Most Popular
1. THE INFLATION MONSTER is Forecasting RECESSION - Nadeem_Walayat
2.Why APPLE Could CRASH the Stock Market! - Nadeem_Walayat
3.The Stocks Stealth BEAR Market - Nadeem_Walayat
4.Inflation, Commodities and Interest Rates : Paradigm Shifts in Macrotrends - Rambus_Chartology
5.Stock Market in the Eye of the Storm, Visualising AI Tech Stocks Buying Levels - Nadeem_Walayat
6.AI Tech Stocks Earnings BloodBath Buying Opportunity - Nadeem_Walayat
7.PPT HALTS STOCK MARKET CRASH ahead of Fed May Interest Rate Hike Meeting - Nadeem_Walayat
8.50 Small Cap Growth Stocks Analysis to CAPITALISE on the Stock Market Inflation -Nadeem_Walayat
10.Apple and Microsoft Nuts Are About to CRACK and Send Stock Market Sharply Lower - Nadeem_Walayat
Last 7 days
Qualcom Stock Market Harbinger - 12th Aug 22
Apple Exec Gets World's 1st iPhone 14 for Daughters 14th Birthday Surprise Present Unboxing! - 12th Aug 22
Steps to remember while playing live roulette online - 12th Aug 22
China Bank Run Protests - Another Potential Tiananmen Square Massacre? - 11th Aug 22
Silver Coin Premiums – Another Collapse? - 11th Aug 22
Gold-to-Silver Ratio Heading Lower – Setup Like 1989-03 - 11th Aug 22
Severe Stocks Bear Market: Will You Be Among the Prepared 1.5%? - 11th Aug 22
There's a Hole in My Bucket Dear Liza, UK Summer Heatwave Plants Watering Problem Song - 11th Aug 22
Why PEAK INFLATION is a RED HERRING! Prepare for a Decade Long Cost of Living Crisis - 9th Aug 22
FREETRADE Want to LEND My Shares to Short Sellers! - 8th Aug 22
Stock Market Unclosed Gap - 8th Aug 22
The End Game for Silver Shenanigans... - 8th Aug 22er
WARNING Corsair MP600 NVME2 M2 SSD Are Prone to Failure Can Prevent Systems From Booting - 8th Aug 22
Elliott Waves: Your "Rhyme & Reason" to Mainstream Stock Market Opinions - 6th Aug 22
COST OF LIVING CRISIS NIGHTMARE - Expect High INFLATION for whole of this DECADE! - 6th Aug 22
Recession Is Good for Gold, but a Crisis Would Be Even Better - 5th Aug 22
Stock Market Rallying On Slowly Thinning Air - 5th Aug 22
Stock Market Trend Pattren 2022 Forecast Current State - 4th Aug 22
Should We Be Prepared For An Aggressive U.S. Fed In The Future? - 4th Aug 22
Will the S&P 500 Stock Market Index Go the Way of Meme Stocks? - 4th Aug 22
Stock Market Another Upswing Attempt - 4th Aug 22
What is our Real Economic and Financial Prognosis? - 4th Aug 22
The REAL Stocks Bear Market of 2022 - 3rd Aug 22
The ‘Wishful Thinking’ Fed Is Anything But ‘Neutral’ - 3rd Aug 22
Don’t Be Misled by Gold’s Recent Upswing - 3rd Aug 22
Aluminum, Copper, Zinc: The 3 Horsemen of the Upcoming "Econocalypse" - 31st July 22
Gold Stocks’ Rally Autumn 2022 - 31st July 22
US Fed Is Battling Excess Global Capital – Which Is Creating Inflation - 31st July 22

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Protect your Wealth by Investing in AI Tech Stocks

US Economy’s Bubble: Casting the Recession Runes

Economics / US Economy Oct 08, 2007 - 07:25 PM GMT

By: Gerard_Jackson

Economics Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleThat the US economy is running into problems is becoming clearer by the day. It is equally clear that America’s economic commentariat is still wedded to the fallacy that consumption drives economies. Time after time I keep reading that consumer spending is more than 70 per cent of GDP which means that if consumer spending falls the economy will slide into recession. What matters, however, is total spending, of which business spending is the most important component. The problem here is that the commentariat has unthinkingly swallowed the fallacy that including spending between stages of production would be a case of double-counting.

If this were so then eliminating spending on intermediate goods would have no effect on production. Yet we know that if this were to occur the economy would collapse. Fortunately some government economists seem to have seen the light. The Bureau of Economic Analysis calculated that though GDP for 2000 was about $13 trillion actual spending came in at nearly $23 trillion. Although I think this is an underestimate it nevertheless reveals a fundamental and vitally important fact. And that is that business spending is what really drives the economy. We can therefore deduce that business spending is where we should first look for danger signs of an impending recession.

The following chart is a graphic example of our premise. Although it is for Australian spending it still applies equally to the US economy. The orange line represents consumer spending and the blue line is business spending. Now how any economist or finance writer could look at this chart and still categorically state that consumer spending is the most important component of total spending leaves me completely bewildered.

business spending and consumer spending

The chart clearly shows that business spending is the largest and most variable component of aggregate spending. The years 1998 to 2001 are particularly striking. As we can see, business spending plummeted, slowing the economy considerable, and yet consumer spending remained comparatively stable. In 2001 business spending rapidly expanded. The reason? It was then that the Reserve Bank of Australia let loose with the money supply, expanding M1 by 22 per cent and bank deposits by 25 per cent.

So how does this look today? The same as it did under Clinton. Back in 1999 I warned that the US economy was moving into recession. I emphasised the fact that manufacturing was contracting and shedding labour, a sure sign that recession had started. I also stressed that commentators would be deceived by the unemployment rate because it would continue to fall. This led to Steve Slifer, chief economist at Lehman Brothers, to say of the US economy in January 2001:

It’s really an odd-looking slowdown. The manufacturing sector is, in fact, in a recession but not the overall economy. At least not yet.

This is what happens when you have been infected with Keynesianitis: it forces its victims to focus on aggregates instead of relative prices. This is why the likes of Slifer were unable to see that the boom was nearing its final phase. Consumer spending was quickly rising at the same time as business spending was falling, creating an additional demand for labour at the lower stages of production. I pointed out in a number of articles that this consumer-led demand for labour would serve to conceal for a time what was really happening to the economy. Eventually a point would be reached where aggregate unemployment would begin to rise, even if consumer spending remained stable. And this is precisely what happened.

The same pattern appears to have re-emerged. The industries closest to the point of consumption hired 143,000 workers in September. But in the same month manufacturing shed 33,000 jobs. In January factory orders fell by fell 4.2 per cent and by 3.3 per cent in September. The Institute of Supply Management’s manufacturing index fell to 52.0 in September. It was 53.8 in July, dropping down 52.9 in August, a month that experienced a fall of 4.4 per cent in orders for capital goods. Yet employers hired an additional 110,000 workers in September. The pattern still holds. We also find that wages rose by about 4 per cent during the last 12 months. But this is usual for a boom that is drawing to a close.

New housing as well as manufacturing is also a good economic indicator, not just because housing is a durable good — so are my DVDs — but because it is an expensive good whose services are continuously consumed for decades. It therefore has the characteristics of a durable capital good.

So is the US economy on the skids? This is where the Fed comes in and the story becomes murky. Last September it cut the federal funds rate by 0.5 percent, bringing it down to 4.75 percent. Rates on 30-year mortgages quickly dropped to 6.37 per cent from 6.42 per cent. There are now reports that the housing markets in New York and San Diego are moving up again. If this is true then it’s possible that the Fed’s cut has given the housing market another gin and tonic. (This is like putting an alcoholic on a diet of whisky). If the cut is moving housing markets then it should also bolster shares. Well, this also appears to be the case, with the market turning bullish and commodity prices being driven up again.

At this stage it’s impossible to predict where interest rates will be within the next 6 months — even Bernanke doesn’t know that. What I do know is that back in 1927 Benjamin Strong gave the US economy a massive monetary injection that triggered a stock market frenzy. The rest, as they say, is history.

I’m not predicting another Great Depression, far from it. There existed at that time a concatenation of forces that do not exist today, or at least anywhere near the same scale. The real problem is not interest rates, exchange rates, unemployment, etc., it is bad economics. So long central banks and economists refuse to jettison Keynesian fallacies and the fallacy of the ‘stable price level’, and adopt sound money policies we will continue to suffer these economic crises.

By Gerard Jackson

Gerard Jackson is Brookes' economics editor.

Gerard Jackson Archive

© 2005-2019 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in