Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Market Decline Will Lead To Pension Collapse, USD Devaluation, And NWO - Raymond_Matison
2.Uber’s Nightmare Has Just Started - Stephen_McBride
3.Stock Market Crash Black Swan Event Set Up Sept 12th? - Brad_Gudgeon
4.GDow Stock Market Trend Forecast Update - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Gold Significant Correction Has Started - Clive_Maund
6.British Pound GBP vs Brexit Chaos Timeline - Nadeem_Walayat
7.Cameco Crash, Uranium Sector Won’t Catch a break - Richard_Mills
8.Recession 2020 Forecast : The New Risks & New Profits Of A Grand Experiment - Dan_Amerman
9.Gold When Global Insanity Prevails - Michael Ballanger
10.UK General Election Forecast 2019 - Betting Market Odds - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
Gold and Silver Capitulation Time - 14th Nov 19
The Case for a Silver Price Rally - 14th Nov 19
What Happens To The Global Economy If the Oil Price Collapses Below $40 - 14th Nov 19
7 days of Free FX + Crypto Forecasts -- Join in - 14th Nov 19
How to Use Price Cycles and Profit as a Swing Trader – SPX, Bonds, Gold, Nat Gas - 13th Nov 19
Morrisons Throwing Thousands of Bonus More Points at Big Spend Shoppers - JACKPOT! - 13th Nov 19
What to Do NOW in Case of a Future Banking System Breakdown - 13th Nov 19
Why China is likely to remain the ‘world’s factory’ for some time to come - 13th Nov 19
Gold Price Breaks Down, Waving Good-bye to the 2019 Rally - 12th Nov 19
Fed Can't See the Bubbles Through the Lather - 12th Nov 19
Double 11 Record Sales Signal Strength of Chinese Consumption - 12th Nov 19
Welcome to the Zombie-land Of Oil, Gold and Stocks Investing – Part II - 12th Nov 19
Gold Retest Coming - 12th Nov 19
New Evidence Futures Markets Are Built for Manipulation - 12th Nov 19
Next 5 Year Future Proof Gaming PC Build Spec November 2019 - Ryzen 9 3900x, RTX 2080Ti... - 12th Nov 19
Gold and Silver - The Two Horsemen - 11th Nov 19
Towards a Diverging BRIC Future - 11th Nov 19
Welcome to the Zombie-land Of Stock Market Investing - 11th Nov 19
Illiquidity & Gold And Silver In The End Game - 11th Nov 19
Key Things You Need to Know When Starting a Business - 11th Nov 19
Stock Market Cycles Peaking - 11th Nov 19
Avoid Emotional Investing in Cryptocurrency - 11th Nov 19
Australian Lithium Mines NOT Viable at Current Prices - 10th Nov 19
The 10 Highest Paying Jobs In Oil & Gas - 10th Nov 19
World's Major Gold Miners Target Copper Porphyries - 10th Nov 19
AMAZON NOVEMBER 2019 BARGAIN PRICES - WD My Book 8TB External Drive for £126 - 10th Nov 19
Gold & Silver to Head Dramatically Higher, Mirroring Palladium - 9th Nov 19
How Do YOU Know the Direction of a Market's Larger Trend? - 9th Nov 19
BEST Amazon SMART Scale To Aid Weight Loss for Christmas 2019 - 9th Nov 19
Why Every Investor Should Invest in Water - 8th Nov 19
Wait… Was That a Bullish Silver Reversal? - 8th Nov 19
Gold, Silver and Copper The 3 Metallic Amigos and the Macro Message - 8th Nov 19
Is China locking up Indonesian Nickel? - 8th Nov 19
Where is the Top for Natural Gas? - 7th Nov 19
Why Fractional Shares Don’t Make Sense - 7th Nov 19
The Fed Is Chasing Its Own Tail; It Doesn’t Care What You Think - 7th Nov 19
China’s path from World’s Factory to World Market - 7th Nov 19
Where Is That Confounded Recession? - 7th Nov 19
FREE eBook - The Investment Strategy that could change your future - 7th Nov 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How To Buy Gold For $3 An Ounce

Silver Position Limits, Commodity Perceptions and Monetary Ignorance

Commodities / Gold and Silver 2014 Feb 28, 2014 - 04:08 PM GMT

By: Dr_Jeff_Lewis


The dividing line between silver performing as a monetary asset versus an industrial commodity is tethered to a broken price discovery system, where unlimited position limits are held by the most influential of traders.

This fault line, at the heart of price manipulation, paints a dangerous and false perception that permeates the trading landscape - as well as the mainstream perception of money.

Price Discovery and Position Limits

Dollar and other fiat currency price discovery for world silver prices occur on many exchanges. But it remains centered on the largest: The COMEX, a division of the New York Mercantile Exchange and owned by the for-profit CME Group.

No serious discussion about prices can ignore what transpires in the COMEX pits - but even more so how it transpires.

We can look to one thousand points of macro interest for some insight on how prices performed; yet no matter how much we strain to see the connections, they are all too dim without first starting with the entities that represent the dominate positions in those markets.

Ted Butler of Butler Research is one of the most well known, distinguished, and influential silver analysts. Butler is a former commodities futures trader and has been a prolific silver market reporter for decades. He has documented the precarious and unique situation that exists for silver and the other precious metals.

Simply stated, in the four precious metals the dominant and concentrated net short (excluding swaps for contracts out along the curve for the purpose of arbitrage) have been held by the four largest traders in the commercial category of traders. This has been documented by the CFTC for years. And while many prefer to lump all government data into the same pile (where we might include the CPI or labor reports), the data has held very consistent with only a few changes over the years.

The main issue (and not much else matters more) is that these four traders comprise a dominant position that should never be allowed in any market, simply because its very existence interferes with potential price discovery. Of course, in silver and gold the interference is literal.

When one entity holds the majority of any stock traded, the temptation to game the system by moving prices would be (and is) impossible to contain. It does not matter if those positions are hedged. The fact that they exist is enough evidence of foul play and puts the blame at the feet of the exchange itself.

The influence of high frequency trading merely adds fuel to the fire. HFT has exploded the issue by making it even less likely that the Exchange would ever self regulate, as it profits directly from the sheer number of trades. HFT enables spoof trades that never clear - nor are they intended to clear. It also enables the continued dominance and, ultimately, the ability for these massive entities to make the market literally by painting the tape and guiding the technical patterns - drawing in further speculation.

Position Limits at the Heart of the Matter

As Ted Butler has pointed out on numerous occasions (but especially along recent rule change considerations):

"At current levels of total open interest (including spread positions, the formula would call for an all months combined position limit in COMEX silver of less than 5,000 contracts, or the equivalent of 25 million oz. in COMEX gold, the formula would dictate less than 12,000 contracts as the most a speculator could hold long or short.

The problem is that JPMorgan is holding, at last count, (nearly) 18,000 contracts short in COMEX silver, well in excess of the current 5,000 contract proposed limit and 72,000 contracts long in COMEX gold, six times more than the proposed 12,000 contract limit in gold."

If JPM Morgan were forced to comply, the result would be a sudden knee jerk return upward in the direction of price based on fundamentals.

Silver: The Monetary Asset

The aftermath of this illegal, uneconomic, and distortion of price discovery mechanism is overshadowed by another misconception held by many professional traders. These traders prefer to justify price movements in conjunction with the general commodity sector. Unfortunately, they wield undue influence and feed off of a mentality that is driven by yield and underscored by a broken system of money and credit.

Gold and silver are, first and foremost, monetary metals. This is difficult for any modern investor who has come of age over the last 40 years, but it is a taboo that is directly opposed by thousands of years of economic and financial history.

Precious metals influence has been muted by price manipulation. Nevertheless, they lead, rather than follow, the collective commodity movement. Opponents (usually traders) of manipulation are quick to point out, and often ridicule, the suggestion. This is because they refuse to acknowledge the monetary role and, therefore, inflationary signaling (again muted) from the metals.

They watch the alt indicators. Professionals see the trading structure. They know the probability of price moves based on the illegal positioning.

Manip is not just down, but all around. The misconception is that our complaint is one way. It is not. Any force that distorts price or down is, ultimately, destructive.
Futures zero sum. Once rally short cover ends, new longs threaten the big silver short and eventually press on supply "awareness".

Control the most visible and emotional indicator and you control them all.

Breaking the Taboo

It all boils down to the general view of silver by the majority of mainstream investors.

Again, it may be taboo to mention the monetary character of silver in the polite company of a sophisticated investor even when, ultimately, it comes down to simple risk assessment.

And sadly, clear acknowledgement of risk is unfashionable, to say the least, in the current investing environment. The 'sophisticated' investor will go down explaining the motion of electrons as the water all around him boils.

But the average man intuitively understands, perhaps by omission or healthy ignorance. To be small also means to be nimble; and there is certainly no shortage of small investors who understand the intrinsic value of the food and energy they consume - or that the budget has limits.

And invariably, eyes light up when only a brief sprinkling of industrial uses are shared.

In an age of prosperity, for many the understanding of things like the function of electricity is closer to magic; this means the masses are much more primed to accept the faith necessary to accept silver as a monetary asset once again.

It is guaranteed that the big players will see this wave of liquidity approaching as well. And glamour will follow in the aftermath as the taboo becomes lifted. Once the taboo is gone, there will no longer be a barrier. Whether that manifests as a COMEX default, physical market, premium surge, or some combination remains to be seen.

Watching the day to day price should be the same overall - prepare for the worst and the best will take care of itself.

For more articles like this, and/or for a breath of fresh silver market reality amidst the stench of denial and technically meaningless short term price obsessed madness, check out

By Dr. Jeff Lewis

    Dr. Jeffrey Lewis, in addition to running a busy medical practice, is the editor of

    Copyright © 2014 Dr. Jeff Lewis- All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

Dr. Jeff Lewis Archive

© 2005-2019 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules