Best of the Week
Most Popular
1.Stock Market in DANGER of Strangling the Bears to Death - Nadeem_Walayat
2. Germany Pivoting East, Exit US Dollar, Enter Gold Standard - Jim_Willie_CB
3.Flight MH17 – Kiev Flash Mob's Last False Flag? - Andrew_McKillop
4.Stock Market Crash Nightmare! - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Gold - The Million DOLLAR Question... - Rambus_Chartology
6.Gold And Silver – BRICS And Germany Will Pave The Way - Michael_Noonan
7.The Jewish Selfish Gene, People Chosen by God, Everyone Else is Goyim to Kill - Nadeem_Walayat
8.The Israeli Promised Land Dream - The Criminal Roadmap Towards “Greater Israel”? - Felicity Arbuthnot
9.Which Way is Inflation Blowing? Watch Commodities - Gary_Dorsch
10.U.S. Economy Quarterly Review and Implications for 2014-2015 - Lacy Hunt
Last 5 days
More Weakness Ahead for Gold Miners - 25th July 14
Gold Price Strong Season Starts - 25th July 14
Geopolitics and Markets Red Flags Raised by the Fed and the BIS on Risk-taking - 25th July 14
Gold Lockdown Until Options Expiry - New Singapore Gold Contract Threatens Price Manipulation - 25th July 14
The Bond Markets, Black Swans, and the Tiny Spirit of Santo - 25th July 14
No Road Map For Avoiding The Future - 25th July 14
Israeli War Machine Concentrating Women and Children into UN Schools Before Killing Them - C4News - 25th July 14
Israeli Government Paying Jewish Fundamentalist Students to Post Facebook Gaza War Propaganda - 25th July 14
Why the Stock Market Is Heading For A Fall - This Time Is Not Different - 25th July 14
An Economic “Nuclear Strike” on Moscow, A “War of Degrees” - 25th July 14
BBC, Western Media Working for Israeli Agenda of Perpetual War to Steal Arab Land - 25th July 14
Ukraine: What To Do When Economic Growth Is Gone - 24th July 14
Stock Market Clear and Present Danger Zone - 24th July 14
The Five Elements to Creating a Something-for-Nothing Society - 24th July 14
Instability is the New Normal? - 24th July 14
Israel's Suicide Bombers Over Gaza - 24th July 14
EUR-AUD Heads Into The Danger Zone - 24th July 14
Tesco Supermarket Death Spiral Accelerates as Customers HATE the Mega Brand - 24th July 14
Ukraine MH17 Crisis - Best Remember Who Your Friends Are - 24th July 14
Three Reasons Why Gold Price and Gold Stocks Will Rise - 24th July 14
HUI Gold Bugs Fighting To Break Downtrend - 23rd July 14
What Putin Knows About Flight MH17 - 23rd July 14
Why Microsoft Will Continue to Rebound, Huge Upside Potential - 23rd July 14
Will Putin Survive? - 23rd July 14
MH17 Crash Next Phase Economic Warfare - 22nd July 14
The TRUTH about China’s Massive Gold Hoard - 22nd July 14
Forex Multi-week Consolidation in EUR/USD Ended - 22nd July 14
Bitcoin Price Medium-term Trend Being Tested - 22nd July 14
Beware Of The Flash Mob - 22nd July 14
Can Putin Survive? - 22nd July 14
Israel Assault on Gaza: A Historic Crime, Nazi Like Final Solution - 22nd July 14
Zionist Israel an International Pariah - 22nd July 14
Reflections on the Global Misery Index - 22nd July 14
GDP Economic Statistic : A Brief But Affectionate History - 22nd July 14
TransTech Digest: Super Battery Bio-Power vs. Dirty CleanTech - 21st July 14
How to Find Trading Opportunities in the Currency Markets - 21st July 14
Stock Market One More Pull Back - 21st July 14
The Conquest Of Real - Degenerate Philosophies of the Book - 21st July 14
A Clear Way to Profit from a Graying Population - 21st July 14
Last Chance Critical Financial Market Forecasts Special Total Access - 21st July 14
Stock Market Crash Nightmare! - 21st July 14
Why the Stock Market Is STILL Cheap - 21st July 14
From Gore-Bore To Gore-War - 21st July 14
Gold Price Looking Drab - 21st July 14
An In-Depth Look at Gold Chartology - 21st July 14
The Jewish Selfish Gene, People Chosen by God, Everyone Else is Goyim to Kill - 20th July 14
AUD NZD Taking The Forex Bull By The Horns - 20th July 14
US-backed Israeli Invasion of Gaza Unleashes Death and Destruction - 20th July 14
The Israeli Promised Land Dream - The Criminal Roadmap Towards “Greater Israel”? - 20th July 14
Stock Market in DANGER of Strangling the Bears to Death - 20th July 14

Free Instant Analysis

Free Instant Technical Analysis


Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

Sandy Hook Solutions

Politics / US Politics Jan 20, 2013 - 02:38 PM GMT

By: Stephen_Merrill

Politics How do people ever begin to redeem the suffering of twenty tiny souls?  What can help diminish the horrible images Americans will long have of that terrible day the week before Christmas at Sandy Hook elementary school?

In our modern world the answer, as always, is curative legislation.  Legislation is the natural offspring of senseless tragedy wherever it might occur.



Make the manufacture, sale and possession of certain guns a crime.  It is not just the gun that needs banning though; it is the size of the bullet cartridge, too.  This is the largest solution type offered by Democrats, including President Obama.
The NRA chorus is quite the opposite. We need even more guns to deal with these criminals. The wilder gun advocates insist the government force the shopping malls, the schools and the street corners to become militarized by the “good guys”, a gun for every pot, crony capitalism for the merchants of death.  The belief is that only when everyone carries a serious weapon will gun violence be ended, surprisingly, as viewed by the people already armed to the teeth.

Quite frozen in place, the Republicans can offer only armed solutions, condolences with no reassurances it seems.  Everyone be prepared.  The President is allegedly coming to take your guns away.

So, the entire polarized gun debate looks at only unworkable solutions. 

The collective dictate so loved by Democrats, prohibition at some level, not only invades the privacy and security of gun owners.  It is an expensive method for the government to administer that always proves full of holes for the con-artists and criminals to exploit.  In a free nation more and more prohibition in more and more areas is not a go to solution.  The unintended consequences of such laws are typically dire for everyone.

On the Republican side of the debate offering the idea of arming unsuspecting school teachers with semi-automatic rifles so the Second Amendment can be saved has truly hit beyond the merely bizarre. 

Until a few years ago the Second Amendment’s meaning was unknown, a constitutional relic.  Yet, gun prohibition never came close to prospering generally in the US. 

The first US Supreme Court Justice to ever write at length about the Second Amendment, Justice Antonin Scalia five years ago, directly held the constitutional right to bear arms has considerable restraints, as most liberties in life do.

Advocating more and bigger guns to solve a gun problem is no more of a solution than offering more and more debt is to solving a debt problem.  It is the same way nations try to avoid war, through an arms race.  Such notions, even when viewed as self-defense, typically end in tears.

A meaningful solution toward reducing gun violence lies in the opposite direction from more government mandate.  It lies in personal responsibility and the freedom of choice that goes along with it.

There is a doctrine in the civil law of all fifty states known as product liability, a seller’s responsibility for damages caused by one’s product while it was being used for its intended purpose.  In the instance of a severe hazard such as chemical pollution the staunch standard applies, “strict liability” no matter the contributing factors to the later tragedy.  For instance, BP was 100% liable for the Gulf oil spill cleanup as a fact from day one. 

That severe doctrine seems a giant overstep for gun violence though.  No one could seriously suggest gun liability be open-ended, or pass along necessarily to the gun owner as a later seller, too.  There are way too many human and situational variables involved.  Different solutions would be used by the states for their different circumstances, fifty points of light, applying over time the remedies that seem to work in practice.

If gun manufacturers and retailers were made potentially liable for gun violence by their customer, there would be effective background checks like the government could never manage to achieve.  With the irresponsibility of it all vanished, the commerce in guns in the US would return to a more rational state for such a dangerous product.

This well-practiced, bottom-up, free market solution would also compensate victims for some of the deadly consequences of gun violence.  When GM or Toyota makes a car that wrongly kills someone, hollow words are not sufficient in the law, rightfully so.

With personal responsibility coming into place, many of the existing legal prohibitions on guns could easily be set aside, making gun ownership more accessible and private than it has been in our lifetimes: The BATF gone someday, the greatest victory of all for peaceful gun owners.

Do Obama and the Democrats have the political courage to seek a viable solution for gun violence?  Obviously not given Obama’s just announced wish list of legislation.  The US weapons industry need have little concern over Obama getting much in the way of their business model.  The Republicans, we already know, have been bought, lock, stock and barrel, by the gun lobby.

So, all we are seeing arise from the Sandy Hook slaughter, from both sides, is the usual pandering to the cameras.   The irresponsibility in US weapons commerce will continue despite the horrid tragedy, driven by the payoffs to members of both major parties in Washington, D.C.  The wall of special civil immunity for gun manufacturers and sellers purchased from Congress and the state legislatures is far too high to breach so far. 

Empty but tyrannical legislation like Obama’s is intended to compensate in the public’s perception for the lack of serious corrective action being taken by anyone.

When people just going about their lives, little children, are being slaughtered as a matter of routine it is a proper area for a legal solution, something quite necessary to remedy, something well within the bounds of legislative choice.  Protection from random violence is one of the three essential missions of government, first, to protect life, and then, to protect liberty and property.

The better legislative choice by far is movement toward the responsibility that goes with liberty. 

Stephen Merrill is a trial lawyer practicing in Anchorage, Alaska.  He was a founder of the Tidewater Virginia Libertarian Party in 2001, the most successful Libertarian Party affiliate in the nation.  He is now a founder of the Anchorage Tea Party, Occupy Anchorage and General Counsel and Secretary for the Alaska Libertarian Party.  He remains a longtime defender of the Bill of Rights. 

Mr. Merrill served in the Navy Judge Advocate General’s Corps and as a Navy Reserve Intelligence Officer.

Mr. Merrill is the editor of the Alaska Freedom News, formerly the Hampton Roads Freedom News

© 2013 Copyright  Stephen Merrill - All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.


© 2005-2014 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

Free Report - Financial Markets 2014