Why read: To test the contemporaneous views I expressed four years ago, to observe similarities and differences then and now, and to determine if you agree with my current views.

Commentary then: On April 12, 2009 I commented as follows:

An article today titled 'Preparing for the Dollar's Next Down Cycle' begins with the author saying "One thing I learned early on in my investing and trading career was that I can't trust analysts or the news media! I learned that not only are these guys not as knowledgeable as they should be, but that they also don't alert everyone to the fact that things are changing until well after the fact".

The author attributes this to "analysts and the financial news media (being) horrible investors", and because "analysts work for firms that are biased".

The author then says that he relies on commodities "like gold, copper, oil, steel, lumber, and even a commodities index...the CRB index (which holds a basket of commonly used goods)" as an indicator for buying stocks and currencies.

His rationale for focusing on commodities as an economic and market indicator is that he believes "when an economy is turning around, companies will need to use these raw commodities to make their products in order to expand their corporate earnings", and that "when an economy comes out of a deflationary (or even disinflationary) period back into a typical inflationary period, you will see it first in the rise of commodity prices".

He then says he thinks (in April 2009) the "The Worst is Over, yet (there are) Still Some Bumps Left" since oil, copper, gold, lumber, etc. have all started to perk up and have broken their downtrends.

While I think the author has it 'generally right' with respect to analysts and the news media, I that he goes 'far to far' by making such broad statements. I think there are many thoughtful media writers and quite a number of good and careful analysts. That analysts may have inherent conflict of interest issues depending on who employ them is something that needs to be weighed when considering their advice. I also think the author's analysis is very shallow with respect to what he sees as a 'fact' that many commodities have now (in April 2009) 'broken their downtrends'. Thus, while I think the author of the referenced article may be directionally and conceptually correct with respect to commodities and commodity prices as indicators of economic and stock market prospects, I think he is a little, and perhaps more than a little, early in his conclusion that 'The Worst is Over'.

A principal reason I have spent a substantive part of my time in the past two years developing the StockResearchPortal.com is because I believe intelligent investors will be more careful and doing more of their own investment research going forward, because I believe in the long term future of precious metals as a safe haven, and because I believe investments in carefully researched commodity stocks will do well going forward.

Commentary now: In the past three plus years I have become more focused on what I perceive to be a significant shift in the financial markets over the past decade from being far more trading markets, and far less investment markets, than they historically have been. Given the evolution of high frequency algorithmic trading, and its instantaneous reaction to news and events, if anything it strikes me that commodities prices in theory ought to be even better short-term indicators of economic and stock market prospects today than they were in April 2009.

That said, I struggle to apply that same conclusion to longer-term economic and stock market prospects today, as I continue today to believe there is a significant dichotomy between current financial markets performance and longer-term world economic conditions.

Ian R. Campbell, FCA, FCBV, is a recognized Canadian business valuation authority who shares his perspective about the economy, mining and the oil & gas industry on each trading day. Ian is also the founder of Stock Research Portal, which provides stock market data, analysis and research on over 1,600 Mining and Oil & Gas Companies listed on the Toronto and Venture Exchanges. Ian can be contacted at icampbell@srddi.com

Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

The Market Oracle is a FREE Financial Markets Forecasting & Analysis web-site.
(c) 2005-2024 MarketOracle.co.uk (Market Oracle Ltd) - Market Oracle Ltd asserts copyright on all articles authored by our editorial team and all comments posted. Any and all information provided within the web-site, is for general information purposes only and Market Oracle Ltd do not warrant the accuracy, timeliness or suitability of any information provided on this site. nor is or shall be deemed to constitute, financial or any other advice or recommendation by us. and are also not meant to be investment advice or solicitation or recommendation to establish market positions. We do not give investment advice and our comments are an expression of opinion only and should not be construed in any manner whatsoever as recommendations to enter into a market position either stock, option, futures contract, bonds, commodity or any other financial instrument at any time. We recommend that independent professional advice is obtained before you make any investment or trading decisions. By using this site you agree to this sites Terms of Use. From time to time we promote or endorse certain products / services that we believe are worthy of your time and attention. In return for that endorsement and only in the cases where you purchase directly though us may we be compensated by the producers of those products.