Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Next Financial Crisis Is Already Here! John Lewis 99% Profits CRASH - Retail Sector Collapse - Nadeem_Walayat
2.Why Is Apple Giving This Tiny Stock A $900 Million Opportunity? - James Burgess
3.Gold Price Trend Analysis - - Nadeem_Walayatt
4.The Beginning of the End of the Dollar - Richard_Mills
5.Stock Market Trend Forecast Update - - Nadeem_Walayat
6.Hindenburg Omen & Consumer Confidence: More Signs of Stock Market Trouble in 2019 - Troy_Bombardia
7.Precious Metals Sector: It’s 2013 All Over Again - P_Radomski_CFA
8.Central Banks Have Gone Rogue, Putting Us All at Risk - Ellen_Brown
9.Gold Stocks Forced Capitulation - Zeal_LLC
10.The Post Bubble Market Contraction Thesis Receives Validation - Plunger
Last 7 days
May BrExit Deal Tory MP Votes Forecast, Betting Market Analysis - 10th Dec 18
Listen to What Gold is Telling You - 10th Dec 18
The Stock Market’s Long Term Outlook is Changing - 10th Dec 18
Palladium Shortages Expose Broken Futures Markets for Precious Metals - 9th Dec 18
Is an Inverted Yield Curve Bullish for Gold? - 9th Dec 18
Rising US Home Prices and Falling Sales - 8th Dec 18
Choosing Who the Autonomous Car Should Kill - 8th Dec 18
Stocks Selloff Boosting Gold - 8th Dec 18
Will Weak US Dollar Save Gold? - 7th Dec 18
This Is the End of Trump’s Economic Sugar High - 7th Dec 18
US Economy Will Deteriorate Over Next Half Year. What this Means for Stocks - 7th Dec 18
The Secret Weapon for Getting America 5G Ready - 7th Dec 18
These Oil Stocks Are a Ticking Time Bomb - 7th Dec 18
How Theresa May Put Britain on the Path Towards BrExit Civil War - 7th Dec 18
How easy is it to find a job in the UK iGaming industry? - 6th Dec 18
Curry's vs Jessops - Buying an Olympus TG-5 Tough Camera - 5th Dec 18
Yield Curve Harbinger of Stock Market Doom - 5th Dec 18
Stock Market Crashed While the Yield Curve Inverted - 5th Dec 18
Global Economic Outlook after Trump-Xi Trade War Timeout - 5th Dec 18
Stock Market Dow Plunge Following Fake US - China Trade War Truce - 5th Dec 18
Subverting BREXIT - British People vs Parliament Risks Revolution - 5th Dec 18
Profit from the Global Cannabis Boom by Investing in the Beverage Industry - 4th Dec 18
MP's Vote UK Government Behaving like a Dictatorship, in Contempt of Parliament - 4th Dec 18
Isn't It Amazing How The Fed Controls The Stock Market? - 4th Dec 18
Best Christmas LED String and Projector Lights for 2018 - Review - 4th Dec 18
The "Special 38" Markets You Should Trade ebook - 4th Dec 18
Subverting BrExit - AG Confirms May Backstop Deal Means UK Can NEVER LEAVE the EU! - 3rd Dec 18
The Bottled Water Bamboozle - 3rd Dec 18
Crude Oil After November’s Declines - 3rd Dec 18
Global Economic Perceptions Are Shifting - Asia China Markets Risks - 3rd Dec 18
Weekly Charts and Update on Equity Markets, FX Trades and Commodities - 3rd Dec 18
TICK TOCK, Counting Down to the Next Recession - 3rd Dec 18
Stock Market Key (Short-term) Support Holds - 3rd Dec 18
Stocks Bull Market Tops Are a Process - 3rd Dec 18
More Late-cycle Signs for the Stock Market and What’s Next - 3rd Dec 18
A Post-Powell View of USD, S&P 500 and Gold - 2nd Dec 18
Elliott Wave: SPX Decision Time Is Coming Soon - 2nd Dec 18
Junior Gold Stocks Q3’18 Fundamentals - 1st Dec 18
Little-Known BDC Stocks Thrive Amid Rising Rates and Earn Investors +7% Yields - 1st Dec 18
Ray Dalio: This Debt Cycle Will End Soon - 1st Dec 18
Bank of England Warns UK House Prices 30% BrExit Crash! - 1st Dec 18
Gold Fundamentals Improving but Not Bullish Yet - 30th Nov 18
What the Oil Short-sellers and OPEC Don’t Know about Peak Shale - 30th Nov 18
Global Economic Perceptions Are Shifting Imnplications for Stock Market - 30th Nov 18
The US Economy is Getting Worse. What this Means for Stocks - 30th Nov 18
Trailblazers Leading the Way in Online Reputation Management - 30th Nov 18
The Shift in Trend from Physical Printers to Online Printers - 30th Nov 18
UK House Prices 2019 No Deal BrExit 30% Crash Warning! - 30th Nov 18
Stocks Rallied, New Uptrend? - 29th Nov 18
The Fed Will Probably Stop Hiking Rates in 2019. What’s Next for Stocks - 29th Nov 18
Love. Fear. Inflation. A Precious Metals' Trifecta - 29th Nov 18
GBP/USD – Double Bottom or Further Declines? - 29th Nov 18
Stock Market Santa Rally Still a GO to Dow 27,000? - 29th Nov 18
UK Government and Bank of England BrExit Economic Armageddon Propaganda - 29th Nov 18
Why the Crude Oil Price Collapsed to $50 - 28th Nov 18
Gold Joins the Decline – the Earth is Shaking - 28th Nov 18
Watch This Picture As Asset Prices Fall - 28th Nov 18
GE’s Stock Price Crash Holds an Important Lesson About Investing - 28th Nov 18
5 Rules for Successful Trading - 28th Nov 18
Dollar Trend Imposes: EURUSD to Fall to 1.11 - 28th Nov 18
Gold, Original Money, Fiat Money - 28th Nov 18
When Will the Stocks Bull Market End? - 28th Nov 18
Looking ahead: Why the Smart Money is Investing in Green Energy - 28th Nov 18
The Yield Curve Will Invert Soon. What’s Next for the Stock Market - 27th Nov 18
Silver Trading and the Hands of a Broken Clock - 27th Nov 18
What's Inside SMIGGLE Christmas Advent Calender 2018 - 27th Nov 18
Investing in Recession Proof Trailer Parks - 27th Nov 18
The Advantages and Disadvantages of Debt Consolidation - 27th Nov 18
GDX, This Most-Hated Stock Could Return You 140% in Just a Few Months - 27th Nov 18

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How You Could Make £2,850 Per Month

NYMEX No Future For Crude Oil Futures

Commodities / Crude Oil Feb 04, 2014 - 02:05 PM GMT

By: Andrew_McKillop

Commodities

Potatoes to Oil

According to Leah McGrath Goodman's well-researched book “The Asylum: The Renegades Who Hijacked the World's Oil Market", the start of Nymex oil trading was in major part due to traders who stumbled upon oil futures after screwing up Maine potato futures. Their trading “industry” or gambling party had been built on predicting the Maine potato harvest, and—much more importantly—trying to manipulate potato prices, to the point that regulators were finally forced to act. They shut down the potato futures market in 1976, after repeated defaults on physical deliveries of more than 25 000 tons of potatoes. As Goodman explains, the traders were forced to cast around for something else to trade. Then-Chairman of the Nymex, Michael Marks tried to boost futures trading in boneless beef and plywood, but that didn't work. In 1978 however, Marks hit on the right thing and introduced heating oil futures - which was the jackpot gusher that led to 30 years of good times.


The oil scares following the Iranian revolution of 1979 led to an explosion of business interest and the original small market of heating oil futures begat natural gas futures, and then hit another jackpot with the creation of futures based on the price of West Texas Intermediate crude, now the US and Western hemisphere benchmark for a barrel of oil. The CFTC regulatory agency, at the time small and understaffed, nodded-through each new extension of instruments traded – and the number of market participants. The first big exemption the CFTC gave for widening market participants, allowing large multiple trades for a single financial player, went to Goldman Sachs in 1991. Others soon piled in.

Marks was soon dumped by the traders after he opened up the oil market, and by the early 1990s traders and their clients rode the frenzy in oil, right up to and over the precipice as speculative money, freed by exemptions, flooded in. Whenever the US Congress held an inquiry into “possible oil price manipulation”, they were each time ritually warned by the incumbent Nymex president about the dangers of  "substituting the judgment of Congress for the judgment of trained financial investment professionals."

Futures to Full-metal Financialization

The Nymex was bought out by  the Chicago Mercantile Exchange Group in 2008, which shut down its recently-started screen trading and shifted it to the OTC (over the counter) market for very short-term trades, as the Nymex became a brand name for a large range of financial futures and options, still including crude oil. By yet another irony in a long list of them, the OTC trading arena started out “gray” and very lightly regulated and became more so, while the Nymex, trading smaller volumes of oil as measured by lots traded each day, became a more-frequent target of regulatory attention. The former “pits” where human physical traders used open outcry trading, wearing strange-colored jackets or clown-like uniforms, in a daily show of frenzy were replaced by a small number of more-sober trading professionals, executing trades on laptops. As one finance journalist put it, its possible to feel nostalgic for the previous amoral furor of the pits where undereducated, drug-taking, frenzied greedheads who would "rip your heart out for a nickel," have disappeared and gone from the scene. At least they were human.

The point underlined by Goodman and other finance journalists and energy writers is that the Nymex morph from “hustling potatoes to rigging oil prices” took place in a certain era and ambiance. To be sure, each new scare on the global oil upstream was seamlessly transferred after suitable distortion and exaggeration, to pushing up oil prices. On occasions of course, to “spook the speculators” prices could be talked down by the daily maximum limit able to alert the regulators, for action after months of delay and usually very small fines for wrongdoing by the slightly-strengthened, more vigilant CFTC. 

The hinge period and game-changer was oil price rigging during the peak oil scare of around 2005-2008.

For Nymex oil traders, this was a “strange and complex theme” because it above all suggested oil demand would top-out, stagnate or decline. Which meant a threat of lower prices unless production fell even faster than demand.  The feeling was that peak oil would be bad for everybody, to be sure because there was no decent alternative for oil, but above all for traders because there was no reliable way of knowing exactly when the planet had reached the oil tipping point. In the meantime, guesses on peak oil could be used by brokers, bankers or traders to shout down prices, as much as gouging them up. The price volatility would be fine, for traders, but the uncertainty about oil would not be.

More finance-technical factors also played a leading role in the period of around 2005-2008. This was reflected by the vastly-rising amount and complexity of “bets on oil”. Via derivatives, the bets could easily throw in and include interest rates, government debt, currency values, mortgage buying and defaults, car sales, job data and any number of other “meaningful derived and related” instruments.

To be sure, there were and still are “oil fundamentals” including geopolitical risk, as well as supply-demand, stocks, oil tanker shipping demand and costs, and so on, but this was swamped by the high ground. In the 2005-08 hinge period, the US was fighting wars in two Middle East nations and drilling for oil in ever more hazardous ocean depths, the shale gas and oil revolutions were beginning, and at least until 2008, “unlimited growth” of Chinese and Indian oil demand looked plausible.

This was a Complex Paradigm. Even as late as 2011, as explained by Erika Olson in her book “Zero-Sum Game: The Rise of the World's Largest Derivatives Exchange”, recent-past Nymex chiefs including James Newsome were always ready to opine that they thought that oil prices would tend to run away on the upside due to peak oil, when it wasn't due to China. The complex paradigm was responded to by reformed “ex-coke head” traders by ever-more-complex financialized assets and tradable instruments.

These are by nature arcane themselves. However, when they are looked at the right way, from the right distance under the right light, with or without the coke they can seem like they reflected “the right market price for oil”.

The Rigged-out Market

By mid-2008 the Nymex was fully and totally rigged-out. Goldman Sachs had “goosed prices” to the limit, although with no surprise GS never admitted that it “goosed prices”. Any multi-hundred-million dollar fines it paid for the Sem Group affair and subsequent or related affairs, or unrelated affairs, were “with no admission of wrongdoing”.

Oil prices on the Nymex in 2008 hit $147 a barrel.

Ironically therefore, the end-result of full-blown financialization as also shown by for example the Man Group blowout at end-2011, and serial CFTC and FERC legal pursuit of the so-called “energy market maker banks” with ever-rising fines levied, is that the Nymex oil market of today is structurally rigged. The Nymex is unable to reflect “the right price” for oil.  For the moment the market playfield tilt is upward, oil has to be expensive because it is such a noble fluid and supplies are so limited. Peak oil has come and gone, but it left an oily dirt line around the empty bath.

This can be put another way. The complexity paradigm, triggered or favored by Peak Oil, led to ultra-opaque Nymex oil pricing with a general bias to extreme-high oil prices. The market size paradigm then baked-in the scum line around the bath. Bets riding on the traded price, today and every day, are so immense that daily price variation in percentage points can only move by fractions – usually upward - except under market disaster and financial panic conditions.

The bottom line is the market is “rigged out”. Probably the only thing which can make oil prices fall like they did in 2008-2009 (by about 73.5% or $147 to $39 from peak to trough) will be a repeat global stock market collapse. Nothing else.

By Andrew McKillop

Contact: xtran9@gmail.com

Former chief policy analyst, Division A Policy, DG XVII Energy, European Commission. Andrew McKillop Biographic Highlights

Co-author 'The Doomsday Machine', Palgrave Macmillan USA, 2012

Andrew McKillop has more than 30 years experience in the energy, economic and finance domains. Trained at London UK’s University College, he has had specially long experience of energy policy, project administration and the development and financing of alternate energy. This included his role of in-house Expert on Policy and Programming at the DG XVII-Energy of the European Commission, Director of Information of the OAPEC technology transfer subsidiary, AREC and researcher for UN agencies including the ILO.

© 2014 Copyright Andrew McKillop - All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisor.

Andrew McKillop Archive

© 2005-2018 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules