False Sense of Security - 20th Mar 19
The Secret to Funding a Green New Deal - 20th Mar 19
Vietnam, Part I: Colonialism and National Liberation - 20th Mar 19
Will the Fed Cut its Interest Rate Forecast, Pushing Gold Higher? - 20th Mar 19
Dow Jones Stock Market Topping Pattern - 20th Mar 19
Gold Stocks Outperform Gold but Not Stocks - 20th Mar 19
Here’s What You’re Not Hearing About the US - China Trade War - 20th Mar 19
US Overdosing on Debt - 19th Mar 19
Looking at the Economic Winter Season Ahead - 19th Mar 19
Will the Stock Market Crash Like 1937? - 19th Mar 19
Stock Market VIX Volaility Analysis - 19th Mar 19
FREE Access to Stock and Finanacial Markets Trading Analysis Worth $1229! - 19th Mar 19
US Stock Markets Price Anomaly Setup Continues - 19th Mar 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Stock Market Trend Forecast March to September 2019

Fear The New Krugman

Economics / Economic Theory Mar 18, 2010 - 09:29 AM GMT

By: Brady_Willett


Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleSuch explosive growth in debt can't go on forever, and it won't. Yet our current leaders and their apologists insist that the problem will magically solve itself.  Paul Krugman ~ November 4, 2003

The U.S. borrows and spends beyond its means and almost everyone realizes that tough policy choices must be made to avert disaster.  However, rather than confront the imbalances that have resulted from U.S. profligacy by ending U.S. profligacy, there is the growing threat that policy makers are in search of ‘magical’ alternatives. One such alternative is trying to force China to stop ‘manipulating’ its currency.

While the Yuan ‘manipulation’ theme is not new, the contrast of little or no growth in America versus supergrowth in China has sparked renewed interest. Highlighting this interest was a recent letter from 130 Members of Congress to the Treasury demanding that China revalue the Yuan or risk tariffs and a popular commentary from Paul Krugman entitled ‘Taking On China’. In Krugman’s article some fantastic speculations are made about what might happen if the U.S. enacts a 25% surcharge on Chinese goods:

“It’s true that if China dumped its U.S. assets the value of the dollar would fall against other major currencies, such as the euro. But that would be a good thing for the United States, since it would make our goods more competitive and reduce our trade deficit. On the other hand, it would be a bad thing for China, which would suffer large losses on its dollar holdings. In short, right now America has China over a barrel, not the other way around. In short, right now America has China over a barrel, not the other way around. (bolds added) So we have no reason to fear China. But what should we do?”

Apparently Krugman assumes – a la the not too hot and not too cold doctrine - that if China starts dumping U.S. assets the U.S. dollar would fall enough to seriously hurt China but not enough to hurt U.S. interests.  But what if instead of a controllable ‘fall’ the dollar crashes in response to China dumping U.S. assets? Krugman continues:

“What you have to ask is, What would happen if China tried to sell a large share of its U.S. assets? Would interest rates soar? Short-term U.S. interest rates wouldn’t change: they’re being kept near zero by the Fed, which won’t raise rates until the unemployment rate comes down. Long-term rates might rise slightly, but they’re mainly determined by market expectations of future short-term rates. Also, the Fed could offset any interest-rate impact of a Chinese pullback by expanding its own purchases of long-term bonds.”

As Krugman explores the outcome(s) to China dumping U.S. assets further it is impossible to not acquire a sense of unease. Think about it: Krugman tells us (incorrectly) that interest rates are efficiently set by ‘market expectations’ and in the next line he claims that the Fed can set long-term interest rates to whatever level it wants. Which is it Krugman?

Rather than continue to attack Krugman with my words, why not do so with his own?  Keep in mind when reading the quotes below that since 2003 the U.S. has grown more dependent on foreign capital, China has become the largest holder of U.S. debt, and the projected fiscal deficits for the U.S. have grown significantly larger.

“…the U.S. currently has very little leverage over China. Mr. Bush needs China's help to deal with North Korea -- another crisis that was allowed to fester while the administration focused on Iraq. Furthermore, purchases of Treasury bills by China's central bank are one of the main ways the U.S. finances its trade deficit.

Nobody is quite sure what would happen if the Chinese suddenly switched to, say, euros -- a two-point jump in mortgage rates? -- but it's not an experiment anyone wants to try.” The China Syndrome - September 5, 2003

Why did Krugman speculate about a 2-point jump in mortgage rates only 7-years ago while arguing that there would be no impact from a major Chinese reserve switch today?

“…we've developed an addiction to Chinese dollar purchases, and will suffer painful withdrawal symptoms when they come to an end.” The Chinese Connection - March 20, 2005

Anyone care to speculate why Krugman now advocates a pain-free withdrawal from the U.S.’s addiction to Chinese dollar purchases?

“…there's no sign that anyone in the administration has faced up to an unpleasant reality: the U.S. economy has become dependent on low-interest loans from China and other foreign governments, and it's likely to have major problems when those loans are no longer forthcoming.” The Chinese Connection - March 20, 2005

Again, why ‘major problems’ when China stops lending the U.S. money yesterday but no problems observed today?

Ignoring the contradictions, Krugman currently believes the following: the U.S. can attack China for manipulating its currency because the only blowback would be an advantageous (to the U.S.) devaluation of the U.S. dollar. Krugman also believes that even if China were to ‘dump’ its holdings long-term interest rates wouldn’t rise because the Fed wouldn’t allow this to happen.

Even if you agree with Krugman, it is obvious that this issue is not about currency prices and interest rates alone. An excellent summary of the U.S./China theme from Brookings recently explored this idea:

“But can China make a big difference to U.S. interest rates ...? The answer lies not in the absolute amounts of financing that China brings to the table, but in how its actions could serve as a trigger around which nervous market sentiments could coalesce.”

What are some of the actions and their impact on market sentiment Brookings may be talking about? Consider a hypothetical: In response to the U.S.’s 25% surcharge China dumps Treasury Securities, enacts retaliatory tariffs against the U.S., invests $100 billion in Iran, and occupies Taiwan.  As global stock prices crash and the Fed expands its Treasury purchase program by trillions, reports of a panicked move out of paper currencies and into precious metals abound. Thanks a lot new Krugman!

Embellishment aside, while focusing policy based upon the premise that the U.S. financial markets and U.S. dollar are too important to fail can, arguably, be beneficial to the U.S., this may only be the case if the policies adopted do not directly endanger the U.S.’s ability to borrow money at attractive rates of interest longer-term. In other words, before undertaking a risky protectionist experiment the U.S. would be well served to try and get its financial house in order (the Krugman of old would probably concur).  The U.S. would also be well served to remember that there is ample reason to fear China so long as the U.S. is in pursuit of novel schemes to intentionally ‘manipulate’ the dollar lower…

By Brady Willett was launched in January of 2000 with the mandate of providing an alternative opinion on the U.S. equity markets.  In the context of an uncritical herd euphoria that characterizes the mainstream media, Fallstreet strives to provide investors with the information they need to make informed investment decisions. To that end, we provide a clearinghouse for bearish and value-oriented investment information, independent research, and an investment newsletter containing specific company selections.

© 2005-2019 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules