Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Market Decline Will Lead To Pension Collapse, USD Devaluation, And NWO - Raymond_Matison
2.Uber’s Nightmare Has Just Started - Stephen_McBride
3.Stock Market Crash Black Swan Event Set Up Sept 12th? - Brad_Gudgeon
4.GDow Stock Market Trend Forecast Update - Nadeem_Walayat
5.Gold Significant Correction Has Started - Clive_Maund
6.British Pound GBP vs Brexit Chaos Timeline - Nadeem_Walayat
7.Cameco Crash, Uranium Sector Won’t Catch a break - Richard_Mills
8.Recession 2020 Forecast : The New Risks & New Profits Of A Grand Experiment - Dan_Amerman
9.Gold When Global Insanity Prevails - Michael Ballanger
10.UK General Election Forecast 2019 - Betting Market Odds - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
Trade News Still Relevant? - 19th Nov 19
Comments on Catena Media Q3 Report 2019 - 19th Nov 19
Venezuela’s Hyperinflation Drags On For A Near Record—36 Months - 18th Nov 19
Intellectual Property as the New Guild System - 18th Nov 19
Gold Mining Stocks Q3’ 2019 Fundamentals - 18th Nov 19
The Best Way To Play The Coming Gold Boom - 18th Nov 19
What ECB’s Tiering Means for Gold - 17th Nov 19
DOJ Asked to Examine New Systemic Risk in Gold & Silver Markets - 17th Nov 19
Dow Jones Stock Market Cycle Update and are we there yet? - 17th Nov 19
When the Crude Oil Price Collapses Below $40 What Happens? PART III - 17th Nov 19
If History Repeats, Gold is Headed to $8,000 - 17th Nov 19
All You Need To Know About Cryptocurrency - 17th Nov 19
What happens To The Global Economy If Oil Collapses Below $40 – Part II - 15th Nov 19
America’s Exceptionalism’s Non-intervention Slide to Conquest, Empire - and Socialism - 15th Nov 19
Five Gold Charts to Contemplate as We Prepare for the New Year - 15th Nov 19
Best Gaming CPU Nov 2019 - Budget, Mid and High End PC System Processors - 15th Nov 19
Lend Money Without A Credit Check — Is That Possible? - 15th Nov 19
Gold and Silver Capitulation Time - 14th Nov 19
The Case for a Silver Price Rally - 14th Nov 19
What Happens To The Global Economy If the Oil Price Collapses Below $40 - 14th Nov 19
7 days of Free FX + Crypto Forecasts -- Join in - 14th Nov 19
How to Use Price Cycles and Profit as a Swing Trader – SPX, Bonds, Gold, Nat Gas - 13th Nov 19
Morrisons Throwing Thousands of Bonus More Points at Big Spend Shoppers - JACKPOT! - 13th Nov 19
What to Do NOW in Case of a Future Banking System Breakdown - 13th Nov 19
Why China is likely to remain the ‘world’s factory’ for some time to come - 13th Nov 19
Gold Price Breaks Down, Waving Good-bye to the 2019 Rally - 12th Nov 19
Fed Can't See the Bubbles Through the Lather - 12th Nov 19
Double 11 Record Sales Signal Strength of Chinese Consumption - 12th Nov 19
Welcome to the Zombie-land Of Oil, Gold and Stocks Investing – Part II - 12th Nov 19
Gold Retest Coming - 12th Nov 19
New Evidence Futures Markets Are Built for Manipulation - 12th Nov 19
Next 5 Year Future Proof Gaming PC Build Spec November 2019 - Ryzen 9 3900x, RTX 2080Ti... - 12th Nov 19
Gold and Silver - The Two Horsemen - 11th Nov 19
Towards a Diverging BRIC Future - 11th Nov 19
Welcome to the Zombie-land Of Stock Market Investing - 11th Nov 19
Illiquidity & Gold And Silver In The End Game - 11th Nov 19
Key Things You Need to Know When Starting a Business - 11th Nov 19
Stock Market Cycles Peaking - 11th Nov 19
Avoid Emotional Investing in Cryptocurrency - 11th Nov 19
Australian Lithium Mines NOT Viable at Current Prices - 10th Nov 19
The 10 Highest Paying Jobs In Oil & Gas - 10th Nov 19
World's Major Gold Miners Target Copper Porphyries - 10th Nov 19
AMAZON NOVEMBER 2019 BARGAIN PRICES - WD My Book 8TB External Drive for £126 - 10th Nov 19
Gold & Silver to Head Dramatically Higher, Mirroring Palladium - 9th Nov 19
How Do YOU Know the Direction of a Market's Larger Trend? - 9th Nov 19
BEST Amazon SMART Scale To Aid Weight Loss for Christmas 2019 - 9th Nov 19
Why Every Investor Should Invest in Water - 8th Nov 19
Wait… Was That a Bullish Silver Reversal? - 8th Nov 19
Gold, Silver and Copper The 3 Metallic Amigos and the Macro Message - 8th Nov 19
Is China locking up Indonesian Nickel? - 8th Nov 19

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

$4 Billion Golden Oppoerunity

Government Debt Is Not Like Private Debt

Interest-Rates / UK Debt Dec 09, 2015 - 04:26 PM GMT



Simon Wilson writesL As the Labour Party fights with Tories over the need to slightly rein in government spending in the UK, opponents of even the slightest bit of austerity have turned out to claim that there is no virtue in “living within your means.”

In a recent article in The Guardian, Ha-Joon Chang, attacked even the Tory government’s timid claim that it wasn’t a great idea to spend more than the government collects in tax revenues. But for the new radical left Labour Party on whose behalf Chang’s article was written, this notion is as quaint as it is “simply wrong.”

For Chang, whether it derives from political expedience or a deeper philosophical current, a claim that one should live “within your means” is wrong because it assumes that our means are and always will be a fixed quantity. In fact, we can determine what our future means will be with actions we take in the present. Chang writes,

If you borrow money to do a degree or get a technical qualification, you will be spending beyond your means today. But your new qualification will increase your future earning power. Your future means will be greater than they would have been if you hadn’t taken out the loan. In this case, living beyond your means is the right thing to do.

Well, that’s that then. In one fell swoop, Chang thinks he demolishes the “homespun philosophies” of fiscal conservatism and “austerity” politics. Of course borrowing is good, Chang tells us. What economic illiteracy it is to suggest otherwise!

The problem for Chang here, however, is that he is really attacking a straw man.

Borrowing Is Not Inherently Good or Bad

All he has stated is the obvious truth that investing in the present is likely to yield greater returns in the future — and this is good.

However, the source of an investment could just as well come from saving as from borrowing. The student in Chang’s example could, instead of taking out a loan, restrict his consumption (undergoing his own “mini recession”) in the years prior to study and pay his college fees outright so he can enjoy increased future returns all without the burden of interest. Wouldn’t this prove the inherent virtue of saving over borrowing?

In reality, neither borrowing nor saving is inherently good or bad. At least in the private sector. Whether one chooses to save or borrow to finance a project depends upon a subjective assessment of the relative trade-offs.

Is It Voluntary?

It’s another matter entirely, though, when we’re talking about the government sector. Chang attempts to dismiss arguments for living within one’s means by comparing private-sector borrowing to government borrowing. But, the two are not comparable.

For example, when Lenin requisitioned grain from the peasants in the Russian countryside to feed workers in the cities, he too was “living beyond his means” in the present to create an industrial base that would provide for greater means in the future. We could say that Lenin was borrowing or maybe “bailing in” the peasants or we could say that the requisitions were a tax forming the “savings” necessary to realize the future socialist paradise.

The problem here is not that wealth was transferred from farmers to city dwellers. Farmers could have, of course, voluntarily lent their wealth to city dwellers had they wanted to. The problem is that their wealth was transferred against their will and without their consent. Lenin was living beyond his means, and others paid the price.

It is unlikely that Chang sees himself as advocating violent transfers of property, however. When he encourages governments to live beyond their means, he may just think he means creating something from nothing, and “borrowing” from the central bank by creating money that will be spent into the economy. According to Chang, this is a recipe for success:

If enough businesses and consumers form positive expectations as a result, they will invest and spend more. Increased investment and consumption then generate higher incomes and higher tax revenues. If the tax take increases sufficiently, the government deficit may be eliminated, which means that the government had the money that it spent after all.

Sadly the difference between Leninist primitive accumulation and modern Keynesianism easy-money policies are only one of degree. Credit expansion deflates the value of the currency, imposing a hidden tax on all to who hold it. It also confers an unparalleled privilege upon all those nearest to where the credit enters the economy (the state, the banking system, and connected business elites). Of course one can always justify this, like Lenin, to the individuals affected by telling them they will be compensated in the form of a boost to economic growth resulting in improved standards of living in the future.

With Government, “Living Beyond Your Means” Is a Moral Problem

The problem is when you throw out morality, you also throw out economy. When the Soviets abolished private property, they removed the ability of individuals to exchange property at a price of their choosing, measure profits, or make economic calculations as to where productive resources should be allocated. With price signals gone, the soviets had to rely on guess work leading to large vanity projects being built which didn’t serve anyone.

The same is true of Keynesian-style money printing and borrowing. Government spending takes resources serving individual’s ends and diverts them to government-chosen ends, thus creating an artificial demand in those sectors of the economy where the money is spent. Without a market in public goods to indicate which are most valuable to consumers, governments essentially are driving blind, trying to pick winners and hoping for the best. You might not get empty missile silos, but you will get chronic debt and a squandering of resources that could otherwise have been more efficiently used by individuals.

Contra Chang, to not “live beyond your means" where government is concerned, is no mere mantra. It is a moral injunction to refrain from violence.

By Simon Wilson

Simon Wilson is a qualified wealth manager with a degree in economics and philosophy from the University of York in the United Kingdom. He currently resides in Peru where he teaches business in a British school.

© 2015 Copyright Simon Wilson - All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

© 2005-2019 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules